Osra said:Rumplestiltskin said:Again, suspects where everyone gets to affect the outcome is for cases where the thing suspected in question is not a clear case, where there are valid arguments for both sides, and where the suspected things existence in the meta can be afforded.
None of the above conditions are met for Z moves, as demonstrated by the discussion so far.
This is a clear case of where a quickban applies, and it's very much needed to get some real develoment in before the month is up, and with it the OMotM ladder.
There isn't really much of a case for banning them either. Upon reading your main post for your decision to support a ban, all you seem to have done is compare apples to oranges by analyzing 2v2 in comparison to 6v6 metagames, which is already a mistake, as well as a demonstration of a lack of understanding of how your own metagame even works. The entire premise of 1v1 and 2v2 is that they are
bitesize metagames, meaning that battles will naturally go by faster in comparison to traditional 6v6 metagames.
Rumplestiltskin said:A Z-move KO in 6v6 is not much of a big deal, you lost 1 poke, that’s 1/6ths out of your team. In 2v2 you lost half your team, turning it into a 1v1, which could quite possibly be the worse match-up for you, decided by the z-move user, simply due to its sheer power. Now of course OHKO’s can happen without Z-moves, but when they happen it’s because of a really strong move (covered below), type advantages, and difference in stats. And in the case where the Z-attack didn’t KO, it still does significantly more damage than it ever would have done otherwise, which is devastating (aka most likely game ruining) for the surviving poke.
...which emphasizes the point of your lack of understanding as to how bitesize metagames even work.
This is literally the way bitesize metagames are played...
Comparing to 6v6 because thats what the standard battles are, and to highlight that Z was made and balanced for standard battles. You're trying to discredit my argument just by stating that there is a difference in the things compared, without addressing the actual point. And bitesize? What? You coming up with a collective name for 1v1 and 2v2 Doubles, and describing how they currently play out doesn't demonstrate a lack of understanding of said metas on my part, let alone address any of my arguments regarding this case. What does battles going faster have anything to do with what I've been talking about? How does battles going faster justify reducing skill and allowing a broken and unhealthy element?
Rumplestiltskin said:The main reason: Z was balanced by its creator Game Freak by being limited to being used once per battle, with a battle being 6v6. Which means that Z is usable on 1/6 of your team and usable once per battle. In 2v2 Doubles it’s usable on ½ of your team, which corresponds to z being usable on 3/6 of your team in a 6v6 battle and usable 3 times per battle. That’s 3 times the impact on the battle. Getting hit by a Z attack in 2v2 Doubles is the same as getting hit by a Z attack 3 times in 6v6. This enough is reason for a ban, however simple you might think the reason is.
This entire argument can also be applied to Mega Evolution, yet you don't seem to be trying to convince us that Megas are broken, hmmm? You're just cherry picking based off of your own personal agenda. And before you try to undercut the argument by saying that "Mega Evolution is limited to certain Pokemon", bear in mind that there are
more Mega Evolutions total than there are problematic Pokemon that abuse Z-Moves, as outlined in my previous post.
You're missing the point. The argument/point can better be explained by
Rumplestiltskin said:Another thing that should be obvious, but might not be to everyone (thanks
qsns), is the factor that compared to 6v6, 2v2 Doubles doesn't have the rest of the game to even out the impact of the Z moves. This could probably already be inferred from my analysis here, but to clarify further, with Z allowed, 2v2 Doubles is centered around the part of the game where Z is used, a part which in regular games is only a fraction of the entire game. Which as I keep stressing, takes the metagame way more into the "kill or be killed ASAP" type of battles, which is undesirable for a healthy metagame.
where as I'm going to explain, isn't the same impact a mega has.
I have already conceded that megas should be held to more scrutiny here due to the reduced opportunity cost, however, there are still major differences from Z. Smogon classifies megas as their own pokes (
Separate Tiering of Mega Pokemon). The differences that each mega stone brings can vastly differ from stone to stone, and ultimately in many cases bring the users to a level that existing pokes already are on, meaning there isn't any difference facing a poke that used a mega evolution to become said poke or not, in contrast to how Z attacks provide a previously unavailable nuke, with none of the usual and accepted costs, to every poke.
Rumplestiltskin said:“But Rumplestiltskin, why not just ban the pokes that you say become unmanageable due to Z-moves?”
