DreamPrince said:Fun Fact: In Gen 7, the Slush Rush Ability was the only ability introduced that was not a Signature Abillity. ( Not counting Beast Boost since it is exclusive to UBs ) And in Gen 8, All the abillities introduced are signature abilities. I wonder if the designers wanted to give each Pokemon a competitive niche and the easiest way was do it was to give it an ability that no other Pokemon had probably so they don't have to give them an alternate form in the future. Corrision for example, will always give Salazzle a niche as a Toxic Spreader even in the lowest tiers, but if they gave it to Vileplume, Salazzle is now outclassed; which is probably why they haven’t given old Pokémon new abilities.
Truth is, if Vileplume got Corrosion, Vileplume wouldn’t really outclass Salazzle so much as rather, they simply compete with their upsides and downsides. Salazzle is faster and can set up with Nasty Plot, whereas Vileplume, while able to now bypass the struggle against Steel-type, would rather utilize Chlorophyll and Weather Ball since it got a low Speed to deal with.
That’s at least understandable for Abilities when it comes to signature, but the execution isn’t consistent. If anything, it actually make some worse about it because without the gimmick, chances that no one would genuinely uses those even in the lowest tier.
And even then, a signature Ability does not guaranteed keeping the Pokémon from lingering in the ZU tier. Aside of the issues with Morpeko and Eiscue I mentioned earlier despite their unique Ability (or perhaps
because of their unique Ability), there some more issues with signature abilities.
:ss/stonjourner:
Power Spot is a potential for Doubles, but consider Stonjourner’s horrid Special Defense and 70-ish Speed (too slow yet too fast for Trick Room teams), and how weak Power Spot actually is in practice, leave very few spots for it in competitive team. It also arrived way too late even before it can be used in Galar’s Double-themed Dragon-type gym, either, so the potential is completely missed.
:ss/cursola:
Cursola’s Perish Body sounds like something that could pressure a switch or even a malicious “taking you with me” if managing to somehow trap it… except it activate through the enemy’s contact. That is not a major problem, except the fact that Cursola’s physical bulk is very bad (60 HP / 50 Def), making not much better than Weak Armor for it.
:ss/flapple: +
:ss/appletun:
Ripen sounds very powerful, though Dragon / Grass is not something ideal to tank a hit, especially not when Ice remained a strong offensive typing. Don’t forget the whole Knock Off shenanigans - if they lose their Berry, the Ability become null.
:ss/frosmoth:
Now, Ice Scales is a good concept, a Special counterpart to Fur Coat. It’s moreso Frosmoth itself that needs serious fixing. If you know the problem with Ice-type Pokémon in general, you’ll understand if you check out Frosmoth’s stat distribution.
Notice all are from Galar. It worked for very few like Corviknight’s Mirror Armor and (controversially) Cinderace’s Libero, but when Galar have about 40% of their Pokémon lingering in PU or ZU, there’s something really wrong.