Brace yourselves, folks. This is a long one.
The two users suggesting the ranking of Zoroark (Katy and Lord Iroh) make valid points despite reaching a horribly wrong conclusion. However, I decided to focus on Katy's argument for the sake of this post whilst making references to Iroh's one.
I'm also flexing my essay writing skills.
Protip: You can skip everything if you really don't care but just focus on the last two paragraphs (conclusion and the final point; in case I write anything more)
Katy said:Hello, I think you underestimate Zoroark a bit with simply saying Illusion is a meme. It has a role imho due to that in the UU tier. Also the fact it gets a wide movepool helps it out. Nasty Plot and also SD are great setup moves, bringing you to a +2 and moves like Sludge Bomb, Flamethrwer and the Dpulse coverage is pretty good. It is able to check Mega Altaria, Celebi, Chandelure which are all not rare mons at the UU tier. Sure Mega Houndoom does the job way better, but I think Zoroark can still fit on teams. So I wanna say:
Man, you are wrong on so many levels. I take it you just skimmed through my post? That's what it sounds like judging by your response. Let me break it down ™.
Katy said:Hello, I think you underestimate Zoroark a bit with simply saying Illusion is a meme.
No, I did not. Let's see what I actually said.
Velcroc said:[2] You know what? Fair point. Illusion works. In theory. (Side note: I didn't even have to emphasise this, LMAO)
Hmmm. Doesn't sound like I dismissed it as a "meme" now did I. I also happened to justify this by saying it wasn't worth it in
this meta by saying that the reason it got banned in RU has no implication on its viability in
this meta. That is (in simple words): Illusion was good enough for it to be banned in
RU but not good enough for it's ranking in
UU.
I'd also like to take you a minute to tell you the difference between a gimmick and a meme. A gimmick is a specific strategy that is based on the assumption that the opponent doesn't know what you're doing. A meme is an ironic team that aims to be as badly made as possible. A meme is also a pokemon that gained attention for being notoriously bad.
I'll change this if you on mobile
I mean come on, this is a tangent
For example:
Curse Alolan Muk = Gimmick
Ambipom = Meme
as is this
Now, Zoroark's illusion ability sounds like a gimmick doesn't it. Zoroark's ability is based on the opponent not knowing which pokemon is Zoroark (
which is difficult to pull off as I will explain later). It also hasn't received enough attention to be as infamously bad as ambipom.
Katy said:Also the fact it gets a wide movepool helps it out. Nasty Plot and also SD are great setup moves, bringing you to a +2 and moves like Sludge Bomb, Flamethrwer and the Dpulse coverage is pretty good.
Hold on! Did someone say a wide m o v e p o o l ?! Let's see what Zoroark
actually has other than hidden powers.
Physical:
*Knock off
*Sucker Punch
*Low Kick
*Shadow Claw
*Pursuit
*U-turn
Special:
*Dark Pulse
*Flamethrower
*Sludge Bomb
*Focus Blast
*Extrasensory
*Shadow Ball
*Grass Knot
Status/Utility:
*Taunt
*Foul Play (technically a move, but practically utility)
*SD/NP
*Pursuit (The other half of the time)
*Substitute
*Agility/ Calm Mind (outclassed set up moves)
*And Toxic and Protect (you don't get points for these)
As you can see, we have a colourful physical movepool consisting of 5 moves! Sounds like a spectacular Swords Dance breaker that isn't outclassed by Terrakion, Cobalion, Gliscor, Scizor, Breloom and even stuff like M-Aboma, Gatr, Absol and everybody's favourite Crawdaunt! Come on. You aren't even trying. This thing is outclassed every way to Sunday over here.
