Ztest said:Hello I just wanted to disagree with your points on team synergy and boosting. I personally don't think too much about flare, I do think you make a great point about Drifbloom.
That said, I think special types have the most busted boosting as opposed to what you said. Yes, special attackers are heavily under represented but that has nothing to do with lack of boosting or team synergy. There are way less special abusers but that is intrinsically how this gen was given to us so nothing can be done there. We unfortunately only have a handful of special mons to play with in any meta. However, the access to Nasty Plot is widespread, basically every viable mon gets it.
You are saying that having to run a physical attacker for the ability on your special mon ruins team synergy, but I strongly disagree. I think that's exactly what defines synergy. Here are some examples:
Crawdaunt + Togekiss
Hydreigon + Steelix
Darmanitan + Gengar
Roserade + Cloyster
Togekiss + Drapion
Golurk + Rotom
Any of these easily fit on any team and sacrifice zero synergy.
That's not even touching on Polteageist, which can make a team of 5 physicals and 1 tea really scary.
Again, I am not disagreeing at all with your original ban argument, but rather I hope to help it by being more concise and demonstrating that there are only a handful of viable special mons to begin with; and that the ban further restrained them. I think that is a much better argument to make, Flare does open up a lot of special attackers when they had their hands tied to begin with.
You make reasonable points. My main point was to seperate the viability of flare boost from guts. And therefore special vs physical teams. As i suspect the ban on guts/problem with quick feet is the real reason flare boost received a ban (As it was wrongly categorised as the equivalent). Besides my own team which i posted here, i had not seen a Drifbloom in 60+ games, and my team is walled by a lot of stall teams.
Special teams definitely don't have the most busted boosting and i haven't been swept/threatened by a special attacker in this game since contrary was banned. Swords dance/dragon dance are quite widespread too. You often have to choose between abuser or ability on special teams, whilst physical teams get both (I'm thinking Crawdaunt, Darm, Conk, hustle users, no guard users, skill link users, etc there's so many powerful mons with great abilities, one turn set up etc), and access better moves (special have higher power generally but at cost of accuracy, which if you want to fix, will require a physical attacker for No guard)
This isn't extensive, but i did a comparison of special vs physical attackers.
Top 25 special attackers: ending with Salazzle at a 111 Spa Att base stat. (All others 110 or below)
5 break the 100 speed base stat, 13 beat base 80 (will outspeed things like Zeroura and Dragapult at +1/scarf)
Viable offence ability boosters: Analytic ( beeyehem), weak armour (Poltergeist), Punk Rock (Toxtricity), Technician (Roserade, Not viable for many special attacks), liquid voice (Primarena, serene grace/super luck, beserk? - i mention the pokemon because most aren't that fantastic options for breakers/offence in this meta.
Special priority users: 1 (Lucario)
Top 25 physical attackers: Ending with Gallispod at 125 Att base stat.
The top 25 have lower average speed tiers, but since there's literally double the amount of pokemon above base 111 Att, you end up with more + the fastest viable pokemon in Dragapult/Zeroura.
Boosters: reckless, guts, iron fist, sheer force, sand force, scrappy, Steelworker, no guard, swift swim, slush rush, sand rush, defiant, moxie. + The users above 110 att: grassy terrain, adaptability, queenly majesty, prankster, Infiltrator/clear body, super luck, strong jaw + a range of already banned abilities/combos for weather, mold breaker, unburden etc. + The majority of these abilities are listed at least twice on different pokemon, giving you more lenient team building.
Priority users: 12
Hell queenly majesty is viable on every single team purely based on the broken amount of priority, insane attack stats/boosters and therefore physical teams + prankster
Not really arguing against you, just adding information to my point/your point.