What I do not understand here is why people seem to be very much in support for an Aerilate + Rayquaza ban as Flint has suggested but seem to not give the same preferential treatment to Kyogre, who would probably be completely balanced if we banned Kyogre + Poison Heal instead. Likewise, Groudon would probably be fine if we banned Groudon alongside all of Precipice Blades, Thousand Arrows, and V-Create. It's the same complex ban idea and would fix the Pokemon, but it seems that nobody is even paying attention to these options. Why? Because it would get to the point where fine tuning our bans would be absolutely ridiculous.
While we're at it why not ban Pure Power + moves with a base power over 80? It would work fine! Or Wonder Guard on all Pokemon with 5 weaknesses or more? That would probably work fine too! Arena Trap and Shadow Tag on Pokemon with 400 BST or less? The sky's the limit!
If you're going to say I'm being intentionally facetious, yes, I am to an extent. But the issue I'm tackling here is what people rooting for an Aerilate + Rayquaza ban do not seem to properly understand: that this road leads to such facetious ideas.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reductio_ad_absurdum
The very same argument could apply to your preference for Pokemon bans. All right, let's ban RayquazaMega cause it is broken with a single set, Aerilate. Let's also ban DiancieMega tomorrow if you feel it is broken with Pixilate; then regular Rayquaza, then KyuremWhite and so on and so forth, all because your possible opinion could change. Similarly, Rayquaza is great with protean so let's ban it; unfortunately Adrian posted only special calcs', so everything there can be done better by MewtwoMegaY, so let's ban him too. MewtwoMegaX can do nearly the same except use the physical spectrum, so let's ban him as well. DeoxysA has the same offenses as Rayquaza meaning that you HAVE to revenge kill him since you have no switch in, just like you would for the other Proteans; let's ban him as well.
It can also extend to your ludicrous "counterarguments"; instead of banning all moves except for 80BP, let's simply ban all the mons with less than 100 base stat in Attack or Special Attack! Instead of banning Wonder Guard on a Pokemon, why can we not ban the Pokemon directly? I'm telling you, it's not Wonder Guard that's broken, all the pokemon are, so let's just ban them all! Yeah, I'm sure that would work just as well.
Sure what you're saying
can happen, but that doesn't mean it
will, because what you're saying will happen has no real foundation in common sense. We as a community will have the main role in figuring out at what point something crosses over from being a necessary minor complexity, to basically trying to create crutches to keep something in the game. I know you're ready to counter "but what is that point at which we cross" and don't fret, because it is coming after this.
As for your so called claim that we are showing "preferential" treatment to MegaRay, then I would have to say that that is just in your imagination. Sure you could say that we can try to extend the argument to PH Kyogre, if you ignore every other aspect that it outshines Raymega in, and the fact that it is completely dominant in the tier with multiple abilities defensive and offensive purely because of what it inherently has; a good defensive and offensive stab typing with lesser used weaknesses and the ability to overcome nearly every threat without straying too far into coverage or relying on a single ability. I've already posed why Kyogre and Groudon should be held as that standard of "what makes a pokemon broken in BH" and that is where we should want to show that Ray is. If you want to argue that KyogrePrimal is not broken without PH, then be my guest, but I already understand that you do not think that is true, and neither do others in this thread, so this entire claim is void in itself. I do not believe it either, or I
would say the same thing for KyogrePrimal and PH.
Or if you still don't acknowledge this argument for some reason then at least the first two, since Kyogre and Groudon are pretty much fine otherwise (And if you disagree, then we can discuss alternatives to making them balanced!). Of course we wouldn't do this, because it's ridiculous. But this is the road we're heading down.
I personally do not think things will become quite as extreme as you are trying to make it out to be. Refer to this post which I found which I think describes what I am trying to say:
http://www.smogon.com/forums/threads/prefer-banning-pokémon-instead-of-items-abilities.3500294/#post-5250718, and be sure to look at his other examples since you don't think mine were applicable.
Getting rid of Aerilate on Raymega is the most concise step that can be taken that also allows it to still remain usable.
