shnowshner said:I think this has a lot of potential but is bogged down by making things too complicated and having some weird rules that seem to make it more annoying to play than anything.
First of all: thank you! For taking the time to read and evaluate my submission!
The parts I like are the randomized team structure and "card drawing" aspects, especially because it makes good use of the 24 box size while keeping things manageable. Losing when you drop six mons is something I also like as it emulates the standard ruleset of play.
Quick disclaimer here: not a Pokémon TCG player, seeing a few games is probs the extent of my involvement with the Pokémon TCG. I based this metagame with a mix of Pokémon TCG and Yu-Gi-Oh!, but in the end, this is of course its own game. It's nice to see that I've brought a sense of familiarity to players familiar with the TCG.
Having your available party change every turn sounds frustrating and a bit too chaotic.
So I don't know if this was communicated clearly enough, but the way the "hand" works is that the mons don't shuffle around randomly: they are always in a set order randomly determined at the start of the battle.
So after choosing our Quagsire lead, the game generated this order:
1. :quagsire: 2. :dragalge: 3. :tapu lele: 4. :landorus-therian: 5. :urshifu-rapid-strike: 6. :tangela:
7. :clefable: 8. :regieleki: 9. :pelipper: 10. :tapu koko: 11. :venusaur: 12. :scyther:
13. :blacephalon: 14. :silvally-electric: 15. :heatran: 16. :kyurem: 17. :crawdaunt: 18. :alakazam:
19. :corviknight: 20. :torkoal: 21. :umbreon: 22. :dragapult: 23. :sceptile: 24. :tapu fini:
When a turn ends, the Pokémon in position
2 goes at the end of the line,
3 takes its place,
4 takes the place of
3,
5 takes the place of
4, and so on, so on. So when a Pokémon comes up in slot
6, the player can choose to switch to it for 5 turns before it goes away. This is still strategic, but also ensures a way that the other Pokémon in the deck can regularly show up in the player's hand.
If this was clear, and despite that you still think it's annoying, that's allright.
EDIT 2021-07-09: I have updated the original post to include the numbering on the deck order.
I think it'd be better if every time you switched something out, that mon was sent back into your "deck" and a new mon replaced it. This would add a bit more strategy to switching and let you plan out your next moves with more depth, in my opinion.
This, combined with your proposal of removing the switch limit, would make switching very very frequent. Switching back and forth until you get
that one mon or
the perfect hand would just go against the "randomized deck" aspect the meta attempts to emulate. Unless you're
Daniel J. D'Arby a charlatan, you won't know the entire order of a deck of cards before a game, and if players are just going to spend their game reorganizing their deck... they're not playing, they're inconvenienced. I personally don't want my meta to just be a regular first-to-6-KOs 24v24 where you choose your entire team order at the start: that's just Custom Game with extra steps.
The rules for fainting seem fair; unrestricted switching however should only apply when something faints, that means the benefit of unrestricted switches only comes from having already incured a penalty. Trust me, if it is tied to items or abilities, people WILL abuse it, and I doubt that was your intention.
Fair point: my thought process was limiting unrestricted switch to things that can't be repeatedly exploited (items are consumed, EE only activates once per battle), but I guess I forgot one of the fundamental rules of game design:
"People spam Hadoukens"
The 40 switch limit also feels really arbitrary as a "i dont like stall" implementation. I mean I get it, 24 mons is pretty big for Stall and it definitely has a lot to gain from the metas mechanics, but I still think it is a bit overblown. If anything it might backfire as one of the best ways to beat Stall is aggressive switching. Sadly I don't have any ideas for reworking/replacing this rule, if it were up to me I'd just trash it. If you're that worried about Stall overbearing the metagame I think it'd be best to observe how things play out and look towards banning the most problematic elements (should they arrise) rather than try to add clauses that may not even work as intended. It could turn out that fast-pased games are the norm and all the switch rule does is make you lose a random game every so often because you forgot.
"I don't like stall" isn't the only reason: aside from real deckouts in card games, switching moves like Pshot, Vswitch, Uturn, Fturn and Baton Pass could become common, seeing as it gives you a free switch (with benefits) while also looking at which mon you just drew. Great pivots like Dragapult and Tapu Koko would probably dominate the meta, acting as an effective "pot of greed". Plus, even with the clause preventing chains, I don't think Baton Passing should be free. But I'm down to have a couple tests beforehand to see if it really is necessary.
(sorry for the font change, I can't find the original one.)
Probably my biggest concern would be if this can be coded, which is a very real and unfortunate reason for something to not be possible as an OM. Would be another benefit of simplifying the mechanics a tad.
I agree, coding this wouldn't be a breeze, but I think it is possible. I'm not a coding guy, but I think this might help any devs who could probably look for some implementation ideas:
-Baton Pass clause: Along with baton passing their stat boosts and everything, the baton passer also gives to the recipient a tag called "Baton Passed" that shows under their lifebar (like with stats). A mon with the "Baton Passed" tag can't use Baton Pass.
-Switching clause (or hiding your full party): 1v1 already hides your other two pokémon in the "switch" section when in battle: maybe work from there?
-Deckout Clause: Super Staff Bros. sends chat messages on switch. Maybe use that logic to increase a counter instead of sending a message? The switch counter could probably be displayed in chat when switching (Mike Hawk withdrew Excavalier! (36 switches left))
-Only 6 Pokémon can die: First blood? Also, Staff Bros. sends messages on death too, use the same counter method there?
Anyways, thanks again for your criticism, very appreciated! Hope you have a good day!