They're related to an extent, but you're asking people to defend Home as if Home is awful because of Dexit. Home is awful because it's an expensive service that replaced a significantly less expensive service for unexplained reasons
Well you see, that's the thing
Dexit is awful
because of Home
First, why would anyone get, or even expect a service like Pokemon Home?
because of the expectation that you can transfer your pokemon, otherwise why would such a service even exist?
and the only reason to transfer pokemon is to get
pokemon from previous games
shinies! exclusive moves! mythicals! or just old pokemon you got an emotional attachment for for whatever reason
that's the service
and if you can't transfer your pokemon to a new game? well then the service does nothing
and
that's why Dexit if awful
because without it Home would be expensive yes, but it would actually do
what it was supposed to do give you the ability to use old pokemon in new games
because if you don't plan to do that, why even get your old pokemon to Home then? why even get Pokemon Home then? or even Pokemon Bank?
and if you can only use
some of those old pokemon in new games, and you have no guarantee which ones you can use, or if you might be able to keep using them later on, then that's
a shitty service
here's an analogy for you: you got a bunch of shoes and you're moving, you want to take your shoes with you so a company offers to get your shoes to you on your new home; but only some of them, the rest will be kept in a warehouse where you can't access them
oh but don't worry, the next time you move some of those shoes will be given to you and some of the ones you were originally sent will be sent to the warehouse, which ones? who knows!
that'd be a horrible service
and you should absolutely complain about it
and that's why arguments like "dexit was inevitiblealable" don't hold water, because when Home was announced it
literally promised that we could transfer our old pokemon to newer games ("only some of them in some games but we won't tell you which one shhh it's a seeeecret!" is both bullshit and of course not advertised at the time of the announcement)
because if you realized you can no longer support transfers
why even announce Home in the first place?
unless you knew you could feasibly keep doing it for as long as Pokemon Home remained in service at least
but then it turned out that Gamefreak couldn't make the old models work on time with the paltry 10% of the budget their competitors get
delay the game? hell no! what about the anime and the merchandise? they'll mostly ignore the new games and pokemon anyways but still
cancel Home? hell no! we release it and increase its price by over 300%
people complain?
but game development is haaaaard so we have to make a worse job than other big game studios and even some indy studios do why oh why are you so mean to us our terrible business practices not withstanding?
"but they had to remake to modelz and better animashunz" for what, Pokemon camp? yeah that's true
you know what's also true? few people give a shit about Pokemon Camp
you wanna know what animations people care about? look at Pokemon Legends which came 3 years after the "better animations" line was given
and all these issues,
all of them, would have been lessened if not gone if Pokemon Home had been never announced
because if the Pokemon Company had actually made the decision and said "sorry guys but we can no longer transfer your old pokemon to new games" instead of "we totally made a new service for your transfers (but not really)"
that would have been sad yes, but it wouldn't have been an excuse for misleading statements and abusive services
without Dexit Pokemon Home is just overpriced
with Dexit Pokemon Home is a terrible service that has led to its owners to make misleading statements and alienate its own costumers
and
also overpriced
