Cuddly said:Metagame premise: The move in your first slot applies the secondary effects of its Max and G-Max versions.
:ss/Charizard:
Charizard @ Choice Specs
Ability: Solar Power
EVs: 252 SpA / 4 SpD / 252 Spe
Timid Nature
IVs: 0 Atk
- Flamethrower
- Weather Ball
- Overheat
- Focus Blast
Here is a pretty standard Charizard. It has Flamethrower in the first moveslot. This Flamethrower still has 90 BP, 100 Accuracy, and a 10% chance to burn, but additionally will set Sun if hit successfully like Max Flare would.
:ss/Charizard-Gmax:
Charizard @ Choice Specs
Ability: Solar Power
Gigantamax: Yes
EVs: 252 SpA / 4 SpD / 252 Spe
Timid Nature
IVs: 0 Atk
- Flamethrower
- Weather Ball
- Overheat
- Focus Blast
Here is also Charizard, but now with G-Max. So instead of Flamethrower setting Sun, all non-Fire types take 1/6th damage for 4 turns.
This Metagame would be what MnM was for Gen 6 and what Ultimate Z was for Gen 7, but with Gen 8.
Potential bans and threats:
:Muk: :hitmonchan: :pidgeot:
The effects of Max-Ooze, Max-Knuckle, and Max-Airstream are all extremely overpowered when they were limited to 3 turns, so these moves would definitely need to be restricted.
:Gengar-gmax:
Gengar has access to G-Max Terror. G-Max Terror will trap any opponent that isn't Normal or immune to Trapping like Ghosts (which are weak to Ghost moves).
:Bisharp:
Probably one of the best Pokemon in the entire Metagame with its ability Defiant, Sucker Punch, Steel Spike, and Dark/Steel typing. It can punish Flutterby U-turns, Strike Facade/Body Slams/Rapid Spin give it a defiant boost, Wyrmwind Break Swipe/Scale Shot/Clanging Scale are resisted and boost Defiant, Phantasm Shadow Sneaks/Poltergeist and Darkness Dark Pulses similarly are resisted too. A new hazard and easier aurora veil also means Bisharp can switch into more Defogs in this meta.
:Raichu-Alola:
Raichu-A becomes one of the strongest Electric types in the tier thanks to Max Lightning Rising Voltage and Volt Switch. It can set up the Terrain it abuses by using Rising Voltage or have one of many Volt Switch users set terrain while it switches in to be immediately threatening. If Tapu Lele or Rillaboom switch into Raichu’s Rising Voltage, they lose their terrains, and Raichu is naturally faster than Lele too. Raichu-A also gains access to Grass Knot and STAB Psychic to deal with Ground types that otherwise block Rising Voltage.
:snorlax-gmax:
Snorlax having ways to restore its own berry while attacking, which like Alcremie, would be it incredibly hard to kill
:pikachu-gmax:
Pikachu may seem weak, but every electric move paralyzes the target, and that might not be competitive.
:hawlucha: :regieleki:
With regular Volt Switch, you can set terrain with any Pokemon that learns that move, so Hawlucha and Regieleki have easy access to Electric Terrain for Unburden and Rising Voltage Spam (and they can set it themselves too).
:Barraskewda: :Excadrill:
Like with Hawlucha, Swift Swimmers and Sand Rushers can set their own weathers, with Swift Swim also having Flip Turn support too. Barraskewda and Excadrill being the biggest threats.
:toxtricity-gmax:
Like Pikachu, but can poison the opponent instead, which is less more competitive tbh but is also on a much better Pokemon.
:centiskorch-gmax: :sandaconda-gmax:
Like with G-Max Terror, these guys can trap the foe with their STAB moves on moves much stronger than Fire Spin and Sand Tomb
:Butterfree-Gmax:
G-Max Befuddle is also potentially uncompetitive strategy I forgot to mention as it has 3 different status effects that also happen to be attatched to a Pivot Move in U-turn. Butterfree is the weakest between Pikachu and Toxtricity, but a 33% chance to Sleep while using U-turn could be strong (or not since Tapu Koko exists and it can only pull this off against something like Blissey or Choice Locked Pokemon).
:charizard-gmax: :Blastoise-gmax: :venusaur-gmax:
Blastoise got Shell Smash in Gen 8, and while still walled by Toxapex, Ferrothorn doesn’t like taking 1/6th health every turn for not being part Water.
Venusaur is absolutely a monster in sun, especially with G-Max Vine Lash heavily damaging Non-grass types, while also packing Weather Ball and Sludge Bomb for Grass types.
Charizard can deal with Tyranitar better by either removing the Sand it sets while it switches in, or making sure Tyranitar takes heavy chip damage on its way in, but still has limited options for Heatran.
:Kingler-Gmax: :obstagoon:
While Kingler is often overlooked even with its G-Max form, Foam Burst is actually pretty threatening on it. A Life Orb Sheer Force Liquidation hits really hard, and when you can lower the switch-in’s speed by 2 stages, something like Zerarora no longer outspeeds Kingler, which is actually insane.
