QibingZero said:The problem is, people take this way too far. Just because you can find ways to deal with a pokemon, that doesn't mean it's not broken. For instance, we're back on the topic of random Raikou 'counters' which die to a super effective HP again. Actually, it's worse than that, because most of the pokemon mentioned in this thread that supposedly can deal with Raikou actually do little for your team otherwise. Most of them can't even do anything worthwhile on the switch, let alone threaten or come in on any other pokemon regularly. At least pokemon like Steelix and Registeel are solid in other situations.
The point was that Raikou forced you to specialize against it. It was not as if you just had to keep it in mind when teambuilding - you had to make sure it was double covered. Even then, your team likely could still be swept by a certain Raikou set that maybe only a couple percent of people were running. You play the odds when you're forced to. Personally, I just used a more defensive Raikou against Raikou. That was one of the few ways my 'Raikou counter' could actually threaten something itself.
Well everybody has differing views on this subject, and I respect your opinion obviously. The main reason I'm not convinced that Railkou is broken is that it doesn't provide the immediate threat to put prepared teams that have their bases covered on the back foot in any way, though it comes alot closer than most to that kind of threat.
If it had access to something like Taunt or 101 HP Subs, or even a set that resembled formidable type coverage, that would possbly be enough to seal it for me, although naturally I'd have to see the effect in testing. As it stands though, Raikou has none of these, and that leaves such a wide variety of scope for dealing with it. I have personally never felt 'forced' to specialize against it. Not once. What I
have been forced to do is find ways to tweak the teams I create in order to provide adequate coverage against any problem Pokemon I notice whilst not compromising the synergy of the team. This sometimes includes Raikou, but is quite frankly just as likely to be any other threat, and IMO this is a normal part of the team-building process that every good player should be doing all the time.
What I'm ultimately saying is this. For te month or so that e have experienced with Raikou so far, I have yet to be convinced by its brokenness, therefore I cannot vote BL if voting were to happen today. I may well change my mind in the future, but it will require more testing for me no doubt. Unfortunately, I get the feeling that that won't happen, which will aggravate me a little, but hey, the system can't satisfy everyone, so if that happens I'll just brush it off and move on. What I blame the most really is the structure of the system itself. I've always asserted that 1-2 months is nowhere near enough time to form a solid opinion on all the suspects out there. Some, but not all.
QibingZero said:And yeah, you can run an anti-metagame team and be successful on the ladder. I don't think that's ever been doubted by anyone intelligent here. However, teams like that are generally regarded as 'gimmicky' for a reason - if your opponent knows what's coming, it won't work. For instance, when I was running Spikes Roserade in the first month after the merger, I was running only Sludge Bomb on it - no grass attack. Still, the threat of a grass attack was enough to get me a few free turns most battles. However, now that it's common to see defensive Roserade not using a grass attack, actually running one gives you immense payoff the second time it switches in. Most successful teams have a surprise or two like this, but we should really make sure to differentiate that from running a team of sub-par pokemon. Standards are standard for a reason, after all.
IMO playing with somewhat of an anti-metagame mentality is the only way to be consistently successful. You can't cover everything 100% anymore, so the best way to play is to try and cover your bases as broadly as possible whilst focusing on the common trends, and being prepared to consistently tweak your teams to account for these trends. And no, I've never felt that I've been having success with so-called 'sub-par' Pokemon just for the surprise factor at all. Non-standard =/= sub-par.