Another post about Z.
In an attempt to analyze how Z-moves affect balance, I will first analyze damage and it's sources in general.
Balance
Disregarding other elements, such as pokes, moves, abilities that offset the balance, let's assume that the meta is balanced.
Starting off with the barebone pokemon, a beneficial gain of any sort, in this case let's look at damage boosts, offsets the balance and shifts the battle toward the advantage of the side with the gained benefits . What corrects the offset is the cost of the benefits. If the cost is insufficient you usually see the source of the benefit banned in Smogon metagames.
The format will be as follows:
Damage source: costs:
A high damage pokemon: Usually pays for it with low defensive stats, low speed, a detrimental ability, a detrimental movepool, or a combination of those.
A high damage attack: Distribution, negative effects, accuracy, and conditions. More details in this post
Rumplestiltskin said:Distribution:
- V-Create
- Victini, Rayquaza (banned)
- Prismatic Laser
- Blast Burn, Hydro Cannon, Frenzy Plant
- starter pokes, Arceus (no Frenzy Plant, banned)
- Eruption
- Typhlosion, Entei, Camerupt, Torkoal, Heatran, Groudon (banned)
- Water Spout
- Wailord, Jellicent, Blastoise, Octillery, Kyogre (banned)
- Rock Wrecker
- Head Smash
- Aegislash, Aggron, Archeops, Basculin, Corsola, Cranidos, Donphan, Emboar, Hydreigon, Nidoking, Nihilego, Rampardos, Relicanth, Scrafty, Sudowoodo, Turtonator, Tyrantrum
- Roar of Time
- Darkrai, Arceus (banned), Dialga (banned)
- Shell Trap
- Doom Desire
- Psycho Boost
- Deoxys and its formes, Lugia (banned)
- Freeze Shock
- Ice Burn
- Boomburst
- Chatot, Exploud, Flygon, Noivern, Pikipek, Swellow, Toucannon
- High Jump Kick
- Blaziken, Hawlucha, Hitmonchan, Hitmonlee, Hitmontop, Lopunny, Lucario, Medicham, Mienshao, Pheromosa, Scrafty, Tsareena
Negative side effects / accuracy / conditions
- Explosion / Selfdestruct, 250 / 200 BP
- V-Create, 180 BP
- 95% accuracy, Lowers the user's Defense, Sp. Def, Speed by 1.
- Prismatic Laser, 160 BP
- User cannot move next turn.
- Hyper Beam / Giga Impact / Rock Wrecker / Blast Burn / Hydro Cannon / Frenzy Plant / Roaor of Time, 150 BP
- 90% accuracy, user cannot move next turn.
- Focus Punch, 150 BP
- Fails if the user takes damage before it hits.
- Eruption / Water Spout, 150 BP
- Less power as user's HP decreases.
- Head Smash, 150 BP
- 80% accuracy, has 1/2 recoil.
- Shell Trap, 150 BP
- User must take physical damage before moving.
- Sky Attack, 140 BP
- 90% accuracy, charges, then hits turn 2.
- Doom Desire, 140 BP
- Hits two turns after being used.
- Psycho Boost, 140 BP
- 90% accuracy, lowers the user's Sp. Atk by 2.
- Last Resort, 140 BP
- Fails unless each known move has been used.
- Psycho Boost, 140 BP
- 90% accuracy, charges, then hits turn 2.
- Skull Bash, 130 BP
- Charges, then hits turn 2.
- High Jump Kick, 130 BP
- 90% accuracy, user is hurt by 50% of its max HP if it misses.
- Draco Meteor / Leaf Storm / Overheat / Fleur Cannon, 130 BP
- Lowers the user's Sp. Atk by 2.
A damage stat boosting move:
- A turn
- Distribution: Game Freak has mostly reasonably distributed boosting moves with qualities that are proportionate the the poke getting them. Disproportionate or too strong poke + boosting move combination gets banned, example being Xern + Geomancy, while Smeargle stays allowed despite being able to use Geo
- Susceptibility to taunt
- A moveslot
A damage boosting ability:
- The ability slot itself: Arguably one of the most important factors, if not the deciding factor many times in teambuilding, which ties in with opportunity cost
- Distribution
A damage boosting item:
- Band / Specs:
- Choice lock: Facing disable/torment usually means losing. If the conditions change, i.e. if the target changes type, it usually means losing. Detrimental to the partner if locked into an attack that hits the partner. Also potentially locks the user into a non effective attack vs the other opposing target. Prevents setup unless you want to be locked into the setup move. Prevents healing unless you want to be locked into the healing move. etc. Prevents any conceivable strat other than what the initial move provides.
