Regarding E4 and Champion:
Before I get to my proposal, let's examine what we know regarding the e4 and champion ingame, in case anyone doesn't know this. Skip the next few paragraphs if you don't really care.
The elite four are four trainers who represent the best trainers in their regional league, other than the champion. They each fight with a mono-typed team, the types vary from generation to generation. The challenger must have all 8 gym badges in order to challenge the elite 4. The challenger must challenge and defeat all four of them consecutively in order to challenge the Champion. It is unclear how the elite 4 are decided.
The Champion is regarded as the best trainer in his/her regional league. After defeating the elite 4, the challenger can challenge the Champion. If the challenger defeats the standing Champion, the challenger will be added to the Hall of Fame and become the new Champion if they so chose. However, as N did in BW, the challenger can decline to become the Champion. They will still be added to the Hall of Fame. If there is no standing Champion when a challenger defeats the elite 4, the challenger will be added to the hall of fame with the team they defeated the last member of the elite 4 with.
The first thing I will talk about is how to decide the initial elite 4. I dislike Rediamond's method of holding a vote, as it exculdes people who are not gym leaders from becoming members of the elite 4, and there is never any mention of that happening in game. Additionally, the elite 4 should not reflect people's thoughts on who are the best battlers, but who actually are the best battlers. Therefore, I am of the opinion that the elite 4 should be decided by a mono-type tournament. The fourth-place winner would be challenged first, then the third, then the second, then the first. There would obviously have to be a third-place game. If a gym leader becomes a member of the e4, they would be able to keep their gym (see aops's post). No two e4 members can have the same type. If two of the top 4 finishers used the same type, priority is given to whoever finished higher; the lower finisher can either pick a new type or give their e4 spot to the 5th place finisher. The fifth place finisher is defined as whomever lost to the first place finisher.
Getting all 18 badges in order to challenge the e4 seems obnoxious and quite impossible to me, so I think we should go with the in-game precedent of 8 badges required to challenge the e4. They would have to be challenged in the order outlined in the above paragraph (unless we don't want to do any specific order for challenging). The first player to defeat all members of the elite four would be added to the hall of fame and become champion, etc etc etc as per ingame precedent. The e4 members are assumed to have beaten themselves, but have to beat the other 3.
Next comes the matter of e4 replacement. This can happen in two ways, both of which are resolved in the same manner. The e4 member can step down or the e4 member can be forced out. A monotype tournament will be held to replace him/her. If the e4 member becomes champion, he/she keeps his/her e4 spot and potential gym spot, if they have it.
If I missed anything ask about it I don't think I managed to cover everything but I did my best.
Edit: <Texas> that sounds like a lot of work
<Texas> for little benefit
<starwarsfan> i guess
<starwarsfan> idk it makes sense in theory but its so hard to do
Before I get to my proposal, let's examine what we know regarding the e4 and champion ingame, in case anyone doesn't know this. Skip the next few paragraphs if you don't really care.
The elite four are four trainers who represent the best trainers in their regional league, other than the champion. They each fight with a mono-typed team, the types vary from generation to generation. The challenger must have all 8 gym badges in order to challenge the elite 4. The challenger must challenge and defeat all four of them consecutively in order to challenge the Champion. It is unclear how the elite 4 are decided.
The Champion is regarded as the best trainer in his/her regional league. After defeating the elite 4, the challenger can challenge the Champion. If the challenger defeats the standing Champion, the challenger will be added to the Hall of Fame and become the new Champion if they so chose. However, as N did in BW, the challenger can decline to become the Champion. They will still be added to the Hall of Fame. If there is no standing Champion when a challenger defeats the elite 4, the challenger will be added to the hall of fame with the team they defeated the last member of the elite 4 with.
The first thing I will talk about is how to decide the initial elite 4. I dislike Rediamond's method of holding a vote, as it exculdes people who are not gym leaders from becoming members of the elite 4, and there is never any mention of that happening in game. Additionally, the elite 4 should not reflect people's thoughts on who are the best battlers, but who actually are the best battlers. Therefore, I am of the opinion that the elite 4 should be decided by a mono-type tournament. The fourth-place winner would be challenged first, then the third, then the second, then the first. There would obviously have to be a third-place game. If a gym leader becomes a member of the e4, they would be able to keep their gym (see aops's post). No two e4 members can have the same type. If two of the top 4 finishers used the same type, priority is given to whoever finished higher; the lower finisher can either pick a new type or give their e4 spot to the 5th place finisher. The fifth place finisher is defined as whomever lost to the first place finisher.
Getting all 18 badges in order to challenge the e4 seems obnoxious and quite impossible to me, so I think we should go with the in-game precedent of 8 badges required to challenge the e4. They would have to be challenged in the order outlined in the above paragraph (unless we don't want to do any specific order for challenging). The first player to defeat all members of the elite four would be added to the hall of fame and become champion, etc etc etc as per ingame precedent. The e4 members are assumed to have beaten themselves, but have to beat the other 3.
Next comes the matter of e4 replacement. This can happen in two ways, both of which are resolved in the same manner. The e4 member can step down or the e4 member can be forced out. A monotype tournament will be held to replace him/her. If the e4 member becomes champion, he/she keeps his/her e4 spot and potential gym spot, if they have it.
If I missed anything ask about it I don't think I managed to cover everything but I did my best.
Edit: <Texas> that sounds like a lot of work
<Texas> for little benefit
<starwarsfan> i guess
<starwarsfan> idk it makes sense in theory but its so hard to do
Last edited: