I've just got to say that I respect every single one of you.
except for Pikachu who is just pitiful
Pikachu hits hard, but kind of sucks.
And I thought I was going to have a silly debate about which pokemon is better.
Alan said:All the electric pokemon (except for Pikachu who is just pitiful) have their uses in NU. I use Manectric as no more than a trick scarfer. Luxray has the opportunity to be good, but its missing out on some key moves that put it into greatness. Electabuzz is good too, but really it can only run moves similar to its older brother so thats about it. Ampharos is good, (WHY AMPHAROS NO HAVE WOOL!?) but offensively speaking, its rather outclassed by everything in the tier (except for maybe SpecsAmphy), imo its uses are best served as a dual screener/supporter type pokemon.
Yeah I agree, Luxray's moveset is a joke. Thunder Fang as it's strongest Electric STAB move? Pitiful.
Electabuzz is best used as a Mixed sweeper.
(Manetric pulls off the specs set the best due to Switcheroo and Flamethrower/Overheat.)
Ampharos in theory can pull off a powerful Specs set, but it's utter lack of speed is really a shame.
As a sweeper, Ampharos is below Pikachu outside of Trick Room. Electabuzz's Defense is low, and in a tier where Sucker Punching Skuntank reigns, that's really quite bad.
Manectric is better than Raichu, IMO, because of Flamethrower. But, this is only comparing non-boosting sets, since Manectric's only option is the unreliable Charge Beam.
When it comes to boosting Electric-type sweepers, Raichu wins. Mostly because of lack of competition.
Apples and oranges.
A win is a win. :P.
Raichu and Manetric are both excellent pokemon to use in NU, and I agree they are similar to Apples and Oranges... So use them people!
Ampharos is the HARD hitting one with Specs (and that any Ampharos will be Modest natured). Also the only bulky one down here(Luxray too).
Ampharos is:
1- a Specs hard hitting poke
2-bulky status spreader/supporter.
Manectric is just like Jolteon: fast and hard hitting. Normally seen with Specs.
Raichu is the sweeper. Has a nice movepool. And can go physical.
Pikachu hits hard, but kind of sucks.
Electabuzz IMO is outclassed by Manectric on the special side, and Raichu from the physical side.
Luxray has the best mixed stats, so go for it. Also it's bulky with Intimidate.
Magneton has nice resists and Explosion when needed.
Electrode is FAST. You can even try a Charge Beam Electrode with a Modest nature and still outspeed everything without Scarf.
The only other plausible choice is Plusle, because of Plot Passing.
A nice summary and rundown of Electric pokemon. Thanks M-blade.
Hide
Gen 5 NEEDS to boost Eletric types. A good amount of them are NU, so I think stat boosts/movepool adjustments are in order. IE: Increase Raichu's stats, give E-buzz Calm Mind etc)