urkerab said:I don't know how much damage Incineroar was expecting to do; is there a way for you to tell whether the Attack drop happened before or after the attack (it's not something I'd want to guess).
Also, what happens with Baneful Bunker and Spiky Shield?
I did some further testing on this. I recreated the same battle both in Showdown and on the 3DS, to show the differences between both of them.
Before talking about the replays, I'm gonna share the EV Spread I used, so that we can have a reference when doing the damage calcs:
All of them have 31 IV's on every stat
Aegislash: 244 HP / 0 Def, Modest Nature
Incineroar: 244 HP / 252 Attack, Adamant Nature
Togedemaru: 4 HP / 0 Def, Jolly Nature, Ability: Lightning Rod (not Iron barbs)
Basically this is what going to happen in both of these replays:
- RaahxenPOV (Trainer A) sents out Incineroar and Togedemaru
- SmileyPsyduck (Trainer B) sents out Incineroar and Aegislash
Turn 1:
- RaahxenPOV's Togedemaru uses Spiky Shield
- SmileyPsyduck's Aegislash uses King's Shield
- RaahxenPOV's Incineroar uses Malicious Moonsault (Incineroar's Z-Move that makes Contact) into Aegislash's King's Shield
-> In Pokemon Showdown, RaahxenPOV's Incineroar doesn't get his attack dropped
-> On 3DS Link Battle, RaahxenPOV's Incineroar Attack drops 2 stages
- SmileyPsyduck's Incineroar uses Malicious Moonsault (Incineroar's Z-Move that makes Contact) into Togedemaru's Spiky Shield
-> In Pokemon Showdown, RaahxenPOV's Incineroar doesn't lose any HP
-> On 3DS Link Battle, RaahxenPOV's Incineroar loses 1/8 of his HP (25 HP)
Turn 2:
- SmileyPsyduck's Incineroar Protects
- Togedemaru uses Fake Out (and it fails)
- Aegislash stays in Shield form by using Wide Guard
- SmileyPsyduck's Incineroar uses Darkest Llariat into Aegislash-Shield
-> In Pokemon Showdown, Aegislash gets KOd by a +0 Incineroar Darkest Lariat (it was a damage roll)
252+ Atk Incineroar Darkest Lariat vs. 244 HP / 0 Def Aegislash-Shield: 104-126 (62.6 - 75.9%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
-> On 3DS Link Battle, Aegislash-Shield takes 62 damage from Darkest Lariat (I got a high roll)
-2 252+ Atk Incineroar Darkest Lariat vs. 244 HP / 0 Def Aegislash-Shield: 54-66 (32.5 - 39.7%) -- 98.6% chance to 3HKO
Possible damage rolls (HP number):
(54, 54, 56, 56, 56, 56, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 62, 62, 62, 62, 66)
Pokémon Showdown replay:
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen7vgc2018-695013947
3DS Battle (FQUG-WWWW-WWWF-ZWK5):
As of right now, I don't have a Pokémon with Baneful Bunker to test this with, but I'll try to get one later.
But seeing how this went down, I'd say that Pokémon Showdown doesn't recognize "Z-Moves that make contact" as contact moves.
List of Z-Moves that make contact:
- Let's Snuggle Forever (Mimikium Z, Mimikyu's exclusive Z-Move)
- Malicious Moonsault (Incinium Z, Incineroar's exclusive Z-Move)
- Pulverizing Pancake (Snorlium Z, Snorlax's exclusive Z-Move)
- Searing Sunraze Smash (Solganium Z, Z-Move exclusive to Solgaleo and Dusk Mane Necrozma)
- Soul-Stealing 7-Star Strike (Marshadium Z, Marshadow's exclusive Z-Move)
So I'd say that this applies to every single attack and ability listed under "Effects involving this contact":
https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Contact
Here's an image to make thing easier: