There are a couple of things to remember about NU. The small playerbase means that things shift far more dramatically - I (and a few others) started using Medicham as a lead, a couple of players caught on after Cham rampaged through their team, suddenly its usage has shot up. Magmortar usage has gone up 5% partly because Leman laddered hard to #1 with it in his team.
It's the sheer utility that Primeape gives you that m'akes it so good - scouting with U-Turn to damage and potentially trap Slowking, revenge-killing everything, cleaning up weakened teams after a wallbreaker like Medicham has put a colossal dent in their Quagsire/Sandslash... Note that Cham and Ape aren't counters to Miltank, but just physical attackers that aren't stopped cold by it. Expect Miltank usage to drop this month - I've panned it in favour of Gligar's better typing, access to U-Turn and ability to check Primeape (and to some extent Medicham).
Quagsire usage isn't rising because of Magmortar. LO Magmortar is the most common set and it runs HP Grass and outspeeds Quaggy. Quaggy usage is rising because it's a physical wall with reliable recovery that stops Primeape.
Slowking usage is so high because only a couple of special attackers - basically anything with an LO or Specs STAB Thunderbolt - can break through it. Unlike Primeape/Medicham beating Miltank on the physical side, though, these attackers don't have the versatility to fill several different roles. Also, depending on the choice of Hidden Power, they're walled by Quagsire or Gligar.
I think I can have a stab at explaining Espeon usage patterns. In January, Espeon was everywhere - despite not being legal for most of the month it was high on the usage list. However, once they realised how badly sets like Specs lost to Skuntank and how easily SubCM Espy was walled, they became disillusioned. In February, people were still experimenting, but the usage of Espy was down. In March, the popularisation of sets like Calm Mind + 3 Attacks meant that Espeon usage has recovered slightly.
Something I posted
in that stats thread:
Ice-eyes said:The other thing about Spikes in NU is that they free you up to use Sub + 3 attacks Espeon, combining the Skuntank-beating power of a Sub Espeon with the coverage of a three-attack variant. Spike support is necessary to 2HKO Slowking.
Floatzel is a very strong lead but it doesn't have the same team synergy as, say, Primeape or Medicham. Notice the popularisation of LeadCham, and Cham in general, during March - I have to admit playing a part in that.
Something to note is the fact that pokes that are high in usage are paired with other high-usage pokes a disproportionate amount of the time. Looking at the top five Miltank teammates:
1. Skuntank | 455 | 70.32 |
2. Slowking | 429 | 66.31 |
3. Primeape | 413 | 63.83 |
4. Medicham | 249 | 38.49 |
5. Espeon | 243 | 37.56 |
Compare to the top five pokes that aren't Miltank:
| 1 | Skuntank | 1228 | 44.98 |
| 2 | Slowking | 1082 | 39.63 |
| 3 | Primeape | 846 | 30.99 |
| 4 | Medicham | 713 | 26.12 |
| 6 | Espeon | 599 | 21.94 |
You'll notice that they're all the same, and in the same order, but all having increased in usage by a huge 20-30% percentage point margin. This reflects the fact that there is a larger rebellious deviation in NU - refusing to use top pokemon just for the sake of it - than in other tiers.
Incidentally, Medicham/Primeape/Slowking/Miltank/Skuntank/Espeon was a team I was using at one point.