Blazade said:I've recently found that I've kind of stagnated and I'm not really sure what I can do about it. I've always found that I do better when my relationship with a girl has time to mature from a friendship and in a few cases it may have gotten as far as love. However now I find that the only way I can meet new people is by pulling teeth and going out to bars or other one off things where I can't possibly get to know someone well enough to develop a real attraction.
I don't feel comfortable in these kind of mingle heavy settings, I have no idea how to steer the conversation out of small talk and somehow in spite of that I'm often told I get too deep into conversation. Even if I have what I consider to be good small talk I have no idea what they got out of it. Anyone that's ever been attracted to me has with very few exceptions had to get to know me well first where they'd find I have a lot to offer personality wise.
Like I know I'm bad at selling myself especially because my interests are also pretty niche and that doesn't fucking help any. I'm always interested to talk about something the other person is passionate about and learn more but I can never seem to coax that kind of thing out of them early for whatever reason. It's really frustrating like maybe all some people do is think about their day to day lives and social circle but it can't be as bad as I'm seeing. And first dates that I get off of Tinder and shit aren't any better most of the time.
Am I missing something out here in the adult world, some situations that will funnel me some regular contact with interesting people? Should I actively try to take up more normal interests to help me in conversations even if my personality won't change or my Power Level's gonna do me in later anyway? Is there any kind of spin or approach that might make me seem more approachable or easy to talk to so they might be able to take some kind of initiative? I fear that if I keep going like this I'm not going to have a chance later on.
Personally I agree with wanting to be friends with someone before going out with them; I'd prefer to get to know them and find out if I'm interested rather than start with the assumption that I'm interested and find out if I actually like them while dating. So let's start by saying that what you're really looking for ways to make new friends, rather than ways to find that special someone. With that in mind, it sounds to me like you're looking in completely the wrong places. People at bars are generally looking to have a good night out, and if you approach them, they're probably going to assume you're interested in sex rather than getting to know them. At least with Tinder you can find out if they're looking for sex or a relationship first, but then you're jumping straight to dating which comes with the complication of saying your romantically interested before you actually know them.
Just based on "Am I missing something out here in the adult world, some situations that will funnel me some regular contact with interesting people?" I think you know what you should be looking for, you just need examples. I'm going to start by recommending group activities, preferably with people you share an interest with. Groups tend to mean a pre-existing dynamic, rather than you and someone else figuring out how things work as you go; they increase your the number of people you meet compared to one on ones (because no shit); and they mean you don't have to be interesting and engaging the whole time, there's a group to carry a conversation with and bounce off of. I know you say your interests are niche, but if you're in a city, I guarantee that other people will share those interests. I'm a uni student so I have it easy - between tute groups, clubs and societies, occasional camps, and residential colleges, I have a shit load of options for groups that meet up regularly. We just need to find these kinds of groups that you can join.
iirc from the "writers on smogon" thread, you're considering jumping into sci-fi writing of some sort. Have you considered joining a writer's group? I also know you're a mathematician, do you know of any math clubs or competitions in your area? Maybe you're interested in some form of sportsball; joining a club and/or playing is a great way of meeting new people. Run through that list of interests and see if any of them - any! - have groups of people that meet up regularly for them.
I also think it's worth considering interested you might not have realised you have. That's worded funnily for a reason, bear with me for a second. The obvious thing that fits into that group is trying new things - even if you end up not liking them and stopping, you'll still have met people while you were there (I believe the cliche is dance classes, but honestly, just try out anything with groups that meet up regularly), and this gives you the double bonus of being awesome if you actually do end up enjoying it. But this category also includes an interest I know you have, but might not have considered useful: the interest in going out and meeting new people. I met my girlfriend on a university camp before semester started that was designed to help first years meet and have a friend to talk to when they started uni. The reason this worked so well was because everyone there was friendly and approachable - and of course they were, they were on that camp for the same reason I was. So take that list of interests you already have, and then add to it - if you can think of them - the things you take for granted, and see if that helps.
tl;dr - groups for whatever interests you have are out there, you just need to go out looking and not wait for them to show up for you. Don't be afraid to put yourself out there and try new stuff.