Volt-Ikazuchi said:This would fit better in the "Unpopular Opinions" thread, but since it's a topic here rn...
The Type-Based Gyms aren't the problem. The lack of strategy associated with them are.
You can absolutely build a monotype team and have some interesting cover for their inevitable weakness and this is part of being a specialist instead of a generalist.
Viola is a great example of a good Gym Battle that actually employs some strategy, especially for early-game.
Meanwhile, in the same game, Korrina is an example of the absolute worst a type specialist can produce and the reason why people want them done with.
I think there is a danger with this mentality that could end up with Gym Leaders who don't just use pseudo-legends and Darmanitar-Galar being seen as "let-downs" and not enough of a challenge. Competitive viability
should matter less in-game, where the focus should more so be on giving a wide variety of Pokémon positive exposure. Though this is with the caveat that if Game Freak finally just introduces difficulty settings to the game like literally everybody wants them to do -- part of the charm of Pokémon is replayability so even casual fans will appreciate this -- then they can throw a broken Pokémon onto a leader's team and it'd be fine.
But of course, the current system doesn't fulfil that either. The move to have gym leaders only use 4 Pokémon max in recent instalments is directly contradictory with having gym leaders show off a wide variety of Pokémon. Though even older games have trainers like Jasmine spamming Magnemite and Misty using Staryu and its evolution Starmie as opposed to any other Water-Type family. Thinking about it, this is perhaps a small part of the appeal of the Sinnoh and Unova games. Each region only has one trainer who doubles up on an evolutionary line -- Candice uses Snover and Abomasnow in DP because they were the only Ice-Type Pokémon alongside Sneasel (lmao sad) and she was already using Medicham as another option, and Burgh uses Swadloon and Leavanny in B2W2 because Roxie took Whirlipede (but they should've just given him a Larvesta or something honestly) -- so each gym battle does feel a little more interesting in that way. Every Pokémon your opponent uses seeming really different I think does genuinely add to the
feeling of challenge, even if it's not actually more challenging.
Others have said this before, but I do think the most logical and arguably easiest way to innovate the gym challenge is to use archetypal teams instead of type-themed ones, at least later in the game. Raihan did this with weather theming his teams which was really cool, but there are still Trick Room, Terrain, even Wonder Room to play with. And just as Tate & Liza did in Hoenn by randomly throwing a double battle in there, ditched concepts like inverse, rotation, horde, and triple battles could be neat too. Hell, throw in a tag battle gym where you fight alongside your rival! One key thing that this does is actually facilitates what I talked about before, where bosses should show off a wide variety of Pokémon. A Trick Room trainer using Marowak and Escavalier is demonstrating these Pokémon at their best where otherwise they often would just get outsped and KOed with a super-effective move. Beartic and Armaldo suddenly become terrifying sweepers in rain, and add to the type diversity of a rain team to boot.
There's definitely potential that's not being met with the gym challenge right now, but imo Alola went wayyyy too far in the other direction with Totem Battles. Honestly, in a region with diverse gym challenges like inverse battles and Trick Room teams, throwing a Totem battle in for one of the gyms would be neat in its own right. There's a middle-ground between Alola (which, ironically, still felt a little samey with its Totem battles by the end of the game -- what's needed is diversity within a single entry as opposed to just being different from prior games in the series) and where we're at now where each gym is just a type-themed singles battle.