Key:
MAW = Metagross Always Wins - The chances of Metagross winning are about 85% or higher
MUW = Metagross Usually Wins - The chances of Metagross winning are about 60% - 85%
~50/50 = Uncertain for either side - The chances of Metagross winning are about 40% - 60%
MCW = Metagross Can Win - The chances of Metagross winning are about 15% - 40%
MAL = Metagross Always Loses - The chances of Metagross winning are less than 15%
S RANK
Gyarados-Mega
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
Overall, Metagross will typically win this matchup with the right moveset, the odds of success only being boosted higher by how rarely experienced people use max Atk/Spe Gyarados.
Kyurem-Black
Hide
Scarf
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Icium
Adamant -MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Specs
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
Band
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Weakness Policy
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MAW
Overall, Metagross pretty consistently counters just about anything Kyurem-Black can throw at it, with only a few sets even having a chance given that they're able to either safely take a hit + Bullet AND outspeed for the 2HKO, or getting the lucky roll against a 0 bulk Metagross with Weakness Policy-boosted Earth Power
A RANK
Charizard-Mega-X
Hide
Standard
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - MAL
Optimized Standard
Adamant -MAL
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - MAL
Bulky
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MAL
Not exactly Metagross' most ideal matchup, most matchups being won typically by Charizard Mega Evolving and Dancing up for the guaranteed OHKO, though Jolly Metagross has a chance by spamming Substitute for the Flare Blitz Recoil before finishing it off with Earthquake, the only risk being that the Charizard might use its own Substitute to automatically win, if you get predicted.
Tapu Koko
Hide
Physical
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - ~50/50 (Jolly/Naive) / MAL (Adamant/Naughty)
Impish - MAW
Optimized Physical
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - ~50/50 (Jolly/Naive) / MAL (Adamant/Naughty)
Impish - MAW
Special
Adamant - ~50/50 (Timid/Naive) / MAL (Modest/Rash)
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MAW
Optimized Special
Adamant - ~50/50 (Timid/Naive) / MAL (Modest/Rash)
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MAW
The generic spreads don't really fare too well against Koko, particularly the Specially offensive kind, but the custom spread is built to withstand anything and everything Koko can throw at it, besides critical hits.
Tapu Lele
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
[Insert Steel STAB here].
Aggron-Mega
Adamant -MAL
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MAL
Aggron bulks everything Metagross can throw at it, not even needing Defense EVs to avoid being 2HKO'd by Hammer Arm. It'd take some serious flinching with Iron Head to make this matchup anywhere near favorable.
Charizard-Mega-Y
Hide
Standard
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAL
Bulky
Adamant - MAW (If slow enough) / MAL (If fast enough)
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MCW (Very EV dependent)
This entire matchup pretty much depends completely on the EV spread of Charizard-Y, as well as the presence of Rock Slide in Metagross' moveset.
Dragonite
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
There are way too many iterations of Dragonite to go into detail for all of them, but more often than not, Metagross wins simply by hitting Dragonite twice with STABs, or even Ice Punch.
Lopunny-Mega
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
The only shot Lopunny has is getting lucky with Teeter Dance and/or misses.
Magearna
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
Unless Ghostium Magearna became a thing in the time it took to make this, Metagross has this locked down, for the most part.
Mawile-Mega
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
Good old-fashioned Bullet spam.
Metagross-Mega
Hide
Adamant
Adamant - ~50/50
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - MAL
Jolly
Adamant - ~50/50
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - ~50/50
Impish
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - ~50/50
All matchups are considered using only Earthquake and Bullet Punch, not adding Magnet Rise to the mix because effort-
Mimikyu
Hide
Ghostium
Adamant - MUW (Jolly) / MAL (Adamant)
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - MAW
Fairium
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Curse
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Metagross actually takes Z-Shadow Claw surprisingly well.
Pinsir-Mega
Adamant - ~50/50
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAL
Matchups done without assuming Rock Slide, as well as assuming Pinsir has Earthquake + Bulk Up.
Aegislash
Adamant - ~50/50
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - ~50/50
Substitute and Earthquake make this unwinnable matchup into something a bit more favorable.
Donphan
Adamant - ~50/50
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - ~50/50
Magnet Rise can turn the tables on this impossible matchup, but Counter still exists.
Landorus-Therian
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAL
It's always either too fast or not fast enough (Ice Punch/Magnet Rise required).
Magnezone
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MUW
You can either bulk a Gigavolt and 2HKO with EQ + Bullet, or pray for Iron Head flinch and EQ.