Because it would mean losing a majority (if not all) of all offensive pokes at the very least, and the meta would still be unbalanced due to the massive power boost to everything (the unfair gameplay mentioned above).
Actually proven wrong. My previous post showed that there are actually only a handful of threats that can abuse Z-Moves to an extent that cannot be emulated without the use of Z-Moves.
And regarding your previous post, you picked the pokes based on a subjective standard that doesnt reflect on reality in the 1st 2 steps. There's no reason to only pick 100 pokes when I've been arguing about how Z affects the entire meta. Even ignoring why the list is bad, a lot of pokes that used sash opt for Z now. And in the second step where the list is shortened, the standards used to make it are subjective and unjustified.
Osra said:The reason why the 23 pokemon are being removed from the list is because they only emulate the process of optimal move selection, ie Thunderbolt>Thundershock. The Pokemon that stayed are all either those that are capable of doing something they otherwise couldn't without Z-Moves, or are capable of setting up in order to launch a nuclear attack that far surpasses anything the pokemon would otherwise be capable of. This list also abided by the ruling of a setup move being at least 5% usage among all of their most used moves.
- "Optimal" is being used subjectively here, there might be some pokes which absolutely always have no reason to use Z over an established item, but there will always be uses for Z, or other items for that matter that results in them being able to deal with different things, or aid their partners in certain ways. And the difference of using Z over an established item is nowhere near as significant as the difference of "Thunderbolt>Thundershock".
- The fact that Z users can setup was never the sole argument for ban.
- Having Z is already doing something they otherwise couldn't, which is being able to deal extra damage without being choiced, losing HP with every attack, or ignoring the various negative effects of stronger attacks.
And the last step, where the list is shortened based on OU usage is entirely irrelevant when the meta only had a ladder for 1 month, and I hope I shouldn't have to explain why, just look up how Smogon tiers work.
In any case, as I pointed out before,
Rumplestiltskin said:banning a bunch of Z users wouldn't solve anything as there would still be Z users, aka problems due to Z would still be there as outlined by the analysis, and new users would still rise to the subjective standard set in that post.
So, no, there is nothing proven wrong.
Osra said:Rumplestiltskin said:A Z-move KO in 6v6 is not much of a big deal, you lost 1 poke, that’s 1/6ths out of your team. In 2v2 you lost half your team, turning it into a 1v1, which could quite possibly be the worse match-up for you, decided by the z-move user, simply due to its sheer power. Now of course OHKO’s can happen without Z-moves, but when they happen it’s because of a really strong move (covered below), type advantages, and difference in stats. And in the case where the Z-attack didn’t KO, it still does significantly more damage than it ever would have done otherwise, which is devastating (aka most likely game ruining) for the surviving poke.
You say all of this as if you yourself cannot do the same unto your opponent. This really isn't even an argument against Z-Moves as much as it is just an argument against Offense as a whole, which emphasizes the point of your lack of understanding as to how bitesize metagames even work.
The argument against Z rather than offense as a whole is literally in the quote. The differences are explained and there's no implification of or even a hint at offense as a whole being unfair. Not sure what you're trying to do here apart from trying to discredit my argument to make me seem biased by just making an absolutely baseless statement.
Rumplestiltskin said:Other strong moves are limited by their distribution, negative side effects, accuracy, and conditions. Which also means that you can play accordingly. And the distribution limit is significant because it incorporates all of the limits that the poke the move is limited to has, and if a poke with access to such a strong move doesn’t have enough limits, you usually see it banned in Smogon tiers/metas.
Speaking of which- Near every Pokemon has access to a strong move that they can use without having to be Z. Unfortunately, though, the matter of "how much limitation is enough limitation" is an objective question that can only be given subjective answers, which ties in to the lacking clarity that you yourself acknowledge is a prerequisite for suspect testing.
There's no need to be "speaking of which", strong moves were already detailed right below the passage you're replying to, where it showed that no, not "near every pokemon".
Rumplestiltskin said:Let’s go over distribution first (excluding banned pokes, smeargle, NFE’s unless relevant, and moves with not so limited distribution (those will be covered in the other list)), and I hope I don’t have to go over the weaknesses and limits of each poke to get this point across.
