srsly why are we only discussing rhydon vs Golbat in making a case for rhydon's "brokenness". this is like trying to make an argument for Ape's "brokenness" by saying it will either kill blissey with CC or set up a NP/SD. show some other things that rhydon can set up on so it's a more convincing argument.
IMO pory-2 should be tested for brokenness before rhydon, since pory-2 is just ridiculous as is.
If Golbat has Giga Drain, it's sole purpose will be to defeat Rhydon. Can't do anything against others, so if you are facing a team with Chansey, or without Rhydon, the Golbat has wasted a moveslot. Same with Marshtomp. Why use Surf, when Waterfall does more damage? If your answer is "to kill Rhydon", again, if the team doesn't have Rhydon you have lost some free power.
Rhydon is way too easy to revenge kill with Scarfers to be broken IMO.
Garchomp and Salamence and Latias and Skymin and all sorts are easy to kill. Even without Scarfs. Hi Weavile.
Ubers:
Rhydon
Borderline:
Porygon 2
Chansey
Dusclops
Magneton
Overused:
Haunter
Kadabra
Electabuzz
Golbat
Monferno
Marshtomp
Croconaw
Grovyle
Dragonair
Shelgon
Metang
Gabite
Seadra
Vigoroth
Pikachu
Piloswine
Roselia
Borderline:
Magmar
Lairon
Sealeo
Wartortle
Prinplup
Grotle
Machoke
Togetic
Pupitar
Nuzleaf
Vibrava
Underused:
Bayleef
Ivysaur
Flaaffy
Luxio
Staravia
Charmeleon
Quilava
Combusken
Lombre
Gloom
Graveler
Poliwhirl
Nidorina
Nidorino
Loudred
Jigglypuff
Clefairy
Pidgeotto
Skiploom
Neverused:
Kirlia
Marill
Metapod
Kakuna
Silcoon
Cascoon
My Tier List :3
Rhydon is banned.
It might have counters, but so did Garchomp and Salamence.
Now, Maybe I should get Magneton and Dusclops of the Suspect list. And I agree with Marill (I didn't know it's Attack Stat was 20...)
However, why put Flaafy as NU without Kirlia there? Flaafy isn't that bad of a trick room sweeper, the only slower ones are (barring the coons, of course) Jigglypuff, Dusclops, Graveler, Grotle, Togetic, Rhydon, Gloom, Marill, and Lairon. The only ones that would actually benefit from the added speed would only be Grotle, Rhydon, and Togetic. Lairon and Dusclops are more defensive, while the others aren't really viable for normal play. It also is the best Electric runner, provided Magneton is banned (which isn't very likely...)
Kirlia, on the other hand, sucks. No offense, Gardevoir and Gallade are one of my favourite pokemon, but Kirlia just sucks. Pitfuller stats. Trick Room may be good, but there are much better options (a bigger gap between Magneton and Flaaffy) like Dusclops.