(Quick disclaimer: I originally planned for a much longer post with more issues mentioned, but I'm not gonna have the will to finish that post so I've shortened it to a post about two mons. If there's any sentence that's completely out of place in the text, it was probably something from the old post that I didn't catch in the edit, sorry in advance if that happens)
With the Home meta coming to a close in a few days, I wanted to talk about a topic that has been bothering me for a while with this metagame - the addition of two uniquely strong Spikers. It's no secret that removal is a tough task in this metagame especially with the lack of options, but instead of focusing on Spikes itself as a move (one that will probably never face any sort of tiering action), I felt it was better to talk about why these two mons are so different to the rest of the pack.
Ting-Lu
To help me get started on why I've singled out Ting-Lu here, I'd like to focus on something Finch said in the Tera thread:
"I find Ting Lu stack management to be an interesting feature of the metagame and it makes finding openings and generating momentum to force switches an important skill akin to BW spikes patterns. I don’t think any of that is an imminent issue." - Finch, 2023
In short, I disagree with this statement in a few ways, but it does remind me of a more optimistic time of building, before the last few rounds of WCOP and OLT. Over the course of the Home meta, I've built a lot of teams that intend to compensate for weak removal options by piling offensive pressure onto setters, Ting-Lu in particular being one of them. After trying this type of strategy a lot, I eventually realised that even with so much focus on adapting to Ting-Lu's defensive profile, I'd still find Ting-Lu to be one of the most likely pokemon I'd struggle with on matchup. Typically what would happen is that you'd reach a point in the builder where you realise that a couple of your mons can either barely touch Ting-Lu AT ALL, or they can only "cripple" it with status, in which time the Lu just went and put up all the hazards for easy value. After that, you'd look to compensate for the weakness in game by giving the Lu less time to operate (i.e. going into something that hits it hard as it sets hazards). This usually creates a catch 22 for the player against Ting-Lu - rushing the strongest breakers in to trade HP with the Ting-Lu can be a risky play long-term, but sitting back and allowing hazards is also a risky play. Often in these situations, the Ting-Lu can both take the hazards and the chip because lol imagine OHKOing a Ting-Lu. On top of this, its practical typing and ridiculous bulk means that chopping half of Lu's HP is nowhere near as punishing as you'd expect it to be - this doesn't open up Zapdos, or Glowking, or Specs Shadow Ball.
Throughout all of these sequences, one thing usually remains true - you have to predict the Ting-Lu several more times than it has to predict anything you're doing. If your opponent wants to take 60 from Valiant because they cant be bothered to figure out a way to switch around it, there's a good chance they haven't even put themselves in the mud by doing so. It's often very difficult to tell whether your low ladder opponent is leaving Ting-Lu in on everything with a plan in mind, or whether they're just doing it because they can - either way, from your side it really does feel like you can't ever predict a Ting-Lu to switch out, unless there's a case where Ting-Lu just can't do anything worthwhile back. I don't think these traits are the mark of a nuanced pokemon - ultimately, having a pokemon that takes somewhere between almost nothing and ~60 percent from the ENTIRE metagame, while being able to make progress itself every time it does get a free turn is already pretty crazy. The fact that most of the 1400s I have come across can emulate the plays needed to do this (because they're easy) is possibly a bad sign.
