MrIndigo said:So you're saying pregnancy is a woman's punishment for having sex? Do you know what the word misogynist means?
No, the man is responsible too. Is it really wrong to want people to hold themselves accountable for their actions? You can't have sex and then get pregnant and then throw your hands up in the air like, "What can be done?" You are directly responsible for your situation in this instance.
MrIndigo said:You're mistaking "Never born" with "Dead". They are not the same thing. By the same logic, every time someone uses contraception and prevents a pregnancy, they just murdered the child that they would otherwise have had.
I addressed this. Sperm do not magically become babies. Ova do not magically become babies. By having sex you start a series of events that result in a baby. Yes, there's not instantly a baby, but that one action is what started the series of events. So to me a fetus is the same as a baby. @below where someone linked me to a thesaurus entry for fetus the notes say that fetus is the term for eight weeks until birth. So aborting a baby the day before delivery is okay because it is still just a fetus, right?
MrIndigo said:Because what you really believe in is emotional oppression of women. It is people who share your beliefs that try to make vulnerable women do what they tell them by trying to introduce laws that allow (or in some cases, mandate) emotional blackmail by (religious) counsellors.
Again, I'm not blaming a woman getting pregnant on the woman. It takes two. They both should be held equally responsible. And neither should have the option to abort.
MrIndigo said:They're also not advocating killing babies - they're advocating the arbortion of a foetus, that's the whole point. You're assuming your conclusion - a bundle of cells attached to the mother's bloodstream is not a baby, and neither would be, for instance, a leech surgically implanted in the womb.
No one has given me a reasonable explanation as to why there is somehow a difference.
MrIndigo said:No, it isn't. What? I don't even.
You said that by not allowing a woman an abortion after a rape I am inflicting a double penalty on the victim. I'm not inflicting anything on the woman. The rapist is.
MrIndigo said:It's not. If you define it any other way, (i.e. that killing a lump of sells is murder), then all cancer treatments are murder. In fact, every ejaculation is a genocide comparable to the holocaust because of the sheer number of sperm that die in so doing. In fact, doing anything at all to any cell carrying any human DNA (e.g. a single flake of skin) is murder.
Again. I didn't say that cancer treatments are murder. I didn't say that killing cells is murder. I didn't. I don't understand how you think I said that. I said that defining something as "not murder" because it is only destroying cells that couldn't live outside of the mother is insane. If you can't see the difference between these two statements you need to work on your reading comprehension.
Fishy LOVES DRAGONS OMG said:No it isn't. No birth control is 100% effective so by relying on it you are making the choice to have sex despite the fact that you could become pregnant.
abstinence is 100% effective, and you can always blow your load elsewhere besides within a vagina. there's a difference between having sex irresponsibly and just being ignorant about how to avoid impregnating a girl. it's NOT that difficult.
I know! That's what I'm saying. People act like, "You need to allow abortions because having a child in high school damages your future as well as the future of the baby!" My answer is to solve that through better sex education. I don't understand how we immediately jump to keeping abortion legal when there are much better ways to solve the same problems.
Because they are advocating killing babies! How is this hard to understand? I actually think that if abortion remains legal they should make the woman deliver the baby and then strangle it to death. That way they can appreciate the blood on their hands.
perhaps I'm being a pedantic asshole at this point, but here's a thesaurus entry for fetus so you can stop using fetus and baby interchangeably. and if you're going to propose such a disgusting and ridiculous idea, isn't less 'suffering' dealt if a woman aborts a fetus very early instead of strangling a newborn i mean i can't even coherently respond to this what is wrong with you.
Again. I see absolutely no difference. Your link even says that it is a fetus up to birth. Are you advocating aborting babies a day before birth? I am saying that I see no difference between an abortion and strangling a newborn. They are equally awful. The difference is that with abortions the parents (woman AND man) can pretend it was just some medical procedure and not murder. (As an aside there were remarks made as to me being a misogynist I can see how some of my comments can be construed that way. So in this example I'll say that the father can strangle the newborn if that is what the parents want.)
Except the rapist is the one who got the woman pregnant. That's like blaming me for someone both shooting and stabbing someone. If someone attacks me and I need a new heart can I kill a baby to take his? That's about the same as killing your baby because you were raped.
The rapist is to blaim because the woman being pregnant is directly his fault. blaming you for shooting and stabbing who now? maybe use less pronouns to make a coherent point. why should a woman be punished with a pregnancy she did not want because a man wanted to use her body for sex? are you insane? the fetus "should" have never existed in the first place, but only did because of the man's crime. how is that hard to understand?
I was saying that saying that it is inflicting a penalty on a rape victim by not letting her get an abortion is like if Tom shoots Bob and then stabs Bob and you blame Tom for the gun shot wounds but you blame society for the stab wounds. Also, who gets to decide whether a baby should have or should not have existed? And why should the baby be held responsible for its father's crime. Again, a woman becoming pregnant through rape is TRAGIC. I just don't think you remedy the situation by killing a baby.