Kind of impressive we went through all of 2023 without mentioning sleep clause (This is the old PR thread from 2021-2022 that has points on both sides).
Considering Darkrai entering the tier with Hypnosis sets is what sort of triggered this discussion, it seems like the issue (if there is one) is more Darkrai than sleep. Was sleep an issue before Darkrai was in the tier? As in, an actual issue that needed tiering action to stabilize the metagame?
If we want to talk about cart mechanics then I think it’s fair to talk about both sleep and freeze clause, but if cart mechanics are the reason to take action then we can’t pick and choose, either stay true to cart or keep both clauses that have kept these two statuses in check for years of competitive mons.
Considering Darkrai entering the tier with Hypnosis sets is what sort of triggered this discussion, it seems like the issue (if there is one) is more Darkrai than sleep. Was sleep an issue before Darkrai was in the tier? As in, an actual issue that needed tiering action to stabilize the metagame?
If we want to talk about cart mechanics then I think it’s fair to talk about both sleep and freeze clause, but if cart mechanics are the reason to take action then we can’t pick and choose, either stay true to cart or keep both clauses that have kept these two statuses in check for years of competitive mons.