So, if trying to push through Ting-Lu as quickly as possible isn't the right idea, what do the good players do vs Ting-Lu nowadays? The simple answer is to never have a below average matchup against Spikes. Out of the teams commonly brought on OLT high ladder in the last few weeks (teams brought by multiple OLT players), we have:
Samu Lando Bootspams (BOOTS)
Stall (6 Boots)
Various Nat balances (all of these have plenty of Boots and Levitators)
Vert Sun (Sun is the only weather/"cheese" playstyle that can carry two Spinners, one of which is a Speed Boosting Tusk)
Notably, pretty much any other type of offense (like the anti-Court Change HO, Shocks Wake HO etc) started to suffer the longer OLT went on. This isn't only down to the Ting-Lu matchup, but the amount of HO win conditions that just dont get past basic fat + speed control cores is getting really high. Between Ting-Lu/Dozo/Birds/Gking and then the priority users like Gambit/Dnite, you can have such a high portion of "top" threats in the meta hard-walled, with a lot of the frailer options being pretty unviable due to how strong prio is. The only mons that seem to escape this decently are the brokens (Val/Bax/Gambit/Ghold) and some slow, frail mons that you'd never want to use over the brokens. I think that this is partially why a lot of offense players are resistant to the idea of banning the top tier offensive mons - they recognize from their own building that there's just not a whole lot out there that can dent the current crop of fat mons. Again, this isn't exclusively a Lu issue, BUT if we ever do get to the point where we start tackling the broken offensive mons and looking at the fat cores, Ting-Lu should probably be first on the chopping block, since it's not a truly passive mon like Dondozo and its Spikes have a major impact on teambuilding across the board.
I've focused a lot on the meta implications of Ting-Lu's ridiculous bulk so far, but really everything in the above paragraphs is meant to convey one thing - the best competitive strategies require you to assume you're dealing with multiple layers of Spikes every single time you build in this meta. Now, I'd like to quickly talk about the ways people try to deal with hazards in this metagame:
Cinderace can use Court Change to deter excessive hazard setting, but it doesn't directly come in on Ting-Lu so there's often progress to be made in getting up one (1) hazard, or simply using Ting-Lu's attacks to force certain plays. Also, Cinderace basically always needs a Tusk to accompany it for removal, otherwise 6 boots super fats or 6 boots stalls will likely try to beat your team by repeatedly setting hazards until they're up on both sides.
Bootspam with a solid Knock absorber allows you to play a lot more calmly vs Ting-Lu since you can afford to waste turns. This is a pretty common metagame approach and well-proven, but these structures don't have that many variants since it's not so easy to cover every threat without much item freedom (things like bulky NP Gholdengo often punish these teams due to the lack of initial power).
Speed booster elephants (Tusk/Treads) can be used on offensive styles as a way to execute the "punish the Spiker, spin in the middlegame and win" plan. Again, these cant fit on every type of team, but there are some good team options in this style. Vert sun also fits under this category since the Tusk is speed boosting.
Hatterene is a somewhat risky and low usage option that can help with Spikes matchups. However, Hat becomes pretty awkward to use if it ever comes in on a Ting-Lu Ruination (it needs its hp), can be punished by more offensive variants of Ting-Lu (Heavy Slam), and doesn't block Samurott's hazards or Cinderace's Court Change (unless you want to play hazardless which is always risky imo). All of these factors point to Hatterene ideally being used with an actual hazard remover.
Defensive Tusk as sole hazard removal is something I see a lot in ladder and tours, and I don't think it is favoured whatsoever when interacting with Spikes teams. Once you identify that Tusk is the only hazard removal and that there isnt a large portion of Boots mons on the team, the Tusk becomes easy pickings in a few different ways. The simplest of these methods is to just Tera Ghost your Lu or Gholdengo, but it's worth explaining that defensive Tusk just doesn't interact with the Ghost types well enough to win the hazard interactions more than like 20 percent of the time. Something I've considered to be a staple on every variant of Gholdengo is having at least 88 hp EVs (or 60 def EVs) as this ensures you always live an EQ from defensive Tusk. This means def Tusk always needs to predict the Gholdengo at least twice, even in a best case scenario where I just choose to throw it out. Typically it's very hard for Tusk to get three switchins vs a Spikes teams, since it doesn't switch directly in on a lot of threats that Spikes teams carry, and often will have to interact with a Ting-Lu Ruination first before even getting into any of the 50/50s. Speedy Tusk can solve some of these issues, but it's still pretty poor in these situations when you factor in the fact that it usually needs to correctly predict two turns to get to a point where it can spin the NEXT TIME it comes in - and of course it still loses to Tera Ghost as well.
