lol
There are obviously going to be people who hate Stealth Rock and think that it "limits and discourages creativity" but to be honest it really doesn't. Stealth Rock balances the metagame if anything, and if this new metagame (no-sr) wasn't so new and so "oh hey look what I can try" I bet most of you would be changing your mind a few weeks in. Stealth Rock keeps a lot of things in check that otherwise would have such a larger and more unfavorable effect in the metagame. HO would basically be non-existent as relying on Spikes for residual damage is unreliable at best without Rocks, and to be honest this would limit playstyles so much more than you think. If you even try to compare this metagame to ADV then you're losing ground right there. Everything in this metagame is so much stronger and more offensive and the variety is so much greater. Do you honestly think that anybody could compare the two at all even remotely?
I guess I can see where you come from by promoting synergy but lets be honest here, "synergy" and "increased creativity" are not arguments for banning Stealth Rock. We don't go on a basis of a creative metagame. Stealth Rock is almost always one of those "synergy" additions you say built in as so many sweepers (including landorus-t lololol) really like Stealth Rock as you can just continuously weaken things like Skarmory or Rotom-W over and over. Synergy is already done and tbh the extent would not be increased that greatly. It doesn't even take that much more skill if you ask me, it just makes the metagame more ridiculous.
I really don't understand your argument at all here. You say that this gen has too much raw
power but you want an added 12% damage to nearly every switch in? Thats quite a power boost to Offensive Threats like Keldeo and Terrakion, among others, if you ask me. You also say that there is nothing to punish switching, but why should there be? More switching means more predictions which means a necessity for more skilled play. More switching also allows you to scout for moves to better check Offensive Threats.
Not saying I 100% agree with everything Curtains said in his post at all but the 12% damage actually helps manage a lot of the threats and raw powerful threats in the metagame and if anything promotes more skill into out-predicting opponents and spinning / managing threats. You basically make the metagame even harder to check and countering become null in some instances. You're losing more ground than you're gaining. Keldeo / Terrakion of course gain a lot from SR, and it is possibly the best teammate to those 2, but they're still perfectly counterable (as expressed in the recent Keldeo test too), and to be honest that kind of build-up balances and even adds skill if you ask me to add passive damage and break down opponents counters with a secondary effect. You can never just stick a CB Terrak out there once and sweep right away against a decent team. And I don't think that it is even a punishment for switching at all, more switching doesn't mean more predictions. More switching isn't so amazing really, and it won't effect prediction in the way you expect. It does weaken some offensive threats a bit and make them a little more manageable in the long run especially with the OHKO-2HKO factor, but that doesn't mean more prediction. I guess you do have a higher capacity of scouting for things like HP Grass Jirachi or Expert Belt TTar, but even that kind of takes away some of the efficiency of lures if you ask me, and that doesn't exactly mean it increases skill.
You kind of are losing the ability to check so many things and overall solidity of a lot of teams if SR is gone. You're acting like you'll all of a sudden be able to cover more threats / break more threats, which is the complete opposite of what will happen. Like I said, wait a little while and you'll realize this and that the perfect picture of a "metagame with no SR" does not extend teambuilding, but limit it and make the metagame worse.
And since when are sashes everywhere a good thing????? you have to be shitting me.