Many of those Zam paragraphs were a bit disappointing. Most people mentioned the big three Zam checks (Spiritomb, Escavalier and Sableye) although nobody mentioned how Sableye doesn't get Pursuit so Zam can switch out for free. Most people mentioned Pursuit, yet nobody mentioned how Focus Sash hard counters Pursuit. Weavile, Krookodile, etc - who cares if they can't OHKO with Pursuit while non-LO Focus Blast KOes them all. Sure it's inaccurate, but it's still 70% chance to hit. In fact 3/7 of the paragraphs didn't even mention Sash.
Close reading the paragraphs:
DetroitLolCat said:
Now, some people say that running a counter to Alakazam is unreasonable because it's complete dead weight on a team. That's just wrong. If a Pokemon is completely manageable in the metagame (as Alakazam is; something has hard counters then it can be managed), then running a hard counter to it will never be dead weight. Just about every sweeper in every tier in every metagame has required you to run either:
1. A specific counter
2. At least one check, preferably 2
to be beatable in the metagame. Alakazam is no different. If you run a counter, you won't lose a Pokemon. If you run some checks, you might lose one but you won't get swept. All a matter of preference.
If you run a specific counter (one of the big three) then you won't get swept. If you run a check, you CAN get swept. Here's how it happens:
Alakazam switches in, kills something.
You go to your check.
If your check has Pursuit, it's likely weak to Focus Blast. If Alakazam survives the hit with Sash (or simply because Jolly Scarf Hera Pursuit vs. non-switching out Alakazam fails to OHKO) and KOes back then you lose a second Pokemon. That's two Pokemon, and if you just lost a Scarfer then you are in trouble against a big multitude of Pokemon.
Snunch's point that it's not OU and there is no Lucario to set up on choiced Pursuit is a good one, but it should still be noted that there are plenty of deadly Pokemon that can still set up on Pursuit (Venomoth, Omastar) or simply bash something in (CB Rhyperior, CB Heracross). Also this:
Snunch said:
To close, I’d just like to add one more point. When considering if a pokemon is broken or not, I always discount arguments that revolve around one side significantly outplaying the other. Arguments like “x pokemon obviously predicts the switch into y and uses z move” and “x pokemon has trouble switching in, but can predict the opposing pokemon using a support move and come in, or it can come in on a predicted double switch” hold absolutely no ground. If one user must significantly predict for a pokemon to be effective, the door is just as open for the other user to predict the prediction, etc. I cannot tell you how many times I have stayed in against Alakazam with my fighting type as my opponent predicts the switch to my pursuiter and uses focus blast. Situations like that simply comes down to who plays better and does not support either side’s case regarding a pokemon’s tiering.
It may be personal preference but I find it hard to ignore a Pokemon that causes a 50/50 every time it switches in. Especially this one. Consider:
In your case -
If Zam uses Psychic, go to Pursuiter.
If Zam uses Focus Blast, stay in with Fighting-type.
In Zam's case -
If he switches to Pursuiter, use Focus Blast.
If he stays in with Fighting-type, use Psychic.
No matter what he does, I can use Sub.
If I have Sash, I can Psychic with little risk.
Clearly Zam has the advantage. Sub and Sash ease prediction significantly to the point that "one user must significantly predict for [Alakazam] to be effective" does not apply.
Moo said:
I'm not much of a big writer, so this'll be brief. My initial plan was to ban Alakazam. It's extremely fast and powerful, and Magic Guard is a blessing. If it can switch in unharmed, you're instantly under pressure, especially if it manages to hide safe behind a Substitute. However, a few things put a stop to it quite handily, due to its awful defenses. Special Defense Escavalier, Spritomb, Sableye, and just about every pursuiter / Scarf mon can revenge it. Yes, sashZam exists, but in my experience it was a lot weaker than LO variants, and wasn't as much of a problem most of the time. Basically, you have to have something that can take a hit from it, and KO back, or outspeed and KO it. That's not as bad as it sounds, though. The reason that it's not that bad is because most of the Pokemon that beat it are pretty good, and have great usefulness outside of countering zam. It can also be played around if you're smart. Most well built teams can usually handle an Alakazam with minimal damage, and you don't have to over focus on it, because it can usually be handled easily by one Pokemon. If I can do it, anyone can! That's why I think it should stay UU. The point I'm trying to anchor is, it does have a few great counters, and is revengable, and just because everyone and their mother doesn't counter it, doesn't mean that it's broken. I'm not denying that it's very powerful, but it's managable if you use your brain.
Props to Moo for being the first person to mention Sash, but the reasoning behind not going for BL is rather sparse. "In my experience it was a lot weaker than LO variants" isn't an argument, because I can (truthfully) say that in my experience Sash Zam was a lot more effective than LO variants. Being able to outspeed and KO, or take a hit and KO, is true enough, but you need examples or you can say the same for Deoxys-A being UU (you can beat Deoxys-A if you outspeed and KO, or can take a hit and KO ...).