There is quite a big difference between stopping the use of a single ability on MegaRay and forcing movechecks on Thosand Arrows et al, because there will always be other ways to exploit nearly the same strategy. You can use EQ with gravity if you wished, go the special side - how many moves are you going to stop? Is stopping Groudon from running potetnailly tens or hundreds of moves that make most sets similar the same level of "complex behavior" as not allowing a
single ability on Raymega that cannot be replicated by any other? Not to mention, Don's main power comes from its stabs and he is already broken on them, so that is even before we have touched on the fact that he can still run coverage with his main moves. Meanwhile, if you get rid of Aerilate, and its sister ates if you wish, on Raymega, there is no way it reaches the same properties it has with them.
This is actually completely false, because:
- The complex bans were removed in AAA some time ago because myself and everyone else on the council realized it wasn't consistent.
- Sableye was banned from being Inherited from outright in Inheritance, which is pretty much the equivalent of a straight out ban.
- In Averagemons this complex ban was done only so Mega Sableye, a completely different Pokemon than regular Sableye, could be used, and Mamp explicitly stated it was not a precedent and would never happen again for obvious reason
I was unaware of this information, although I think it's interesting to note that:
- Surely you thought that complex banning was the correct decision but you seemed to have changed it purely because complex bans are distasteful apparently, not because there seemed to be any problem in the clauses themselves (or why would you have passed them in the first place). In any case, I assure you I would've argued for complex bans in AAA in the same way as I am here, if I was involved there and I've already put this opinion to you before
- When I referred to the sableye problem in Inheritance, I was pointing out how the set derived from Sableye was banned; NOT the Pokemon that worked best to the point of being broken with the set in question, such as Chansey. Why not just ban the biggest offenders, because I'm sure the set could be more or less fine on something like Dratini and Kakuna?
- I feel that the comparision with averagemons is still actually quite relevant. Sableye Mega is not a completely different Pokemon (because the stats are normalized here), its role and its set are completely different to the one that the prankster version uses. How is that any different from what I was saying about MegaRay being a completely different thing if it is using Aerilate and if it is using Adaptibility or Protean? How are those sets related? I shall revisit this point, but furthermore, I don't see why you cannot argue that this is "just a one off" occasion in BH as well; that is just a lazy way to bend the rules
Assist is not a complex ban, as it is the ban of one move and one move only without any additional exceptions. In addition, Assist was banned because people knew that the same garbage could pretty much be spammed with any other Pokemon with any other reasonably high powered move to the same results of winning/losing against good teams on team match-up, which is why it was banned and not Groudon.
I don't think you understand me. I am bringing into question what your supposed definition of
complexity is. To me, assist was a complex decision, because the reasons it was banned are not immediately clear to a new user first time. Many times we had people coming into the OM room asking why Assist is banned, since it seems to be innocuous enough. Then you have to explain, that with a certain exploit and a certain move, Assist can be uncounterable by the majority of the tier. How is this any different from the so called "complexity" when one asks why Aerilate is not allowed on Raymega? The ability clause is another decision that we all passed, that seems complex to me and requires explanation. What exactly made us decide on the arbitrary two on a team other than the persuasion of certain players?
Is there any justification behind having two instead of one or three? None of these are answered even to date. It is more than just the simple wording of a clause that makes something complex. As mentioned in that post I referenced, complex situations are bound to happen. This gets back to your point here
It is applicable here, because perhaps they don't need to be as necessarily complex as you make them out to be. All of my ideas above could be summarized in one statement and exception like your proposed ban, and are relatively easy to understand and achieve the same idea of balance as Aerilate + Rayquaza, nor does it take much effort to apply these bans. Where do we draw the line you're stating here anyway, and for what reasons should it be drawn at that point?