Distribution:
- V-Create
- Victini, Rayquaza (banned)
- Prismatic Laser
- Blast Burn, Hydro Cannon, Frenzy Plant
- starter pokes, Arceus (no Frenzy Plant, banned)
- Eruption
- Typhlosion, Entei, Camerupt, Torkoal, Heatran, Groudon (banned)
- Water Spout
- Wailord, Jellicent, Blastoise, Octillery, Kyogre (banned)
- Rock Wrecker
- Head Smash
- Aegislash, Aggron, Archeops, Basculin, Corsola, Cranidos, Donphan, Emboar, Hydreigon, Nidoking, Nihilego, Rampardos, Relicanth, Scrafty, Sudowoodo, Turtonator, Tyrantrum
- Roar of Time
- Darkrai, Arceus (banned), Dialga (banned)
- Shell Trap
- Doom Desire
- Psycho Boost
- Deoxys and its formes, Lugia (banned)
- Freeze Shock
- Ice Burn
- Boomburst
- Chatot, Exploud, Flygon, Noivern, Pikipek, Swellow, Toucannon
- High Jump Kick
- Blaziken, Hawlucha, Hitmonchan, Hitmonlee, Hitmontop, Lopunny, Lucario, Medicham, Mienshao, Pheromosa, Scrafty, Tsareena
Negative side effects / accuracy / conditions
- Explosion / Selfdestruct, 250 / 200 BP
- V-Create, 180 BP
- 95% accuracy, Lowers the user's Defense, Sp. Def, Speed by 1.
- Prismatic Laser, 160 BP
- User cannot move next turn.
- Hyper Beam / Giga Impact / Rock Wrecker / Blast Burn / Hydro Cannon / Frenzy Plant / Roaor of Time, 150 BP
- 90% accuracy, user cannot move next turn.
- Focus Punch, 150 BP
- Fails if the user takes damage before it hits.
- Eruption / Water Spout, 150 BP
- Less power as user's HP decreases.
- Head Smash, 150 BP
- 80% accuracy, has 1/2 recoil.
- Shell Trap, 150 BP
- User must take physical damage before moving.
- Sky Attack, 140 BP
- 90% accuracy, charges, then hits turn 2.
- Doom Desire, 140 BP
- Hits two turns after being used.
- Psycho Boost, 140 BP
- 90% accuracy, lowers the user's Sp. Atk by 2.
- Last Resort, 140 BP
- Fails unless each known move has been used.
- Psycho Boost, 140 BP
- 90% accuracy, charges, then hits turn 2.
- Skull Bash, 130 BP
- Charges, then hits turn 2.
- High Jump Kick, 130 BP
- 90% accuracy, user is hurt by 50% of its max HP if it misses.
- Draco Meteor / Leaf Storm / Overheat / Fleur Cannon, 130 BP
- Lowers the user's Sp. Atk by 2.
As you can see
all the moves listed (bar Boomburst) have accuracy deficiencies / negative side effects / conditions, with most of them also having limited to extremely limited distribution. This applies to all attacks down to 110 BP in one or multiple ways. I don’t know why I felt I had to make this list, it’s just ridiculous that someone actually thought Z attacks and regular high BP attacks are the same.
And it's not subjective when Z is usable on all pokes, with the only cost being that it's usable once, and that it requires an item slot, while attacks with BP as low as 110 start having worse accuracy deficiencies / negative side effects / conditions, compared to Z's 200's, with most of them also having limited to extremely limited distribution. So no, there is no lack of clarity here.
Rumplestiltskin said:Where such power was once due to a selection of pokes with big offensive stats, pokes with access to devastating moves, and pokes with type advantages, it is now available to pretty much any poke without utterly horrible offensive stats (which is the majority of viable pokes, if not the majority of all pokes). Where such pokes were once utilized for their other traits, traits for strats such as setup, support, walling, or whatever else, they can now have a strong attack (as in strength comparable to pokes that specialized in attacking) in addition to their role/use. That alone makes for unfair gameplay as such pokes now in addition to their specialization also get to nuke. This scales down the entire system of pokemon archetypes. And due to the sheer power of Z attacks, even the system of type effectiveness is scaled down to almost nothing. Who needs type effectiveness when you can just use Z to nuke everything not immune? Edit: A more accurate description of the reality is that the battle heavily hinges on type effectiveness more than anything else, with Z still being able to nuke its way through type disadvantages to varying extents, moreso than regular moves ever could. Again keep in mind that even if the same applies to 6v6, the impact is tripled here. Now if Z-moves can provide such power to pokes that didn’t specialize in attacking, what do they provide to pokes that do? They make them unmanageable to deal with through any means other than outspeeding them and KO’ing them before they do the same to you.