Moo alludes to "Pokemon that beat it" and says "[Alakazam] is revengable", but doesn't list examples. I presume the Pokemon that beat it are the same big three (or Snunch's Aerodactyl in sand), but to say that all four are pretty good and have uses outside dealing with Alakazam takes some justification imo. Yes, they aren't useless, but I'm doubtful about Spiritomb's for example in any meta without Alakazam i.e. it's only there for dealing with Alakazam. Sure it covers other threats, but most of them can be better handled by something else. Revenging it ... is a different matter. If you're facing an Alakazam at 100% health and possibly toting a Focus Sash, what revenges it without being obvious and thus easily played around? It's easy to tell if a Pokemon outspeeds Alakazam and therefore switch out. It's also easy to tell if a Pokemon has Pursuit and therefore stay in (this choice is especially easy if Zam has Sash). I guess Pokemon like Crobat and Scarf Flygon can U-turn safely on Alakazam, but they don't kill Alakazam. Since Alakazam unlike other Pokemon cannot be worn down by passive damage, this is a significant thing.
SJCrew said:
On the subject of Alakazam, I feel as though he's more or less wormed his way into a really convenient metagame for him. Passive damage is at an all-time high because of the dominance of Sand and entry hazards, and a lot of teams demand his presence. Getting past him is not easy at all unless you're packing a dedicated counter, but fortunately, there are some of those. I know of at least three fail-safe counters (Spiritomb, Sableye, Escavalier), maybe more (Scarf Flygon is not KOed by any of his moves), and Pursuit users can get rid of him for good (50/50 if he's running a Sash). Krook's been seeing a lot of usage lately, Weavile is still around, and Stoutland keeps him in line, along with the rest of offense.
The LO/Sash bluff is his biggest offense, in my opinion, but Focus Sash Alakazam just doesn't bring home the KOs he needs to, making it easier to handle him on the defense regardless. Just keep around a nice special tank with recovery and you shouldn't fear him outlasting your checks. UU from me.
I can mostly agree with SJCrew's paragraph, but pointing out a few things: it's actually 70/30 if Zam has a Sash (Focus Blast hit rate), unless the Pursuiter is something like Scarf Heracross when it's 100/0 in favour of Alakazam. Also Scarf Flygon does not OHKO with U-turn while being 2HKOed by Psychic, so if it switches into Sash Alakazam and does not use U-turn it's dead - although personally I'd be inclined to switch Alakazam out and save the Sash. That would lose momentum, but as long as Alakazam has a Sash it'll be
very effective later in the game.
Heysup said:
Against Alakazam, offense does not really need a switch but what can even revenge kill it effectively. Scarf Pursuit is probably one of the most idiotic solutions I have heard so far, considering it gives your opponent a free attack against you. If your opponent has remotely close to your skill level, obviously they won't send something in that you can easily handle. They'll send in their Band Cross, Rhyperior, Shell Smasher, etc and make you pay for that. Not to mention, Scarf Pursuiters mean you always need to sacrifice one Pokemon to Alakazam anyway, since he OHKOed all of them with Focus Blast. The only way to beat Alakazam with an offensive team is to severely outplay your opponent with a U-turn / Pursuit user or by keeping momentum and just sweeping through it. The difficulty here is that, assuming your opponent is good, you will not always have momentum, and also consider that Alakazam does a very good job of changing momentum on its own due to the set mystery it provides.
Heysup mentions things that can make any Scarf Pursuit pay, which is good. I'll add that if Alakazam didn't have Magic Guard, it can be beaten much easier by offensive teams because they can sacrifice something to it and revenge. Alakazam can switch out, but it's not easy to switch in and it'll be worn down fast. Wear it down enough and it'll be vulnerable to priority. It won't have Sash either, which makes it easy to Pursuit.
Finally ToF's paragraph takes a unique approach. Judging a Pokemon by how the metagame will change without that Pokemon isn't something I do and it isn't in the characteristics of an Uber either, but then I guess to each his own. I can agree that removing Alakazam is less likely to impact the meta as removing Hippowdon. I'll point this out though:
ToF said:
Look, with Alakazam you have a good idea of what it's gonna do (abuse its special attack stat), but you don't know how it's going to achieve it (Life Orb, CM, Focus Sash, Substitute). You have definitive ways to kill it (Spiritomb, Escavalier, Sableye, Krookodile, Weavile), but once in a while you might get tripped up by the element of surprise. Hey, this kind of reminds me of what you'd call wall-breakers that can run a multitude of sets; for example, Flygon (Physical or Mixed), Kingdra (Physical or Special), Houndoom (Special or Mixed), and Tornadus (Specs or possibly Taunt + Physical). If you mispredict against any of these things, you might lose a Pokemon or two, but that doesn't imply any of these things are broken. The same applies to Alakazam; you have some things you can definitively send out, but when not carrying these counters, you might get messed up by surprise. Ladies and gents, that is the game of Pokemon. Alakazam can possibly beat you with a multitude of sets (the element of surprise), and if it does, you just need to reconsider and revamp your team to be prepared for it next time.
The only problem with that is, if you expect a physical Flygon and mispredict vs. a mixed Flygon, you can revenge it and still be in the match. This doesn't happen with Alakazam. Since it can't be worn down, you need Pursuit to eliminate it, but like I wrote before Pursuit is unreliable unless you know it doesn't have Sash, when even then you need to be faster or be able to survive a hit.
I think my biggest disappointment with everyone's paragraphs is that they don't give enough credence to the Sash set. In particular, although many people mentioned how Sash Zam does not get as many KOes (maybe, but I'm happy to switch around until the other team is weakened and then go for the cleanup), but nobody mentioned how Sash Alakazam is the ultimate revenge killer + it's very good at finishing up teams late-game. The ability to survive any single revenge kill attempt is HUGE, and makes all checks to it shaky.
That said, I haven't played any UU games for over a week now, and I'm not about to start - so gl with the tiering and feel free to ignore me :)