You are a clever guy because you know already that there is no concrete place to keep a line because it is not possible to have one due to the shifting nature of the game. However that just makes this concern meaningless. I already pointed out that as a group we will decide at what point it is taking more effort to keep something in the tier than remove, and it has to go beyond just a simple wording "complexity" because that is not really complex. You can say a ton of the most complex ideas possible in the blandest terms. Furthermore, the line is already drawn; we are only focusing on three Pokemon yes that are broken? It is not like anything we decide will somehow invalidate earlier pokemon bans because they aren't any. And all the bans that we have already agreed on had their own basis and I doubt any of them were dependent purely on any of these 'mons, so why bring them into this at all? Besides, if you truly want a concrete way, then again I would refer to that post because it seems a solid starting step and again would like to reiterate that as a community we will provide the decision when it is causing more pain to keep a 'mon than ban it, so the hysterical ending you predict as inevitable is actually never going to happen. I don't want to say anything concrete in case it bites me in the ass later one, but I think that if you want a pokemon banned in bh, a meta where the moves and abilities can be nearly limitless across all mons thus providing less distinguishing factors, then there must be something inherently unique in that Pokemon that makes it difficult to stop
and difficult to kill even if you make a concerted effort to do so, across different sets i.e. again, what a pokemon itself can bring into the table. If you look at my previous major post, you can see why I group Don and Ogre together to show that they do follow this
loose guideline and that banning them is the correct decision as per the initial "rules" provided in that post I referenced.
Before you go into how later in that thread Zarel and the rest actually slammed down that post and others similar, I would just like to point out once again what their arguments actually are, which again can be summarized as:
However, the decision was ultimately made to not do so based on two basic points, which across all the posts I've read, can be summarized as:
1) Pokemon with the different abilities still perform roughly the same role, which is what is being attempted to stop. This argument is used against Speed Boost Blaziken vs Blaze Blaziken
2) This decision would affect every single pokemon across all standard tiers, resulting in many cases the same Pokemon being classified in different tiers basedon what abilities it has. This would be a massive undertaking that is simply unfeasible.
Neither of these arguments apply in BH. I'll start with the second point.All we are deciding is if a pokemon is in or out of the tier. There are no other tiers we need to put them into, and there is no reason to bucket every other mon that could be potentially banned (because we have only two other candidates, who are broken across their sets, not on their main one, which is the assumption we made to begin with - if you want to refute this assumption, then you should also be questioning why Don and Ogre are being banned at all). The first point is also completely inapplicable to BH because the ability defines the role of a pokemon in this meta. You can't say "oh look Raymega is broken on aerilate, so we should ban it because it will behave the same across all of the sets". It just doesn't work. Raymega has drastically different sets for Aerilate, Tinted, Contrary, Gale Wings, PH, Fur Coat, Magic Guard and all. There is simply no way to blanket all of them together.
which also addresses Kumi's points and arguments as to why those clauses he lists were not in the tier, bar the one that "noobs should understand the tier in one line or less" which besides being an excuse more than an argument, is a threshold I think we already crossed with our decisions already, something which I know Kumi agrees with already (without any further clauses). I personally agree that there are tradeoffs just like with anything else; I just think that banning Ray has a bigger negative than just banning Raymega with Aerilate.
Finally, I would just like to let you know that I was really intrigued by your post and I think you did an excellent job in delving into the semantics of complexity et al; truly, it was a masterclass in deflecting attention away from the main question:
If a pokemon is not inherently broken how can you justify banning it?
And I already know why; you and Adrian have already agreed with me on multiple occasions in the OM chat that if Aerilate is not on Rayquaza, you both would relax your stance on it, and that evidence does not support that he is broken. And I cannot fathom the idea that if you do not think the mon is broken, why it needs to be banned.To me, all this talk of complexity semantics frankly seems like this decision is turning more into "let's just get rid of it, I don't want to have to deal with it anymore" than any concrete or fundamental issue or concern with the complexity of clauses and the impact they can have on an "innocent victim" new player. This seems incredibly unfair because if the -ates are suspected, which I am confident they shall be after this, then this decision to ban ray is completely pointless and baseless; banning Raymega now is the most favorable because you can just get it out of the way, and then still get rid of -ate later on, by which time there will very likely be extremely little interest in retesting Raymega again, meaning it was banned for no other reason than sheer laziness instead of an indepth look at its place in the tier. Besides, I don't know how you cannot look at it on the flip side; if RayquazaMega
is broken even without -ate, then we can always ban him later as well - once we have seen that it really is impossible to counter across most of his sets and even a concerted effort isn't enough to keep it in its place. That seems to cause the least damage to me.
Also I think it is just a good idea to start wrapping up this argument here because it is clear that we are not going to agree. I just wanted to put my opinion forward though I'm sure it will not be read and I shall be outnumbered as usual. So I am going to refrain from posting now beyond addressing specific counter responses to this post.