Same thing with Obstagoon’s Facade. Any non-Ghosts and the likes of Regieleki become immediately slower switching in, and the Ghosts don’t like Guts boosted Knock Offs either.
Questions for the community:
Should G-Max Pokemon be tier separately from their regular counterparts?
How should problematic Max moves be dealt with?
Would another form of restriction be better than the effects applying to the first move slot?
Should status moves gain the effects of Max moves, or just be restricted?
This was never submitted, and I like the idea. With proper tiering it could be the first actually fun dynamax-based metagame I've seen proposed. I would love to see it submitted if you're still interested.
I do have some technical qs that would need to be answered, such as what happens with 2 turn moves, but we can sort those
Your qs:
Q:Should G-Max Pokemon be tier separately from their regular counterparts?
A: IMO it works either way. They're separate formes so you can certainly ban the gmax forme on its own, or you could ban the whole mon. Personally I think it's best if you take it on a case by case basis, and decide based on whether it's the one move that overwhelms or a combination of factors.
Q: How should problematic Max moves be dealt with?
A: There isn't a good answer for this besides a complex restriction on what's in the first moveslot. This is my biggest problem because "No Flying moves in the first moveslot" is a HUGE ban that is insanely complex, and yet in order for the meta to be at all fun or balanced it's absolutely necessary. But I don't think there's another answer.
Q: Would another form of restriction be better than the effects applying to the first move slot?
A: I can't think of anything. I repeat what I said above, this is the best suggestion for a max based meta I've seen.
Q: Should status moves gain the effects of Max moves, or just be restricted?
A: I'm not sure honestly, but if they gain the max effects they would likely gain Max Guard which is absurdly broken when it doesn't take up your turn even if it does have the chance of failure on consecutive uses.
Codename C.A.T said:Second Chance
Metagame premise: Pokemon nicknamed after others(i.e. Weavile nicknamed Slowbro) will be replaced by the Pokemon they're named after once fainting. The learnset must be from the Pokemon being nicknamed, and transfers over after fainting, not accounting for the other Pokemon's learnset.
Rules
Clauses: OU clauses
Bans: OU bans + Melmetal
Unbans: None
Potential bans and threats
:zapdos-galar: Zapdos-G would absolutely love being nicknamed after a strong physical breaker or sweeper like Weavile or Garchomp. Thunderous Kick wears them down and gives them free entrance, while Brave Bird makes it somewhat easy to KO itself.
:blacephalon: :heatran: :landorus-therian: Pokemon that can KO themselves become much more deadly, as they can do huge damage and continue their offensive assault.
:toxapex: :slowbro: :tornadus-therian: Pokemon with Regenerator get a bump up in this meta, as they can try to beat the offensive threats such as Zapdos-G and Blacephalon through just outlasting them.
Questions for the community
How would Species Clause work in this meta?
What are some other breakers or walls that would get better?
How would abilities work?
This is my first submission, so I'd appreciate all the feedback I can get.
This is an interesting idea. I'm assuming you took some inspiration from Crazyhouse, but this takes it in a different direction that IMO should play out considerably differently than that meta. It seems fun to build and a bunch of field effect or momentum strategies seem really fun to play around with.
Second Chance is a little boring as a name IMO. Second Wind comes to mind, but this is super subjective.
The games are likely to end up being very long (imagine stall where you KO their Chansey after 200 turns and now they have a full health Blissey :D), which brings me to an important question: how will PP be handled? And items / status for that matter? Should the Pokemon only recover health (which it has to do or there's no point), should it be treated as if the new Pokemon was hit by a Healing Wish, or a Lunar Dance, or should it be treated as if it's fresh from team preview? My suggestion would be don't restore PP or items, but do restore status, semi-status, and HP. This seems to me to be the most balanced manner to handle this. PP being restored would make stall insanely good and stall v stall so long that roomtours would legitimately be impossible to run. HP not being restored makes the mon not actually restored oops. When a Pokemon faints I believe it usually is considered to have lost its status / semi-status, so it makes little sense to restore them on the new mon coming in. And items... well the closest parallel I can come up with is a Revive here, and I do not believe that revives restore item status.
That was an unnecessarily long paragraph sorry whew.
Questions for the community
Q: How would Species Clause work in this meta?
A: You'd probably only be able to have one total of each Pokemon. As in the nickname counts as a species. We would bow to whatever works with coding of course but this is likely the answer that is truest to the nature of species clause.
Q: What are some other breakers or walls that would get better?
A: Drampa
Q: How would abilities work?
A: This is the hard one, because there isn't a good answer. There are two answers I can see being possible. The first is that the first Pokemon's ability is passed along to the second Pokemon. This is a terrible idea specifically because it turns into Inheritance but you have to knock out the donor first. The second is it passes along the ability slot, which is somewhat of a pain to build for, especially if you do something like say Latios -> Slowbro (just two mons off the top of my head) where you only have one ability slot and the second mon really wants not to use the first. But despite the drawbacks it's still the best option imo due to being less complex than some of the other options suggested here and not turning this meta into budget Inheritance.