smellslikememe said:This is going to come very late as I've been busy for most of this weekend, but I'd like to get some of the community's thoughts on the following quickbans or suspects.
How will we handle:
Strong evolvers?
Frosmoth/Ice Scales?
Other extremely versatile/powerful evolutions?
Obviously, there are plenty of other Pokemon in this metagame in particular that might be worth mentioning, but these are the obvious offenders that are mentioned the most often. Will we go about suspecting individual Pokemon or mass quickban anything "broken"? Which evolvers or evolutions constitute a serious problem, and where do we cut the line between healthy and unhealthy centralization? Much of this is open to discussion, and although I've seen a few opinions in this thread as well as talk on main, I'd prefer to get some more input before I and
anaconja come to a decision.
addendum: would like to see how many people want to qb moody since that shits just not fun lmao
Scyther: Of the big two (Sneasel and Scyther), the mantis is the bigger problem. While both share stellar attack and speed and Swords Dance, Scyther differentiates itself with better defenses paired with options like Roost, Defog, and U-turn, making it a much harder to beat and giving it better natural team support. This means that its best offensive sets (especially Gyarados, Urshifu, and Hitmontop/Toxtricity) are not only extremely powerful but very hard to kill. It's so strong and fast you need to attack it using defensive mons, which can't take it out immediately, so Scyther just heals up again or boosts its stats. If you actually do have a good switch-in it can just pivot away, weakening your check in the process. It has Agility, and if you knock off its HDB it's still immune to Sticky Web, so it's hard to reliably outspeed it even with Choice Scarfers. Unlike Sneasel, it isn't weak to common priority (yes in theory Accelrock exists but that is so limited that it is just not comparable to Mach Punch). And then to top it off, the above options allows it to throw curveballs in the form of defensive or support sets. I've seen an effective Umbreon variant for crying out loud. It's a super badass looking pokemon and I wish I could see it stay, but the unfortunate reality is that it's probably broken.
Sneasel: I actually think that the majority of Sneasel sets are acceptable in the current meta, or even healthy, as it is a great check against many would-be indomitable stall mons. It lacks natural speed boosting options and has enough weaknesses that it isn't hard to take out with a Scarfer, Sticky Web support, or Zacian, it can be chipped down more easily by defensive mons, and then Mach Punch is common enough to be a reasonable counter strategy. There is one notable exception: Sneasel * Hitmontop. This thing's Beat Up and Triple Axle are strong enough that they beat things that should otherwise be able to stand up to it, such as Bulky Waters. The fact that this variant also gets its own Mach Punch from Top means that priority is no longer a reliable option against this version. Unfortunately, banning one variant is not doable, and banning Hitmontop evos would deprive other mons of reasonable Hitmontop sets. It's a shame, but this variant alone may be responsible for a ban. Then again, since this is just one very threatening variation, perhaps it's possible that we can put our collective minds together to design some perfect counters it. Maybe some extra time would be nice.
Corsola-G: Not mentioned above, but if Sneasel gets banned, this does need to go. Right now it's balanced because Sneasel keeps it in check, but even with all the Sneasel it can still put in serious work and is very hard for others to reliably take out. Maybe I'm just uncreative, but I personally depend on Flash Fire Sneasel for defeating Corosla (and even then some anti-Sneasel Corsola sets like Dubwool can ruin the plans). Ban it if Sneasel goes, leave it if it doesn't.
Frosmoth/Ice Scales: Frosmoth without Ice Scales is totally fine. Ice Scales itself may be busted. I've admittedly had less trouble with it than the others since my teams are mostly physical, but I could support an Ice Scales ban.
Chansey/Milotic/Gyarados: The two sea serpents are fine, but Chansey may be a problem. It single handedly allows almost anything to be a Wish Passer. If we lose it, we'll still have other great pokemon that can perform the act so it's not like we'd miss out on the archetype. Again, I don't think it's a problem at the moment, but if Scyther and/or Sneasel leave then that could change.
Moody: Yes please ban it, it's stupid.
On another note, I'll share a team I've been having pretty good success with. It's not perfect, leveling off in the high 1300s on the ladder, that's still good enough to peak at #9 and it's a lot of fun. It's a balance team that makes use of Sticky Webs and pivoting moves.
https://pokepast.es/0992caa0c9ff6b14
Team Description
:Carvanha: Carvanha is almost always my lead. Most of the time you click Flip Turn which, with Technician and 150 Atk, is just about the strongest pivoting move you'll ever get--a stronger Liquidation that gives momentum. Later in the match, I try to get it in safely with Lickitung's slow Flip Turn, and then I repeat the process. In tight matches Carvanha is also my final player as well, for it's also a great revenge killer--Mach Punch is for Sneasel and Aqua Jet is for most other things. I honestly hardly ever use Bite--may try Facade in case it ever gets burned.
:Swirlix:Swirlix and Lickitung are my two defensive pokemon, making them the main things I switch in or pivot into. Swirlix is amazing at coming in on powerful Fighting, Bug, and Dark attacks from the likes of Gallade, Scyther, and Urshifu variants, making it a great partner to Sneasel, who hates the first two. After tempering the opponent with Intimidate, it can easily set Sticky Webs or Heal Bell its teammates. Taunt stops stall or runaway sweeping attempts (though it's slow so the opponent often gets one status move it).
:Lickitung:Lickitung is an amazing Wish Passer that does respectable damage and spread burns with Scald. Sneasel, Zacian, and Swirlix are especially appreciative of the Wishes. Carvanha and Magneton--the more hit-and-go mons--love that Lickitung's slow Flip Turn allows them to get in safely to do pivoting of their own. Licktitung is slow enough that it is still outsped by most mons even with Sticky Webs up.
:Zacian-Crowned:Zacian-C has it all--great natural speed, sky-high attack, and good defense--making it the offensive mon that is easiest to switch in and the one who is most capable of committing a sweep if webs aren't up. Substitute is to stop it from being complete Will-o-Wisp/Strength Sap bait to Corsola, but even Zacian isn't strong enough to break it behind the sub, so once it's broken it needs to switch to my Corsola destroyer.
:Sneasel:Sneasel*Centiskorch is custom-designed to be able to beat the most common Corsola variants. Swords Dance lets its attack outpace the Strength Sap drops, it is immune to Will-o-Wisp, and Fire Lash is a fantastic move for softening Corsola before finishing it with a full-power Knock Off. Remember that it's not immune to Scald burns and that Milotic Corsola's Shadow Balls can still wear it down, and it can be outsped, so the healing, cleric, and web support from Swirlix and Licking are valued to let it reach its full potential.
:Magneton:My special attacker. Like Sneasel, Magneton can be outsped (even more easily) and like Carvanha, it is frail, so Magneton really loves the web support. But once that's set up and it's gotten in safely, Magneton is a beast. Accurate Sleep Powder lets it incapacitate most things that it can't OHKO save for Tangela & Ferroseed cross-evos, and it then fires away it's high-powered STAB moves or pivots with Volt Switch.