On the nasty plot side, it's alright. It has to contend against stuff like the Monkey King, Luke Skywalker and Cerberus (all pokemon that can break through the same/similar stuff) but it does have a wide m o v e p o o l. Too wide, in fact. You usually end up having TOO many moves to fit in one slot and end up missing out on coverage. For the nasty plot set this is already compounded due to having two moves set moves (Nasty Plot and Dark pulse) and you would have to choose moves accordingly. Without flamethrower or focus blast, steels are a lot tougher to face (particularly scizor) and without sludge bomb, you miss out on hitting fairies. While Sludge Bomb, Flamethrower and Dark pulse hit most of the meta, you
still miss out on walls such as Blissey (which is crucial) and the odd RU walls such as Umbreon (which has inner focus to avoid flinches) and Snorlax. And that's not including the merits of the other moves
Now let us see what it "checks". Mega Altaria.
Well, that's a wonderful first impression right there. Mega Altaria. Mega. Altaria. You do realise it'd be a pain to switch into mega altaria. And if you do happen to, it could just dragon dance in your face. Or chunks you. Listen, simply having poison move =/= fairy check. Especially if you're 'checking' one of the most resilient and versatile mons in this meta. Sure, Mega Alt can't exactly switch in but that doesn't mean that zoro checks it.
Moving on, Celebi. Now this could actually be somewhat correct. However, Celebi also has a high chance of running Colbur Berry meaning it could still end up tanking a sucker punch and end up Ko'ing it back. Other than that, zoroark
does soft check it. Chandelure. Hahaha. Nice one. Good luck tanking a specs fire blast and flamethrower. At best, Zoroark is a revenge killer.
You Keep Using That Word, I Do Not Think It Means What You Think It Means
Illusion is also not a reliable ability in UU. At best it may fool an experienced player a few times here and there; however, every time you switch out, it becomes harder and harder to conceal zoroark due to hazards. This means zoroark requires hazard control in order to work effectively. You know what else does: Mega Houndoom.
So ironically, Zoroark doesn't even patch up Mega Doom's allergy to stealth rocks (and hazards in general) because of its ability; to put it simply, it's a poor man's Houndoom. Even if your team had another Mega, I'd still prefer Hydreigon over it. It offers more speed control (scarf), more momentum and the ability to break past fairies via Z-Belch. It even has the ability to pair up with other dragons and dark types to pressure the opposing checks (Dragon Spam being good with M'Alt and Dark Spam being good in general due to lack of viable and reliable dark resistances in Pokemon as a whole - the ones that are don't like taking coverage to the face).
So no, Zoroark does not fill any role in UU. Even if it does, it fits its role on 1 or 2 teams. The Viability Rankings focuses on the meta as a whole. One or two teams are
never an accurate representation of
any metagame in
any video game.
Which brings me to my final point:
Why would you rank a mon that is so thoroughly outclassed?
Honestly, this reminds me of that Sneasel nomination a while back based on the merit "Since weavile was ranked why can't sneasel be too!!!1!". And frankly, this nomination reeks of the same pungent notion. Except it's: "Why is this mon not ranked it's BL2 !!1!!". And out of all the BL2 mons, Zoroark is the least viable. Out of the unranked mons, Durant is far, far, far better and even Sharpedo (base form) outclasses it and has an even better match up against offense. I brought this up in the last post but zoroark is outclassed by something in almost every. single. ranking. Skeptical? Well...
Here you go
D-Rank -> Nothing really comparable but Ambipom puts more pressure on offense. Both are equally bad. Arcanine also has a much larger niche in general.