Porygon-Z
Hide
Scarf
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
Specs
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MCW
Bulky Download Specs exists, but unfortunately, so does Hammer Arm.
Snorlax
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
Hoping for max Sleep turns and no Iron Head Flinches is all Snorlax has going for it here.
Slowbro-Mega
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MAL
Not even Grass Knot reliably beats it.
Venusaur-Mega
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
It would take either a miracle or the lack of Zen Headbutt for Venusaur to win.
B RANK
Altaria-Mega
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
Cotton Guard may exist, but so does Ice Punch, not to mention you can just fish for a crit even if you predict wrong.
Blaziken
Hide
Physical Z-move
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - MAL
Special Z-move
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - MAL
Physical Mega
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - MAW
Special Mega
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - MAL
Pretty mixed in matchups, Jolly is able to force a 50/50 with sub/zen vs protect/fire, while the other two have decent chances at standing up to a physical mega, but practically no chance against anything faster and special/z-move.
Garchomp
Hide
Groundium
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAL
Band
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Other
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MUW
All matchups made assuming Metagross has Ice Punch.
Genesect
Hide
Scarf
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MAL
Specs
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MAL
Flamethrower = die. Even Bug Buzz can do the trick.
Golem
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Magnet Rise is a killer. Get rid of it, however, and those W's become L's.
Greninja
Adamant - MUW (Timid/Naive) / MCW (Modest/Rash)
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MUW (Timid/Naive) / MCW (Modest/Rash)
Dark Pulse flinchcrits or gtfo.
Heracross-Mega
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Pretty straightforward.
Meloetta
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MAW
Also straightforward.
Primarina
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MUW
The special bulk on that custom set sure comes in handy, otherwise, Metagross relies pretty much completely on flinchcrits.
Tapu Fini
Hide
Specs
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Waterium
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Thunder Punch is a killer.
Blastoise-Mega
Hide
Offensive
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MUW
Counter/Coat
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - ~50/50
This matchup is pretty geared towards moveset. Metagross' assumed moveset here is Thunder Punch + Substitute.
Chansey
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW
Since Charm/Counter pretty much instantly wins, Metagross' only hope here is to get the nasty flinch hax.
Carracosta
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
+2 Earthquake only takes out Jolly on a high roll, but still just gets bopped by Hammer Arm and Bullet anyways.
Crustle
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
All matchups won by using Bullet Punch pre-mega and then finishing them off with either another Bullet if they Shell Smashed, or any other attack if they used Earthquake or Counter.
Ferrothorn
Hide
Standard Leech Seed
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MAL
Curse
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MAL
Iron Defense
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MAL
Matchups done without the consideration of Substitute, which probably still wouldn't change the result vs Curse and Iron Defense, only chance vs Standard set is getting high rolls with Max Attack Hammer Arm.
Gardevoir-Mega
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
You might not even need steel type moves for this one.
Heatran
Hide
Bulky
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW
Speedy
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MUW
Matchups vs Bulky Heatran are assuming you get the Iron Head flinch and finish with Hammer/EQ, while matchups vs Speedy are instant loss for Adamant, and a decent chance of the custom spread being able to take a Timid Overheat.
Jirachi
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
Only hope is the 20% Fire Punch burn.
Jumpluff
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - MAL
Jolly speed ties while Adamant has decent chances of getting the Bullet KO if played right.
Kartana
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - ~50/50
Banded Night Slash can threaten the custom spread, but otherwise, Metagross has this.
Sableye-Mega
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MAL
Metagross has about as much chance of winning as Sableye has of missing Will-o-Wisp.
Sawk
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Use Bullet Punch pre-mega to avoid the bop from Counter and you can't really lose.
Swampert-Mega
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW
Adamant just bops with Zen Headbutt while the other two have to rely on careful predicts with Magnet Rise.
Tyranitar-Mega
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MUW
Counter may exist, but so does Hammer Arm.
Blissey
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW
Pretty much the same story as Chansey, but worse.
Buzzwole
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MUW
Zen Headbutt owns this, for the most part.
Celesteela
Hide
Leech Seed
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MAL
Specs
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MUW
Physically defense Leech Seed is hard to break, but Specs Fire Blast has difficulty with bulky Metagross.
Diancie
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Steel moves = no chance.