In summary,
Cinderace and Hatterene (especially Cind) want to be paired with Tusk, which is a pretty large team commitment.
The most splashable Tusk set is a terrible solo remover.
The result of this is a deceptively small pool of teams that can handle Spikes in the current metagame, which forces me to question whether Ting-Lu stack is a healthy style for the meta in the long run. Obviously, much of this will depend on what our DLC options look like in terms of hazard immunities and hazard removal, but the current situation is very not good imo, speaking as someone who brought Spikes to 13 consecutive competitive matches in this tier (and about 70 percent of my comp matches total).
Samurott-Hisui
Hrott forms the other half of my issues with Spikes in the current metagame. Samu's Ceaseless Edge feels a lot harder to deal with your average offensive Spiker due to a few interactions, including:
- Being able to fit with extra coverage or utility options that can dramatically improve its usefulness outside of Spikes
- Bypassing Hatterene
- Creating free chances to get up Spikes vs mons like Gking
- Forcing defensive mons to Recover, buying you more time to get up multiple layers
Samurott is also just super well-positioned to threaten the entire meta, with its water STAB hitting almost every common mon that wants to come in on Ceaseless Edge (barring Zapdos). In particular, going into mons like defensive Lando or Tusk can swing between being the best option on the field if your opponent clicks Ceaseless, to one of the worst options on the field if they SD instead. This type of uncertainty heavily encourages players to deal with Spikes from a full scale teambuilding perspective, rather than a playing perspective (similar to Ting-Lu).
Another aspect of Samu-H that I find pretty annoying to deal with is the types of teams it is commonly used on. Samu-H glues together the common style of Boots spam + Helmet Lando-T, providing it an easy catch all progress-maker that can run Boots easily. These teams can usually get away with having a lot of walls to common threats (Zapdos Gking cores etc) and even failsafe options like Fairy Gambit, and as such they are some of the easiest teams to pilot "decently" at a high level. Due to the limitations placed on the metagame with poor removal options, it's pretty hard to find a way to consistently skill gap weaker players using these teams. Usually, the nature of the metagame will force you to engage the Boots spam teams with a largely similar style, and in many cases where the style matchup is so symmetrical, small mon changes can make a huge difference. For example, there was a point in OLT Cycle 4 where the top ranked player at the time (leng loi) sniped the second ranked player (Kebab) while both players were using Samu Lando-T bootspam teams. After
winning the game, leng loi explained in the OLT chat that the reason she decided to load a game then was because Kebab's team was "super weak to NP Ghold". To me this begs the question - how do you consistently win a mirror style matchup (regardless of how good you are), if the adaptations within that style essentially lead to some mons being way more unkillable than everything else in the game. If both players are playing full on Spikes + Boots and one player also has a mon that is pretty close to winning the game on its own, then the natural response for a very good player would be to try and avoid the style altogether (even though it is overall a great style). This is an issue that I've been running into a lot in the builder - I feel like I'm forced to experiment so that I can actually make use of the knowledge gap, but any experimentation may just lead to using something outright worse in the meta because the parameters of what actually works are so limited. Although I don't think that this situation is close to egregious enough to warrant tiering action, this type of thing lowers my opinion of the generation a lot - having one of the most reliable styles also be one of the most clicky is never an ideal situation imo, and this gets even worse if there's a very limited pool of reliable styles in the first place.
Like I said at the start of this post, this was originally planned to be a much longer post airing my issues with more of the top mons in the meta, but I decided to hold off on that and focus on these two instead as they've been responsible for a lot of my issues in practice. Obviously, I don't expect anything to happen before the DLC, but I thought it was worth talking about this for a bit as it may be a useful retrospective if we run into similar issues in the future. Hopefully sometime in the future I'll get a chance to talk about the other asshole mons in this metagame and the potential consequences of removing them, but for now I'll leave it here. Thanks for reading if you did get this far lol, writing is not my forte.