- Expert belt:
- Itemless vs pokes that aren't hit SE
- Life orb:
- Lose 10% hp on use of an attack
- Metronome:
- Requires using the same attack consecutively
- Type boosting items:
- The boost isnt that significant. only boosts 1 type
- In general:
- The item slot itself
- Boost gone if the item is lost
A damage boosting terrain/weather:
- Through a move:
- A turn
- Distribution
- A moveslot
- Susceptibility to taunt
- Through an ability:
- The ability slot
- Distribution
- In general:
- The opposing side gets the boosts as well
- Can be nullified by the opponent setting up a different terrain/weather
A damage boosting partner:
- In general:
- Distribution
- The boost is gone if the partner is KO'd
- Through an ability:
- The ability slot
- Has counterplay in the form of removing or changing the ability
- Through a move:
- The partner basically didnt do anything that turn
- A moveslot
- Susceptibility to taunt
Z:
- The itemslot
- Only applies to 1 type
- Only usable once / game
Analysis:
Looking at everything else shows that everything has costs, costs which are more or less proportionate to the gained benefits.
Looking at Z:
- The itemslot:
- Standard, everything takes a slot in some form.
- Only boosts 1 type:
- The boost to damage is so huge that it offsets the type damage difference, reducing the effectiveness of this cost.
- Only usable once / game:
- Very significant cost. ...In 6v6. This cost forces careful thought into when to use Z, against what, and on which poke to use it, which creates opportunity cost. The cost results in that Z becomes power spike that impacts only a fraction of the battle, which provides ways to play around the fact that someone has "blown their Z" by being able to take on the opponent in standard battle conditions, without Z in the picture anymore. What becomes of this cost in 2v2 though? There will be no need for much careful thought about when to use it other than the 50/50 that arises from "will the opponent use protect this turn?". Not to mention how you don't even need to put too much thought into whether or not you use it against a Protect as the damage can still be significant enough to change the outcome of the battle, and because it means that the Protect user won't be doing anything that turn. Even less need for careful thought as there's no risk of the target switching out. The thought put into what to target is reduced as well, as there's only 2 targets to consider, as opposed to 6. And, once again, way less need for careful thought, into what poke to use Z with as there's only 2 to pick from, which also means way less opportunity cost. And finally, the impact won't be a fraction of the battle that can be played around, but will essentially become the battle itself. There will be no way to play around the fact that someone has "blown their Z" by battling in standard conditions, because you only have the 2v2 matchup at hand and it will have been impacted in some way already, be it that one of your pokes is KO'd or injured, or that an opposing poke has gained some sort of massive boost, with the former being the most usual case. In conclusion, the most significant cost for Z is diminished in 2v2 Doubles, and with it the counterplay.
Costs it lacks:
- As a high damage attack:
- Distribution, negative effects, accuracy, and conditions. This is all while having more base power than than the attacks that are balanced by these costs. This is extremely significant.
- Hitting the partner is bypassed, and if such damage is normally to be used, the user would be choice locked into hitting its partner.
- Low accuracy is bypassed, which ties in with distribution. Accuracy of attacks of different types is distributed to pokes with qualities that are proportionate to the poke getting them, Z takes that balance out the window.
- Negative effects: a drop in the relevant attacking stat or a drop in defensive stats, a drop in speed, or recoil damage very much gives the opponent a means of managing.
- Conditions: Some high powered moves have conditions for the attack, such as doing nothing a turn before or doing nothing a turn after the execution of the attack, which very much gives the opponent a means of managing.
- As a damage boosting item:
- Boost gone if the item is lost
This is a too disproportionate of a cost:benefit ratio. No other means of attaining such damage come near.
Taking another look at
Characteristics of a Desirable Pokemon Metagame.
Balance
Balance
All viable playing options and strategies should be as competitively balanced as possible, in relation to each other.
Explanation:
When any elements of the metagame are considerably better than others, it gives an intrinsic advantage to players that prefer or excel with the superior elements, and handicaps players who are most proficient with other elements. This skews the player base, and hinders the potential to develop new ideas and attract new players. In order to ensure widespread appeal, the metagame should not be unbalanced for or against any particular viable strategy or expert playing option, if it is reasonably possible to avoid.
Issues and Concerns:
- How unbalanced is too unbalanced?