Durant
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MUW
Adamant hopes for misses to 2HKO the hustler, Jolly just plain 2HKOs with EQ then Hammer Arm while not getting OHKO'd, and Durant needs Crunch to 2hko the custom spread, while the custom spread 3HKO's with Hammer Arm and Bullet.
Gengar-Mega
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - ~50/50
Adamant has a solid shot of 2HKOing with Bullet, factoring that in with the 40% miss chance and the 33% chance to wake up first turn makes things favorable for Metagross.
Latios
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MUW
Only Specs Shadow Ball has a chance vs the custom spread, but it still isn't very likely.
Mew
Hide
Genesis Supernova
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MAW
Defensive
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MAL
Assuming GeneMew runs Overheat and ~0 Speed EVS (Most frequent in usage), Metagross wins most of the time by just spamming Iron Head, not even needing the hax very much if at all. Bulky Mew, on the other hand, can only be threatened by Substitute and hax, and even then, the odds aren't really in Metagross' favor.
Pheromosa
Hide
Physical
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Special
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MAW
Z-Focus Blast is all that Phero has going for it in this matchup.
Terrakion
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Any STAB is just an automatic win
Umbreon
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MAL
Adamant at least has a chance with Hammer Arm and hoping for a flinch/crit with Iron Head to finish with another Hammer after being Z-Charmed, but that's as good as it gets. (using the top usage Umbreon spread)
Whimsicott
Hide
Babiri Berry
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAL
Cotton Guard
Adamant - ~50/50
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - MAL
Other
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAL
Jolly wins over Babiri by outspeeding AND using Bullet, Cotton Guard is forced to a 50/50 if Metagross has Substitute, and all Whimsicott can be bulked to withstand an attack from the custom spread.
C RANK
Archeops
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Only chance this thing has at all is speed tying Jolly and KOing with a Z-move, but even then Metagross can just Bullet Punch and win.
Avalugg
Hide
Weakness Policy
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MUW
Curse
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
Other
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
The best chance it has is with weakness policy against Jolly, but even that can end up falling to an Iron Head flinch, everything else just ends up taking the gamble that they don't get screwed over by crit/flinches.
Hoopa-Unbound
Hide
Scarf
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MUW
Specs
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW
Other
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW
Scarf Dark Pulse can't possibly OHKO the bulky spreads, and it just ends up being picked off, while Bulky Specs takes the risk of being flinched or crit.
Keldeo
Hide
Speedy
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MUW
Bulky
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MAW
Most of these matchups are either dependent upon Scald landing a burn, or surviving Zen Headbutt if you're bulky.
Landorus-Incarnate
Hide
Life Orb
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MCW
Scarf
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MUW
Ice Punch is required on the custom spread, but the other two can Meteor/Iron and Bullet.
Marowak-Alola
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MAL
Flare Blitz hurts too much, and can just use Shadow Bone afterwards if you try to Sub spam for the recoil. You can go for the Iron Head flinch to finish it with EQ, but that's about as good a chance as it gets.
Medicham-Mega
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - MAW
Fake Out + HJK can take out Jolly, but Meteor Mash can also OHKO on a solid roll, if no bulk investment.
Victini
Hide
Speedy
Adamant - MCW (Scarf) / MAL (Band)
Jolly - MAL (Scarf) / MCW (Band)
Impish - MAW (Scarf) / MAL (Band)
Bulky Band
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW
Metagross actually has a surprisingly decent chance of surviving Scarfed V-Create, but in the case of Band or other non-Scarf sets, it's pretty much dependent upon Metagross getting a lucky Rock Slide flinch and snagging the 2HKO.
Dusclops
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW
Metagross only has a chance here because it can use Substitute.
Hitmonlee
Hide
Normal Gem
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Liechi
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
You'd have to either try pretty darn hard or not have Bullet Punch in order to lose this matchup.
Infernape
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAL
Any kind of boosted fire move makes this an automatic loss for anything slower.
Lucario-Mega
Hide
Physical
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Special
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
Lucario doesn't really have much of a chance here beyond hoping for Hammer Arm misses and Dark Pulse flinches.
Pidgeot-Mega
Hide
Speedy
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Fertile Crescent
Adamant - ~50/50
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - ~50/50
Regular Pidgeot kinda just loses, with their only chance of winning being a Heat Wave crit/burn, which is less than 1% more likely than Will-o-Wisp missing. The best chance it has vs the famed Bulky Birb, however, is by relying on Rock Tomb without mega evolving and hoping they don't go for Heat Wave when you do so.
Quagsire
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MAL
Kentari can vouch for probability management playing a big role in this matchup.