This all just ties into the concept of optimal move selection that I brought up briefly in my previous post. When would you ever not pick the best move you can to use in most situations? Aromatisse would never use Fairy Wind over Moonblast, Tapu Koko would never use Thunder over Gigavolt Havoc
unless you already have, etc.
Are you sure you're replying to the right thing there? Optimal move selection has absoluetly nothing to do with the passage you're quoting and why Z moves are bad for the meta.
The main matter is outlining what constitutes as being "too much", and a good couple of minutes in the damage calculator will show you that most Z-Moves used by non-offensive Pokemon amount to little more if even more than just a regular attack from a standard Offensive Pokemon, which mainly just makes it a contextual matter, certainly not "too much" for the metagame to handle. The real issue comes when you get into Offensive Z-Moves, as those are the real issues, and should be handled on a case-to-case basis, especially if you want your metagame to have any kind of longevity behind it.
and a good couple of minutes in the damage calculator will show you that most Z-Moves used by non-offensive Pokemon amount to little more if even more than just a regular attack from a standard Offensive Pokemon
That's exactly the point. You're literally reiterating my argument. Non-offensive pokes are non-offensive and don't do the same damage as offensive pokes because they give that damage up for being whatever archetype they are, for being able to do whatever they're able to do that offensive pokes can't. Them getting access to that damage without any turns used
scales down the entire system of pokemon archetypes. This by itself is already sufficient enough reason for quickban.
Rumplestiltskin said:“But Rumplestiltskin, why not just ban the pokes that you say become unmanageable due to Z-moves?”
Because it would mean losing a majority (if not all) of all offensive pokes at the very least, and the meta would still be unbalanced due to the massive power boost to everything (the unfair gameplay mentioned above).
... As for the "unfair gameplay", it's only literally unfair for people who either don't know that Z-Moves exist, or
purposefully choose not to use them :eyes:
Rumplestiltskin said:A Z-move KO in 6v6 is not much of a big deal, you lost 1 poke, that’s 1/6ths out of your team. In 2v2 you lost half your team, turning it into a 1v1, which could quite possibly be the worse match-up for you, decided by the z-move user, simply due to its sheer power. Now of course OHKO’s can happen without Z-moves, but when they happen it’s because of a really strong move (covered below), type advantages, and difference in stats. And in the case where the Z-attack didn’t KO, it still does significantly more damage than it ever would have done otherwise, which is devastating (aka most likely game ruining) for the surviving poke.
You say all of this as if you yourself cannot do the same unto your opponent.
So you're admitting that Z-moves allow for unfair gameplay, but that it can be avoided by simply using the very thing in question brought up for ban. You realize that argument is in direct conflict with
Smogon's Tiering Policy Framework?
Tiering Policy Framework said:III.) Broken - elements that are too good relative to the rest of the metagame such that "more skillful play" is almost always rendered irrelevant.
- These aren't necessarily completely uncompetitive because they don't take the determining factor out of the player's hands; both can use these elements and both probably have a fair chance to win. They are broken because they almost dictate / require usage, and a standard team without one of them facing a standard team with one of them would be at a drastic disadvantage.
This emphasizes your lack of understanding of what broken means, how Smogon does things, and balance logic in general.
Rumplestiltskin said:In a meta where surviving is a massive struggle due to focus fire, and where power dominates, the addition of Z-moves, taking said power to a whole other level unbalances the meta too much and takes it even more in the direction of outspeed-and-KO ASAP type of battles. It utterly dumbs down the meta when not even type effectiveness or poke archetypes matter much any more.
This is literally the way bitesize metagames are played. Just because it's your preference that the metagame shouldn't be inherently one way or the other doesn't mean that your preference is anything more than just a preference. And everyone has a preference, which ties even further to lack of clarity and thus the need for a suspect.
