Storm Eagle said:I should probably address two points here which I feel are important.
View attachment 235774
First, Imposter. Imposter has always been a staple of BH, but I wouldn't say it holds the meta together. Its presence has always led to a unique teambuilding process known as imposter-proofing. Imposter-proofing is when you add checks to your own pokemon on your team. The idea being Imposter has a much more difficult time getting any momentum upon switching in. Almost anything can be an improof. I've even used Imposter as an improof to my pokemon as Imposter doesn't activate on transformed pokemon and Snorlax/Munchlax (and Chansey in gen 7) are already good special walls.
There's a few issues with this, though. Not all improofs are perfect. Not all situations will be the same. Sometimes Imposter can gain momentum by pivoting when you switch in your improof, a specific scenario being a FC/Scales improof for a Band/Specs mon. Here's an example of one of my teams here.
Choice user and improof
:xy/kyurem-white:
Kyurem-White @ Choice Specs
Ability: Refrigerate
EVs: 252 HP / 252 Atk / 252 Def / 252 SpA / 252 SpD / 252 Spe
Modest Nature
- Boomburst
- Dynamax Cannon
- Earth Power
- U-turn
Note: Volt Switch is usually standard on Specs users but U-turn is fine if you're improofing with a Water-type.
:xy/primarina:
Primarina @ Assault Vest
Ability: Regenerator
EVs: 252 HP / 252 Atk / 252 Def / 252 SpA / 252 SpD
Sassy Nature
IVs: 0 Spe
- Volt Switch
- Moonblast
- Scald
- Spectral Thief
Fairly standard specs Kyu-W set. It's improofed by this Primarina set. It's not the greatest example, but Imposters can gain momentum by pivoting off my Primarina. Otherwise Kyurem-W cannot do anything to Primarina. Also of note RegenVest users can still thrive in the meta despite Ice Scales having higher usage, as I've said in my previous post. There are other Pokemon which can work as improofs for Kyurem-W as well, such as Ice Scales Snorlax, but I specifically chose Primarina for my use case.
Imposter can also use Dynamax to its advantage to try and break improofs. But both of these scenarios are controlled specifically by your teambuilding. Even with Dynamax, Imposter usually fails to break good improofs. I know momentum is much more difficult to deal with, which is why some mons will forego pivoting moves in favor of trapping moves. This is seen more often on defensive pokemon because they can afford the moveslot and also denying Imposter the opportunity to heal itself is critical. Anchor Shot Melmetal is a common example. Trapping Imposter will guarantee they faint because they only have 5 PP on each move.
I personally do not agree with this due to the reasons outlined above. Given you can control every aspect of your team, you can also control how effective Imposter is at any given time. It's difficult, and I am not saying it's necessarily healthy for the metagame as I've seen legitimate arguments saying it restricts teambuilding, but it can be done. One thing I should point out is that I see "hyper offense" being mentioned a lot in this thread. Hyper offense doesn't exist beyond Shell Smash spam, and it never will because of Imposter. If your team is too offensive, even in the context of spamming Shell Smash, Imposter can and
will beat you. "True" HO cannot exist in BH as it currently stands. The logic being if your team cannot be improofed, it won't win against Imposter. Even in Gen 7 where the amount of options were nearly unlimited, building a "true" HO team was nearly impossible. In Gen 8, you will only ever see balance teams, with very occasional semi-stall.
Now, the main reason I wanted to talk about Imposter was a point abriel gabram brought up.
One quirk with BH that has always existed is Imposter rises in viability with setup. The more you see Shell Smash, the more you see Imposter. This is because Imposter is often used at the highest level of play specifically as a check to setup. Scarf Imposter is used to get the upper hand on Shell Smash sweepers. It is the only reliable offensive check due to Dazzling. The only reliable defensive check is Prankster Haze. But I would not call this healthy for the meta. The only reason Imposter is seeing increased use recently is due to Shell Smash. Deal with Shell Smash and Imposter use goes down. Same stuff happened in Gen 7 when people were discussing Shell Smash as a potential issue. Whenever Shell Smash usage spiked, be it through an RMT or something else, Imposter usage usually followed.
