Nysyr said:We currently have no compex bans in This gen, and I'm fairly sure they aren't looking to implement another. Banning speedboost, Batonpass, or Magic bounce as a whole are the 3 options they will most highly consider. Getting rid of Speedboost is the simplest way to nerf Baton pass.
So I have no idea where you got the "not how we do things" part of that. 5th gen Drizzleswim ban was an exception among exceptions.
Where did I give the impression that I thought a complex ban was needed? What I actually think needs to happen is a ban of Scolipede, because it's his support that breaks BP (I think we agree on that).
Ninjask isn't broken, and let's not pretend there's anything wrong with Yanmega or Sharpedo. As far as I know, abilities CAN'T be broken, only pokemon and pokemon combinations.
And don't even bring up "Drizzleswim," because rain in gen 5 is undeniably one of the worst things to happen to competitive battling
BenTheDemon said:I think that Espeon (more specifically Magic Bounce) is what breaks Baton Pass. It prevents Taunt, phasing (even Dragon Tail and Circle Throw because Espeon always carries Substitute.), and status. Mix in a few Speed Boosts and Iron Defenses from Scolipede, and you're essentially fucked. All you can really do at that point is pray for a really strong critical hit. Even then, it needs to be a Powerhouse to break Espeon's defensive EVs.
So my ideal solution would be to ban Baton Pass + Magic Bounce, so that Baton Pass can still be used but without Magic Bounce to mitigate its counters.
I personally do not think that Speed Boost alone breaks Baton Pass, since there's nothing really that's unstoppable after a few Speed Boosts. It can also be stopped easily with phasing.
Read this post:
Kairyu_Gen1 said:[By banning Espeon] you didn't fix the root problem of it [Baton Pass] being match-up based at all, just made it weaker to more match-ups. That's ok if that's what you wanted, but I don't think that should be the goal of any ban
I'm open to reasons why I'm wrong, but I don't think I am
Edit:
Thank you whoever deleted that terrible post after mine.
tennisedit: you're welcome