- Imbalance is easy to detect, but hard to quantify
- Balance can be bad, if the balanced level is mediocre or worse
Other Comments:
This characteristic is typically underlying arguments about something being "overpowered". Variety refers to the breadth of aspects of the metagame; Balance addresses the magnitude of those aspects relative to each other. While these characteristics are probably closely correlated, they are two distinct aspects and care should be taken when discussing the merits of each.
This is pretty straight forward. As outlined in the costs analysis, Z is considerably better than other elements in the game by virtue of costs. The explanation part in the quoted post says pretty much everything about this case.
Skill
Skill
The metagame should require knowledge and practice to become an expert player and to achieve consistent success at the highest levels of play.
Explanation:
Although the metagame is based on Pokemon, which has fairly simple basic gameplay, the metagame should require skill to master. The ability to increase proficiency through study and hard work is the hook that draws players to become avid practitioners of the metagame. The metagame should recognize and reward players with the most knowledge, talent, and dedication. All players should feel that it is within their power to "master the metagame".
Issues and Concerns:
- Simple essential gameplay should not be compromised
- Don't add artificial complications to increase skill requirement
- Intellectual and strategic skill, not physical or execution skill
- Do skills erode?
- Ratings systems, tournament formats, rankings, etc...
Other Comments:
This characteristic addresses how the metagame is played, and how success is defined and rewarded. While it can be difficult to truly determine who is "the best" at any given time or in any given competition -- the overall metagame should cultivate a perception (if not reality) that more skilled players will experience greater success than lesser skilled players.
An aspect of skill that ties in with costs is managing options. Z provides a way out of having to make decisions. Examples being:
Setup or boosted damage (through a choice item)? Z -> Both
Protect or boosted damage (through a choice item)? Z -> Both
Hit partner because the move needed hits the partner or use a partner that won't take damage (through ability / type / move) / use a poke that has access to a variant of the move that doesn't hit the partner? Z -> Neither.
You don't need to have much of a plan or strategy to win if you use Z. Just slap it on a poke, have some knowledge about the ability to take a hit or outspeeding, and you're good to go.
In the same vein, pre-Z, a player going in with the same skill would translate to using a choice item, which against skilled players wouldn't pay off nearly as well, considering the counterplay and limits that exist, thanks to the outlined costs. Now I'm not saying that only low skill players use Z or Choice items, only that the strats can already be used successfully enough even going in with minimal skill. The point is that Z reduces the skill required for success. Hence why "the overall metagame should cultivate a perception (if not reality) that more skilled players will experience greater success than lesser skilled players" equates to that Z should be banned.
Variety
Variety
The metagame should have the widest possible variety of playing options and strategies that are viable and competitive for knowledgeable players.
Explanation:
As they say, "Variety is the spice of life". And nowhere is that more true than in the world of gaming. Game makers discovered long ago that players crave diversity, change, and improvement. That's why most successful games are very broad, and are constantly adding new elements. For this reason, a high-quality metagame should be inviting to a wide number of people and personalities. By constantly striving for maximum variety, we can maximize the potential player base, which has the inevitable effect of increasing the number of good players, good strategies, and overall quality of competition. A varied metagame is fresh and exciting, and provides a constant source for investigation and discovery.
If we limit variety, or allow it be reduced, we effectively "shrink" all aspects of the metagame. A game with limited variety is boring to all but the most diehard participants. In a low-variety metagame, the best playing strategies become widely known and predictable, and participation wanes. For this reason, we should constantly strive for as much variety as possible. And, when limits to variety become apparent, the limits should be removed, if possible.
Issues and Concerns:
Too much variety is chaos.
Variety without quality is useless.
No one can master a game with too many options
"Wide" is sufficient, not "widest"
How knowledgeable should players be?
Other Comments:
This characteristic is typically underlying arguments about "centralization", or when people complain about the game being "boring".
The state of variety as it stands is that there barely is any. As pointed out in past posts, the existence, and thus extremely common prevalence due to the superiority of the strat, Z has put extreme offensive pressure on the metagame, which has shrunk and/or altered the other archetypes. The defensive archetype can now only bring the most bulky of the bulky to the table, it has thus shrunk. Other archetypes such as support have been modified so that they also double as offensive forces with power comparable to offensive pokes pre-Z.
In short, Z is an unbalancing force that also reduces skill and variety in the metagame. Z bypasses costs and balance, and an unbalancing force of this degree should be banned if a balanced, skilled, and diverse meta is what's sought after.