Relictivity said:Thanks for pointing that out :).
OK, first things first, you would agree that the user of evasion would have to be properly bulky, like a Gliscor, Skarm, Dusknoir, or whatever. It also should avoid being weak to fighting (hence why Umbreon, Heatran, and T-Tar would not do good jobs). The thing is with crits, if someone is using a pokemon with enough initial power, it's likley to 1HKO the pokemon, as it utterly avoids the stat-boosts and has double power. Thus, if you managed to land a crit on a pokemon using such, it would be gg, as most of those pokemon will be attempteing to do it with a supereffective, or at least neutrally effective move. With evasion, you have to worry less about these random crits as you have that extra chance to dodge them. Considering that you are using a defensive pokemon that has quite the bit of chance to survive one supereffective move, your pokemon still won't be taken down easily, even if the opponent hits.
I have to agree here. However, there are still common scenarios in which bulky pokemon can be OHKOed, excepting perhaps when talking about Ubers and Cresselia (the latter has near no offensive cabilites and even with +6 CM, she is walled by Blissey. For other bulky pokemon, Gliscor hates Ice Beam and even Ice Punch, Skarmory has Electric and Fire problems, Dusknoir hates Tyranitar and the list goes on.
Erm... please only Compare it to Cosmic Power. Only Cosmic Power protects you from both sides of the spectrum in one move slot. The most defensive use of Cosmic Power... is Claydol. The most powerful with a one spot recovery move is... Clefable (which actually is really good in doubles for Follow Me-ing if you get the Cosmic Powers up).
I agree though, it would be just as difficult to get +6 evasion as +6 Cosmic Power. However, I think the crits would make Cosmic Power to risky. About the type coverage though... have you ever thought about using moves that force them to switch on entry hazards, or what about running this during a Sandstorm. The entry hazards add up, and Double Team has quite a bit of PP (though most of it is useless). Imagine facing a whole team of double teamers, eventually, you would die of either running out of PP or switching on entry hazards too much (you cannot Heal because of Taunt).
I admit that Cosmic Power has very few good users. However, I think we can all agree that DT is most powerful when used with Baton Pass.
If the DT user manages to get +6 Evasion and has Taunt, what happens then? Sweeping attempts and residual damage will be just too hard to pull off. Entry hazards mean little against Wish, and Sandstorm is negated by Leftovers. Your DT + Taunt + Roar suggestion is ruined if Rapid Spin manages to hit the DT user, and that's a 50% chance after 3 DTs. Of course, this argument doesn't apply for Dusknoir, but as you said, he's a too slow Taunt user.
I agree, Dusknoir is a bit too slow for the ideal Taunt. Try looking for something a bit faster.
Strickly speaking, the best users of DT are bulky. EVing them in Speed will remove some of their bulk and make the challenge of pulling off +6 Evasion even harder. And even if they are EVed for speed, there will be still plenty of faster pokemon that can know Taunt.
Chimera said:Who can use Haze effectively? Haze beats stat ups, but it isnt seen in competitive play now where Dragon Dance, Swords Dance, Nasty Plot, and Curse are frequently seen. The current environment can't support much in the way of (p)hazing due to the speed of it.
Decent users of the move Haze are Vaporeon, Dragnoite, Tentacruel, Milotic, Weezing, Driflbim, Blastoise and Crobat. Should DT be introduced, Haze would become more common, for it is a 100% DT counter and is only beaten by Taunt. That is if the DT user can use Taunt in time. And which good DT users have the speed to do that? Or which DT users can afford to use Taunt on a Salamence, Tyranitar, Heatran, Lucario or Metagross switching in?
Then we have the fact that Sand Veil on Garchomp was one of the reasons people clamored for its banning (though not the only one, it was certainly brought up frequently), so it does say something when you can play a game right and lose due to a couple of Minimizes or Double Teams. Luck may not be dominant now, but a move that raises evasion only raises luck, so any percentage you have would shift with evasion moves.
Sand Veil wasn't the dominant reason for Garchomp's banning. Rather, it was that it was near guaranteed to net a KO each match thanks to Earthquake, Outrage, SD and Fire Fang with a Yache Berry to remove it's one key weakness.
