lilyhollow said:If you see someone punch me in the face repeatedly, and I punch back one time, condemning me for that is definitely not going to help me out. It is the police who are committing violence here.
This would be fine if the actions weren't also aimed at people who aren't involved. Goes for both sides fwiw.
The governor of Minnesota lied and said that 80% of people arrested at the protests were 'outside agitators.' He used this to justify the curfew and increased violence from the police. So you are believing the government in what is just an attempt to get people to look past the violent response to these protests. You also are believing the police when they show 'solidarity' with the protests. Not sure how that's possible when you have police shooting people point-blank with 'rubber bullets,' shooting people for being on their porch, firing tear gas into peaceful crowds, etc etc etc.
I said I had concerns that the small minority of "protesters" that riot would used as an excuse for further government intervention against actual protesters who were protesting peacefully...I'm kind of lost at the first two sentences.
And interesting for the rest of it, I didn't know that. Mind sourcing?
Also Actually he's only been charged with 'accidentally' killing George Floyd. So he actually hasn't even been punished at all yet, and even if he does end up punished, it won't be to the fullest extent of the law. And on top of that, there were three other cops involved here who have not been charged at all.
Then he would be insufficiently punished, not unpunished.
Thanks for the clarification, though!
brightobject said:Many of these photo ops are closely by donning of gas-masks, loading of guns, and tear gassing of crowds--a notable example being Portland. If the liberal overapplication of force by cops is really up for dispute, consider the fact that a peaceful protest was tear-gassed without any prior warning by cop squads in order to clear the street for a
Trump photo op in front of a church. Don't be fooled into taking symbolic acts and statements of goodwill by the police or the administration over their actual conduct. This modern incarnation of an eternally present problem has been in the news for at least a decade now, yet police chiefs have always been hesitant to condemn or call out the behavior of their officers.
I guess I'll take your word for considering I don't really keep up with police brutality in the US.
Note further how the police seem to be in many cases deliberately provoking aggression and engaging in intimidation tactics. A friend of mine working at a peaceful sanctuary in NYC had the officers shaking tear gas canisters in the parking lot 10 minutes after curfew. Regardless of the police's feelings on the ACAB mantra, that is NO excuse for them to engage in such hostility towards the citizens they are supposed to be protecting.
I agree,
Re: looting...there's an incredible disconnect to me when people look at protests of people burning down some store and feeling more shock and horror than when they hear about the systematic violence enacted against BIPOC in this country, to the extent that their fundamental physical needs are compromised. Death by cop is ALWAYS a factor, no matter one's standing. Note the recent viral video where Audubon-society birdwatcher, Harvard-graduate, award-winning movie producer Chris Cooper was threatened by a white woman in Central Park with murder by cop. Property is insured and replaceable. Black lives are not.
This above paragraph is assuming quite a bit. For one, I never said this instilled more horror to me than violence against black americans. The point I made wasn't "this is worse than George Floyd's murder and other cases like his", it was "this will undermine the message that the protest as a whole is trying to send and will be used as an excuse for more government intervention" because attacking stores and the like that didn't have anything to do with this doesn't garner sympathy from those more moderate. It would make some sense if the burning was kept to police stations and police cars, but they aren't.
And if this wasn't aimed at me in particular...why are you bringing this up?
If you are curious about what you can do but don't feel like you are able to donate to organizations like bail funds or Reclaim the Block, consider that even having the conversation about BLM with your family and friends can be a big deal in terms of correcting unspoken racial prejudices.
E: To clarify, while my post might come off as in some ways generally anti-cop/capitalist, this is NOT about the simple proletariat and VERY much about antiblackness in America, and capitalism/law enforcement are just two of the many tools baked into the arsenal of white supremacy.
I doubt it, considering I don't live in the US and neither do most of my family and friends. Seeing as said people are also diverse, I fail to see the need to bring this up. But maybe you can convince me otherwise. Maybe.
As for the last sentence...a bunch of claims on topics I didn't bring up and aren't backed up by anything in the post. I don't know why you're going here, but sure?
TexanSansei said:To respond to this with an actually(what I thought)good list of 5 reasons why people destroy stuff at riots as opposed to your one reason.
So I gotta say that I think at least some people out there are doing it for reason number one.(Which I find incredibly honorable) although there are some negative reasons why people do it as well
I already kind of adressed it earlier, but how does lashing out against those who weren't involved garner sympathy?
I will admit I'm not particularly informed on the subject, which is why I'm genuinely asking for sources.