Squidsauce said:The annoying part is that Crobat can't switch into heracross/roserade/mienshao because of stone edge, sleep powder, and stone edge. It also loses 25% to stealth rocks, which makes it prioritize roosting up over utilizing any potential offensive momentum.
That's why I really hesitate when I read that Crobat is a "fantastic anti-metagame" pokemon. U turn is great, but I think gligar does a better job as a pivot since it can switch into a higher variety of things and lose much less to SR.
However, Gligar lacks any sort of offensive presence. It also cannot switch in on Roserade, Shaymin, and Scrafty the way Crobat can. Crobat takes little, but it can dish out some damage back in return, and it has room for Taunt. Crobat's flaws are thoroughly mitigated by its qualities.
Flaws:
SR weakness
Dismal movepool
Qualities:
Checks half the damn meta
Great typing defensively
Roost
Squidsauce said:On another note, maybe these proposed changes can spur some discussions:
heracross--> suspect. no counters (swords dance facade beats gligar easily)
gligar B --> A. Counters nearly every physical attacker (can stall out fucking azumarill) and u turns out for momentum, sets up rocks, and is a dedicated physical wall
mienshao A --> S. HP ice/HJK/u turn/SE or Fakeout = hard to play around
chandelure A --> S. No snorlax or P2? Get fucked son
crobat S --> A. see previous comment
froslass A --> S. between taunt, destiny bond, and spikes.... good luck guessing what this beast will do. you'll find yourself playing 5-5 and with 2 spikes disadvantage. there's actually no way to beat this thing.
zapdos S --> A. can't sweep like raikou, gets hurt by rocks, forced to switch out often because of its speed. what's going for this thing? wallbreaking with life orb? i'm not buying S until it gets lightningrod
Heracross...It's up to the council and further discussion in the NP threat to warrant a suspect for it.
I do not agree with moving Gligar to A. While it is a good physical wall who can take on Heracross, it is also a big momentum killer thanks to its weak offensive presence. It also is vulnerable to special attackers. Still, Gligar is pretty decent for use in UU, but is not A-Rank worthy.
Mienshao for S was something I was just about ready to speak on. It's a great and modestly versatile Pokemon in the tier; it hits pretty damn hard, has a great speed tier, makes for a great mixed attacker. And the Scarf set is a solid revenge killer, and Jolly Scarf is literally the fastest thing in the tier. U-turn also allows it to keep up momentum and also escape from Cofagrigus. It also has SD and Baton Pass to do work too, and STAB Hi Jump Kick ain't nothin' to be trifled with. And plus,
everyone uses it. Good thing you mentioned it; I was just ready to speak on it. But then again, that's just what I think.
Chandelure was actually discussed on, although it is a fan fave of mine, here's
why it isn't S.
No for Crobat for reasons stated above.
I really am thinking Froslass should be S at this point. Let's be honest here: Froslass is the best spiker in the tier; it can Taunt, it is a speedy Spiker, its Cursed Body ability and Destiny Bond. It's a one trick pony, but it does its one job pretty damn well. You're not going to remove it without having some Spikes down, and heck one of your Pokemon removed from play.
This post explains as to why Zapdos is S-tier material.