You're referring to that 1v1 and 2v2 Doubles are inherently fast paced, and accusing me of preferring them to not be like that, while I didn't allude to such a preference. Of course 1v1 and 2v2 Doubles are going to be faster paced than 6v6, but my argument was about Z causing the meta being disproportionately so, it's an argument about having balanced meta. Preferring the meta to be balanced is valid, while preferring the meta to be unbalanced (proven to be the case in the discussion about Z) doesn't make sense to cater to. Again, this is not simply preference or opinion.
Explanation literally follows in the same paragraph you quoted from. Not sure if serious here.
Rumplestiltskin said:If one Z-crystal is broken then they all are, this isn't monotype where you ban things based on type. If a Z-crystal is broken, it isn't because of its type, but because of the other reasons mentioned.
Osra said:Rumplestiltskin said:Just because some of the most used pokes resist the Bug type doesn't mean that Buginium-Z does what it does any differently than the other Z crystals. It just means that it will do less damage against the pokes that resist the Bug type, which shouldn't hold any relevance to balancing unless you're saying “screw the pokes that don't resist Bug”. You could also mean that no currently strong popular poke has X-type to use X-type Z-crystal with, which again shouldn't hold relevance because I'm arguing that Z is broken for what it is and does nonetheless, regardless of how popular a certain type Z-crystal is.
No, that's exactly what it means. Everything that has been banned for being broken,
ever, was banned because it performed too well within the specific context of the metagame it was removed from. Please do not try to push your agenda of favoritism towards irrelevant Pokemon that hold little to no impact on the metagame.
...You're just cherry picking based off of your own personal agenda...
You're not refuting the point that for instance "Buginium-Z does what it does any differently than the other Z crystals", by saying "no, that's exactly what it means". In any case you don't see certain Arceus formes like Arceus-Bug unbanned in OU for example, because it's still Arceus, and it still does what it does. And STABmons didn't only ban certain Silvally formes based on type.
And regarding the "agenda", where did I even hint at having such an agenda? And how is said agenda even relevant to banning all Z crystals over only some? If I have any "agenda" it's to have the metas I play be competitive, balanced, and healthy.
Rumplestiltskin said:First of all, while some pokes become more viable, others take a hit. Second of all, become viable at what cost? You don’t allow something broken just because it makes more pokes viable. In fact, I’d wager it’s a given that broken moves would make more pokes viable. If Perish Song was allowed on more pokes, we would get more viable pokes then too. And when it got banned in 1v1 for example Lapras and Murkrow fell real hard in viability. Just because something makes more pokes viable doesn’t mean it’s not broken, and you don’t keep broken stuff in a metagame just because they make more pokes viable.
I do agree that broken elements shouldn't be included for the sake of influencing other elements within the metagame, however, Z-Moves aren't broken; a mechanic of a game cannot be inherently good, bad, "too" good, or "too" bad, as they are just tools for the users that
can become all of these things. You cannot remove an entire concept or mechanic from something simply because you lack the desire to adapt to the environment changing around you. If an individual element or elements become a problem, then each of those elements should be handled individually.
So you're saying evasion can't be inherently uncompetitive, instead ban only the "evasion abusers" or ban only
some evasion moves, OHKO moves can't be inherently uncompetitive, instead ban only the "OHKO abusers" or ban only
some OHKO moves, Eviolite can't be broken in Averagemons, instead ban only the Eviolite abusers, Perish Song can't be broken, overcentralizing, and unhealthy, instead ban only the Perish Song abusers.
And regarding wanting Z banned because I can't adapt, that really isn't a valid argument. 1st of all you have no idea of whether me or anyone who wants Z banned hasn't adapted to it. Second, adapting to something doesn't make it lose all of the traits that made it banworthy.
Also regarding
...Please do not try to push your agenda of favoritism towards irrelevant Pokemon that hold little to no impact on the metagame.
...You cannot remove an entire concept or mechanic from something simply because you lack the desire to adapt to the environment changing around you.
a little sprinkle of ad hominem here and there, nice.
TGC Disunited said:Possible Precedents for a Z-Move Ban
Z-moves are the hot topic in 2v2 dubs right now, so I decided on weighing in with my opinion, which I shall try to back up with facts.