And here's some more
C-
Honchkrow (mentioned it in the previous post),
Cloyster (better sweeper with actual utility),
Stoutland (better sweeper; granted weather. About the same level of viability if zoro wasn't so outclassed)
C
Barbaracle (Shell Smash)
Chesnaught (Belly Drum with perks thanks to bulletproof)
Entei (Physical wall breaker that's more difficult to switch into)
Gatr (Better set up move in DD and Sheer force + LO combo)
Linoone (Not too sure what this guy's niche is; maybe something to do with belly drum and how it's difficult to kill this thing under veil. Perhaps that)
Lycanroc (Might as well abbreviate the moves to SD, BD and so on) SD btw
C+
Aboma (Mentioned)
Absol (Likewise)
Decidueye (SD + Trapper)
Hoopa (NP + Sub)
Reuniclus (actually takes hits)
Talon (SD and Gale Wings)
Venomoth (QD)
Zygarde (Good matchup against Rotom Volt-turn (rip); Good spikes abuser; reliable priority (move acronyms too ig, ExtremeSpeed)
B-
Bewear (SD, Actual wallbreaker)
Crawdaunt
Toxicroak (Better ability, better typing)
B
Celebi (NP and SD lure)
Doublade (SD + Bulk)
Haxorus (Breaks stall so hard it's not even funny)
Kommo-o (Wallbreaks with SD, DD or BD)
Luke (SD and NP)
Necro (Odd SD & CM sets but a rocker with actual utility)
Salazzle (NP; defines this rank)
Sceptile (SD + Speed)
B+
NOT Azelf (NP sets are worse than zoro tbh)
Houndoom Mega
Terrakion (SD)
A-
Krook (Pursuiter)
Sharpedo (Sweeper)
Heracross (Sd + Guts + a stall team's nightmare)
Togekiss (NP + ParaFlinch + stallbreaker)
A
Infernape (Literally every set)
Breloom (Sd + good priority)
Cobalion (DualDance with SD and Rock Polish - Terrak does this too btw)
Muk Alola (Pursuit traps nearly every special attacker)
A+
Mega Aero (The odd Hone Claws)
Altaria (DD + Bulk + Defensive utility)
Hydreigon (scarfer)
S
Scizor (SD sets with numerous variation)
Gliscor (SD Stallbreaker)
Azu (BD)
Italic = fulfills niche outlined in the two posts and my post
Conclusion
Before you call me a "smogonite" for proving you wrong let me explain two things as clearly as I can humanly possible: I do not oppose any new rankings, in fact, I actively encourage them as they challenge the status quo (I supported Bro nom after thinking about it long and hard - for example); and I am not doing this simply to belittle you two. The nomination was, in all honesty, courageous - however flawed it may have been. The fact that you came here and contributed shows that not only this system works but that you are willing to learn. There are two types of people: those that succumb to critcism and those that learn and bounce back.
On a less sappy pretence, I would like to conclude by saying there is nothing wrong with Zoroark inherently. However, the meta as a whole is rather unkind to zoroark. Viability rankings are determined by three things: how good the mon is, its impact on the metagame (being meta defining or anti-meta) and competition from other Pokemon. Zoroark has the first criteria down pat and you can somewhat justify the second by saying zoroark is an anti-meta pick. However, what is
indisputable is that Zoroark is immensely outclassed by not only fellow dark types (1st post for more) but also by almost every set up sweeper in the tier (even excluding other niches/moves such as Dragon Dancer, Belly Drummer, Curser and so on and focusing on NP and SD).
This is why it must stay unranked
Thoughts on all of this
Man, this probably the second time I've accused of underestimating a pokemon (the first being by Geezer during the Volcanion Escapade) without the people actually reading what I wrote. Look, I realise that my writing style is pretentious and a little unbearable but if you want to prove me wrong, you have to get past this and critically analyse my work for what it is instead of reaching blind conclusions. This brash attitude to criticism and skepticism is one of the reasons why Youtube "debates" are so bloody awful.
Anyways, here's my 2 cents on the other nominations:
* Rhyperior is the most based mon I've ever seen. This thing can legitimately 1v1 gliscor if it needs to be.
100% for its rise.
*
Don't Drop the Wasp - especially considering we need to see how the meta will evolve afterwards (gliscor leaving means it's hard countered by one less thing).
* Ambivalent on Shark but since Slowbro is hot rn,
Agree
* Celebi is cool, even cooler is the fact that it can set up so easily on Hippo and Co. and break through stall/bulky/balance teams.
* Hoopa should stay C+, imo. While Alo Muk is a bit of a thorn in the side, Hoopa can potentially break through it with sub + NP + Fightinium. If anything, the presence of Gengar hurts it more (+usage of alo muk + a bit of competition)
* I say no to Swellow, bro. This can change though.
Nothing else to add (which incidentally describes why I lurk).