InkyDarkBird said:You didn't address my argument at all. I said that you completely destroy defensive Pokemon because they now lack recovery and now lack the tools to actually wall top-tier Pokemon. Skeledirge is a decent counter to Zacian-Crowned in regular Ubers that now gets completely destroyed by Zacian-Crowned because it cannot threaten Will-o-Wisp and it lacks recovery.
In fact, offensive Pokemon become ridiculously boring too, because the majority of them now can't use Dragon Dance, Swords Dance, Nasty Plot, and other setup moves, meaning that Regenerator walls will be basically impossible to defeat. This metagame also fully lacks any hazards and Knock Off, Trick, and Switcheroo also probably don't exist.
I honestly don't even think Calyrex-Shadow is good at all because it can only use Astral Barrage.
Just because you "have had real fun" means almost nothing. This metagame is not competitive and the best Pokemon will be found very quickly due to the lack of moveset diversity and need for prediction.
InkyDarkBird said:You didn't address my argument at all. I said that you completely destroy defensive Pokemon because they now lack recovery and now lack the tools to actually wall top-tier Pokemon. Skeledirge is a decent counter to Zacian-Crowned in regular Ubers that now gets completely destroyed by Zacian-Crowned because it cannot threaten Will-o-Wisp and it lacks recovery.
In fact, offensive Pokemon become ridiculously boring too, because the majority of them now can't use Dragon Dance, Swords Dance, Nasty Plot, and other setup moves, meaning that Regenerator walls will be basically impossible to defeat. This metagame also fully lacks any hazards and Knock Off, Trick, and Switcheroo also probably don't exist.
I honestly don't even think Calyrex-Shadow is good at all because it can only use Astral Barrage.
Just because you "have had real fun" means almost nothing. This metagame is not competitive and the best Pokemon will be found very quickly due to the lack of moveset diversity and need for prediction.
First of all, I don't play Ubers so I didn't know that skeladirge can be a specific counter to Zacian-Crowned, so I want to apologize for the previous message sounding rude/dismissive.
second, defensive play is valid simply because each specific mon has a forced set, so if you can counter that set you counter that mon if you can pivot well, or stop your opponent from switching via abilities although those abilities are rare (magnizone is an example)
You talked about offensive mons being boring and easily walled by regenerator.
Regenorator is not that good because only one mon has regenerator as its first ability which is tornadus-t and is ironically walled by zacian-crownd plus its not extraordinarily bulky so its not that good of a stall mon (ive tried it so that’s coming from experience)
Also offencive mons are not only playable but very good. For example Zacian-crowned gets a +1 boost from intrepid sword and has STAB behemoth blade coming off of a very impressive attack stat. This is an example of an instant damage dealer, but you also talked about reduced setup moves and while this is true agility, bulk up, and calm mind which ALL have been used well at one point or another
fouth you specifically talked about CSR being bad because it only had astral barrage, but because this gamemode restricts movesets specifically other mons struggle to have multiple great moves, and STAB astral barrage coming off of a 165 spa stat will hurt and that doesn't account for As One boosts. If you were trying to say that it gets walled by normal types it get body press, which might not ohko but will probably do at least 25-50%
Lastly, your final point was really fair. I've never dived too deep into playing OMs, and honestly i don’t know exactly what makes a metagame competitive, and assuming that you have experience in this type of format I will try to be open to suggestions.