So one of the big reasons that people say we shouldn't ban Z-Moves is that, well, Smogon metagames rarely ban anything other than actual Pokémon. But it has happened that other parts of the game have been banned. In this post, I will show some applicable examples, namely Items, Mechanics, and Moves, to decide whether Z-moves fit the mold that these earlier bans do.
Short answer: no.
Long answer: read on.
MOVES
In the history of Generation 7's official ladders, exactly five different moves have been banned that I could find after going through banlists. These are:
Move(meta)
Sonic Boom(LC)
Dragon Rage(LC)
Perish Song(1v1, 2v2)
Dragon Ascent(Ubers)
Swagger(pretty much everywhere)
and ohko moves everywhere but AG but I'm not listing them individually
Now, we can rule out Dragon Ascent, as it is merely a part of the ban of Rayquaza-Mega, which requires Dragon Ascent to Mega Evolve, which is banned under the Mega Rayquaza Clause in Ubers. And Swagger is only banned because Pokémon becomes a coinflip.
So what do the remaining moves have in common? They each OHKO the opposing Pokémon, regardless of attacker or defender, barring sturdy/Focus Sash or an immunity. Yes, in LC nothing gets above 40 hp so nothing can live Dragon Rage, and the number of things that get above 20 HP(for Sonic Boom) is few. Perish Song OHKOes both after 3 turns, so if no one can switch, gg xD.
OHKO moves obviously OHKO everything, albeit with shaky accuracy.
So do Z-Moves do this? Do they all OHKO the opposing Pokémon no matter what uses it and what defends against it, barring SturdySash or an immunity? No! As I can testify, Ludicolo does not always even OHKO Charizard X with Icium Z-boosted Ice Beam (yes, I've been in that matchup. Don't ask.) As an added detriment vs. those other moves, Z-Moves use up your item slot! No more UltraSweeper(tm) Charmander with dragon rage running Scarfed through the meta. No more Choice Scarf to let your Kartana beat Tapu Koko or Choice Band to let it beat Charizard. Instead, you get a one-off item that only boosts one move, maybe not even your STAB.
Z-Moves, therefore, do not fit the precedent of move bans.
And Swagger did not OHKO pokes so it did not fit the precedent either at the time it was banned.
ITEMS
Item bans are realllllly fucking rare, just gonna say that. After looking through like everything I could find, there's some mega stones, Soul Dew, and like... uh... Light Ball in Mediocremons?
oh yeah also Kommonium here and Eevium in LC
So what do these bans all have in common, kids?
Well, gee, Mister TGC, it looks like they're all items that are mon-specific!
Correctamundo! As Z-Moves can be applied to all Pokémon, for the most part (obviously mimikium can't be), they do not create an imbalance in mon power like these Mega Stones and other items do.
Hence, they do not fit the precedent.
Except that Eviolite (Averagemons, Scalemons), and Focus Sash (1v1, 2v2 Doubles) can also be applied to all pokemon, so not even by your standards does this make sense.
MECHANICS
All of Smogon's clauses are really kinda metagame specific, and none of them are even applicable, bar Swagger and MRay, which I already brought up, so uhh... I DONE NOW
there I finally posted some facts
Not really sure what you're trying to say here.
In any case, I'd like to stress what I've already said:
Rumplestiltskin said:The move Perish Song is banned in both 1v1 and 2v2 Doubles due to circumstances caused by the format, same goes for the accuracy dropping moves in 1v1. Items get banned too if needed, most recent being Focus Sash in 2v2 Doubles (however questionable that quickban was) and in 1v1 since gen6. Different formats require different actions to achieve the goal, which is a competitive, balanced, and healthy metagame. A multitude of reasons for why Z moves as a whole don't belong in 2v2 Doubles has already been outlined and justified using Smogon guidelines and general logic for a balanced and healthy metagame.
directed at both this and the last point made in
Osra's post.
I want to get this posted before replying to
Wrath of Alakazam, and this post is becoming too long.
Meanwhile, directed at anyone intending to post regarding a balance subject: If you haven't already, read and
understand these posts before posting:
Characteristics of a Desirable Pokemon Metagame
Tiering Policy Framework (Don't get hung up on the parts that only are relevant for 6v6 etc, use common sense)
For a progressive discussion and for not wasting people's effort and time.