It doesn't matter what you think of saves, when EVERY team in the league places a premium value on relievers who can effectively close out games. Like it or not, the save has become a desired trait in the current climate of the game and he's proven to be pretty effective in obtaining them. Also as I'm sure you're aware, they originally slated this guy to be a starter. If he got stretched out there's no telling how effective he can be in that role.
miss the point. a star closer is nowhere near in value to an ace starting pitcher. you could offer Riveria in his prime and you'd still need a ton more to acquire Felix. if Feliz can be converted into a good starter, it's a whole other story completely but right now, an "elite" closer is not worth anything compared to an elite SP.
Andrus is a bit of a work in progress, but he's only 22 years old. You think what he's accomplished at this point in his career is him reaching his peak?
i don't think Andrus is going to get that much better than he is now. that said, he's a 3 WAR (so far this season) SS, a really thin position.
Also I like how you glossed over Ogando when he's currently 10-4 with a sub-3.00 ERA in his FIRST SEASON. Not to mention the other pieces that you left out; which are still valuable no matter how much you'd want to bash/ignore them.
i hope you didn't just cite W/L as a stat to talk up a pitcher. and a sub 3 era looks great...but he's got an xFIP closer to 4. Ogando isn't this good but he's still a decent mid to back end starter.
Finally, I will steadily agree that Felix is one of the best pitchers in this age of pitching. But has he really had a historic career so far, as you put it? My vote is not, but to each their own.
he's already got a Cy Young and over a thousand strikeouts at age 25. he is coming off back to back amazing seasons. he is a ridiculously good pitcher signed to a very friendly contract given his performance. you don't trade Felix Hernandez for B players like Feliz, Andrus, and Ogando. conversely, if that deal gets it done for your team to acquire Felix, you pull the trigger. quickly. before someone tells the Seattle GM he just got swindled.
With what logic do you offer up this nugget of baseball knowledge? He's a good, young talent who hasn't even had that much time to offer much to form an opinion on his ceiling; he hasn't even pitched a full-season's worth of games yet! Please let me know what team you scout for to have this fantastic baseball insight.
he doesn't strike batters out, here or in the minors, doesn't show good control, and doesn't have any true plus pitches. he's a back end guy, especially in the AL East.