Relicanth
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
Substitute shenanigans kinda skew this matchup, so we'll just pretend it doesn't exist for this one. With that said, Relicanth needs a 3 turn sleep in order to win using Earthquake.
Thundurus-Therian
Hide
Specs
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
Z-move
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW
Specs Dark Pulse hax makes things uncertain for any Metagross slower, while also OHKO-ing Jolly, usually. Bulky Z move, on the other hand, is a bit more challenging for Metagross to beat, so it ends up relying on haxing Thundy for the win.
Abomasnow-Mega
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Yet another matchup decided by typing alone.
Barbaracle
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MAW
Though +2 Earthquake does have a solid chance of OHKO-ing Jolly Metagross, Metagross can also either hax or pick up a 2HKO with the right moves.
Camerupt-Mega
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW
Being able to always OHKO your opponent is half the battle. Not getting haxed and 2HKO'd is the other half, sadly.
Manectric-Mega
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MAW
Overheat only has about a 40% chance of OHKO-ing Jolly with Overheat, that's pretty much it.
Nihilego
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
You could probably win this matchup without even using physical attacks.
Pyukumuku
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW
Sub and Thunder Punch are all Adamant needs, while Jolly and Impish have to go for flinches, otherwise Pyu will usually win this matchup
Sceptile-Mega
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
Why was this even ranked again? You could argue SubSeed exists, but I could argue Ice Punch exists.
Zygarde
Hide
Band
Adamant - MAL / MUW (Depends on whether Zygarde outspeeds or not)
Jolly - MUW (Tarrows) / MCW (Earthquake)
Impish - MAW (Ice Punch) / MCW (No Ice Punch) (Depends on whether Zygarde outspeeds or not)
Groundium
Adamant - MAL / MCW (Depends on whether Zygarde outspeeds or not)
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW (Depends on whether Zygarde outspeeds or not)
Other
Adamant - MAL / MUW (Depends on whether Zygarde outspeeds or not)
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW (Depends on whether Zygarde outspeeds or not)
Ice Punch kinda wrecks this matchup, otherwise, typically in Zygarde's favor.
D RANK
Alakazam-Mega
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MAW
I'll be generous and make Jolly MUW, just because crit Shadow Ball OHKOs.
Aron
Adamant - ~50/50
Jolly - ~50/50
Impish - ~50/50
Without assuming you have Sub, you're basically just hoping for Iron Head flinches.
Azumarill
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - MUW
Adamant Metagross 2HKOs pretty easily, while Z-Aqua Tail can be pretty threatening to the other two if they don't get good RNG/rolls.
Clefable
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MAW
S/O to the babiri Counter Clefable I used last gen-
Latias
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MAL
Meteor Mash boosts pre-mega and crits are pretty much all you have going for you in this matchup. Reflect Type always wins, I guess, but Charm is used more/generally better by far.
Necrozma
Hide
Specs
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MUW
Impish - ~50/50
Z-move
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW
Adamant 2HKOs with Iron Head, Jolly does the same with Meteor Mash, while Impish relies on Iron Head haxing. Iron Defense Necrozma causes difficulties that can only be solved via haxing.
Porygon2
Adamant - ~50/50
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW
Adamant has a decent chance of 2HKOing max bulk with Hammer Arm, the miss chances bring that down to about a 50/50, though. The other sets just rely on good old-fashioned
skill hax.
Salazzle
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MAW
Fake Out and Overheat are just short of 2HKOing the custom spread. Z-Fire just kinda wrecks them all, however.
Scizor-Mega
Adamant - MAL
Jolly - MAL
Impish - MAL
This guy is the OU dedicated Metagross Counter for good reason.
Slaking
Adamant - MAW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MUW (Depends on whether you outspeed or not) / MAW (Hammer Arm)
Banded Earthquake OHKOs Jolly pretty easily, but Flinches put the odds quite a bit less in Slaking's favor.
Smeargle
Adamant - MCW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MCW
Everyone loves praying for that 1/3 chance at waking up, right?
Stunfisk
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MCW
Impish - MCW
Ignoring the existence of Sub and Magnet Rise, it's just another round of praying for the 1/3 wakeup for Jolly and Impish, while Adamant pretty much safely 2HKOs with Iron Head and EQ, possibly auto-winning with a Flinch.
Vivillon
Adamant - MUW
Jolly - MAW
Impish - MUW
It takes a lot of hope for Vivillon to win this matchup.