---
Secondly, I would like to speak about setup again. Belly Drum was brought up as something of concern should we ban Shell Smash. I should note that one of the reasons Shell Smash is so difficult to deal with is because it enables physical, special, and mixed attackers simultaneously, and on top of this it boosts speed. Belly Drum does not boost speed (Unburden was already mentioned). Of the setup moves that do boost speed, Shift Gear gives half the boosts smash does and does not boost Special Attack, while Quiver Dance boosts Special Defense rather than Attack and also gives half the boosts. One thing about Shell Smash is it's immediately threatening turn two, whereas every single other setup move is either not as strong or has drawbacks. Shell Smash does have a drawback, but reducing defenses means very little with White Herb and Focus Sash. Sometimes even then it doesn't matter.
Every single other setup move is more manageable either through requiring more setup to be equally threatening or having drawbacks that are more noticeable than Shell Smash. They're more manageable by simply having more checks as well. Spectral Thief alone makes other forms of setup much more difficult.
I think one thing to consider for your argument is that Shell Smash, on Unburden sets or not, will use other items like White Herb, or Focus Sash, which means that it achieves a flat +2 (2 x) boost.
Quiver Dance, and Shift Gear provide a flat +1 (1.5 x) boost, but if you add Life Orb, that makes the 1.5 x 1.3 = 1.95
This means you don’t have to stick for situational one time use items like Focus Sash, or White Herb, and you get a 1.3 x boost before you even set up.
This is the same as using Tough Claws (or Adaptability) and Choice Band/Specs, versus Shell Smash.
The difference is 5%, or equal (in the case of Adaptability boosting 1/3, rather than 30%).
Ultimately while you could technically get away with Life Orb and Shell Smash, it’s a bigger risk when you have compromised your Defenses.
If your argument is: Shell Smash boosts 2 x while Quiver Dance boosts 1.5 x - then bear in mind this only really makes a difference when you use Simple, or boost with Shell Smash multiple times in a row, when comparing non-Life Orb Shell Smash to Life Orb Shift Gear / Quiver Dance.
Another boosting move not mentioned is Throat Spray + Clangorous Soul. Which provides an immediate +1 to all stats, and then another +1 to Spa for +2 SpA total. That also raises defenses, by 1.5 which more than makes up for lowering HP by 1/3.
Shell Smash without White Herb cuts both Defenses by 1/3 at -1 Def / SpD, so it looks equivalent, before you consider Clangorous Soul boosts Def / SpD.
Both can be used for Power Trip and Stored Power, even on Simple sets, as Throat Spray allows it to equal Shell Smash in terms of SpA boosts, without compromising Defense/SpD stats (now doubling Defenses and even more so that before making up for the HP Drop).
Lastly, Throat Spray can be used on Unburden sets to boost SpA and keep up with Shell Smash. Since Unburden is a one-time use, it doesn’t feel like a compromise to use Throat Spray since you are going to lose Unburden on switch outs, regardless.
So I think if you are using Life Orb that keeps Shift Gear Quiver Dance on par with Shell Smash, and Clangorous Soul + Throat Spray on par with Shell Smash.
Plus, getting switched into any chip damage like hazards compromised Focus Sash, so Life Orb is much more reliable on a Quiver Dance or Shift Gear, for consistence, than Focus Sash Shell Smash.
Lastly, like Clangorous Soul, Quiver Dance helps you Imposterproof thanks to the raised SpD. This was exemplified by Xerneas last generation.
So besides Speed, which is tied by Shift Gear - regardless, it can be really difficult to view non-Life Orb Shell Smash as much better unless you are using Simple, and even then Clangorous Soul + Throat Spray can be used to get a matching SpA boost.