Luck has always been dominant. Stone Edge with 80% accuracy (like a self Sand Veil effect) and a high crit chance is currently the 4th most common move and takes up 10.1% of moveslots. Fire Blast takes up 6.0% of moveslots.
Hipmonlee said:Any problems with the testing process arent relevant to this discussion. The fact is the suspect test process is the process we will use, and any flaws in it dont have any bearing on what should be tested.
Nobody is suggesting to test DT to shake things up. Or at least, nobody who knows anything about pokemon. I want to test DT because I think it is banned without good reason. Smogon's philosophy dictates that if that is the case, then something should be done to rectify that problem.
Have a nice day.
Agreed. This is the reason that Skymin is being tested again in the future and why we are not re-testing Garchomp.
Relictivity said:If the Evasion User is faster, and Taunts you, you lose. Really, the Evasion user has to have a good combo of Defenses and Speed, but there are some tanks that have this. And it is kind of pointless to run evasion without a Taunt, unless you're baton passing a Belly Drum, in which case one will do.
I am agreeing with Steeve here - Evasion is NOT COMPLETELY luck. You used a move to have a chance at dodging something, it's only right you get some reward, and that is other moves not being able to hit as much. So let's test it, though it probably will be to much. Because if there is at least SOME chance that the thing will be proved or disproved centralizing, than it is worth a test.
And SOME != a little.
I will agree that Evasion is not completely luck. But to say that if a DT user lands a Taunt, its gg, is complete rubbish when after 3 DTs, you still have a 50% chance of being hit by a move that can pose a OHKO threat.
On that topic, let's say a move will always 2HKO a pokemon, and that pokemon has no form of recovery. That pokemon has 1 DT up, is faster than the opponent, and the opponent has been Taunted. The pokemon will pull off another DT before having a 3/5 chance of being hit by that move (2/5 chance of miss). Next round, it will have a 50% chance of being it (3/6 chance of miss). Then it's 3/7, 3/8 and 3/9 chance of miss. There is a 4.76% chance of dodging all the attacks (2/5 x 3/6 x 4/7 x 5/8 x 6/9. The chance of dodging one attack is (3/5 x 3/6 x 4/7 x 5/8 x 6/9 + 2/5 x 3/6 x 4/7 x 5/8 x 6/9 + 2/5 x 3/6 x 3/7 x 5/8 x 6/9 + 2/5 x 3/6 x 4/7 x 3/8 x 6/9 + 2/5 x 3/6 x 4/7 x 5/8 x 3/9), which is a 20.7% of dodging one attack. The
chance of survival (being hit once or less) is
25.5%. So being Taunted against a DT user is far from gg.
Bon Jovi said:If evasion moves are allowed into the metagame, there will become 3 types of teams: evasion teams, evasion countering teams, and normal teams. Evasion>normal>counter>evasion and so forth, like a game of rocks paper scizors. Any pokemon that can use double team/minimize and taunt will become nearly unstoppable with luck on it's side. Bringing evasion into the metagame will make it more reliant on luck rather than skill. Therefore, I belive evasion should NOT be allowed.
EDIT: I do support the idea of testing it, so we can have proof on whether or not it is broken.
There is no way you would be able to predict this. And I doubt there would be a team solely dedicated to countering DT; it'll fail against every other type of team. Either normal teams would adjust themselves so they can handle DT better e.g. use No Guard Machamp, or they wouldn't change at all.
hhjj said:Still, wouldn't Bibarel be quite too powerful with the following set? Remember, it only takes 3 turns for max evasion, and it learns a +Defense move, so in accordance to the OP comparing Def, Sp Def VS Evasion, this Pokemon can take advantage of both.
Bibarel: @ Leftovers
Double-team
Super-fang
Curse / Taunt / Return
Waterfall
Bibarel with its pathetic speed is very prone to Taunt and Toxic, especially when it uses Curse. It's too slow to use Taunt effectively. With Return and without Curse, it's easy to wall - Skarmory, Rotom, Dusknoir, Forretress, Vaporeon, Suicune, Cresselia, Hippowdon (even with a weakness to water), Salamence with Roost (if Salamence doesn't have Roost, it'll have the power to OHKO Bibarel - this may still be the case if it has Roost), the list goes on. Finally, Bibarel is incredibly easy to OHKO with its 79/60/60 base HP/Def/SDef and is about as easy to KO as Medicham.