A Different Kind of University
Nicholas [surname redacted]
Genre Analysis
In 1996, a Japanese video game company called Game Freak released a pair of games for the Nintendo Game Boy titled
Pokemon Red Version and
Pokemon Green Version. These were the first entries in what would go on to become the second best-selling and highest-grossing video game franchise, being beaten out only by
Mario, and when taking into account spinoff material such as a cartoon series and trading card game,
Pokemon is the highest-grossing media franchise in the world.
Pokemon games build themselves atop a few pillars. The first pillar, as the cartoon’s theme song goes, is “to be the very best like no one ever was.” The main single-player story of each game revolves around the player traveling the region and becoming the champion of the Pokemon League by pitting their Pokemon against those of other trainers in legalized cockfights.
But don’t worry. The Pokemon love to fight. This is completely ethical. Don’t question it. The second pillar, as the series tagline goes, is to “catch ‘em all.” In the player’s quest for glory, they are also tasked with collecting specimens of every Pokemon species, Noah’s Ark style, by capturing them in tiny spheres that turn them obedient.
Pokemon just want to be with a worthy trainer who will help them become stronger. And those spheres are super comfy because techno-magic. It’s fiiiine. This ties back into the first pillar, as in their pursuit for more Pokemon, the player will naturally amass a wealth of options to overcome whatever obstacle the game may throw at them. The focus on collecting takes inspiration from main developer Satoshi Tajiri’s childhood hobby of insect collecting, a detail which will become relevant shortly.
The third and central pillar is player-to-player interaction. Like Newton and his apple, Tajiri had two major inspirations to create
Pokemon. Upon taking note of the Game Boy’s ability to join two consoles with a Link Cable, Tajiri imagined an insect crawling along the wire from one game to another. Additionally, Tajiri was frustrated that he had not found any Mad Caps in his playthrough of
Dragon Quest II, while his colleague Ken Sugimori had found two, with no way of lending the spare. These situations ripe for player cooperation tied in with the second pillar. Each main installment in the
Pokemon franchise is split into two versions:
Red and
Green,
Gold and
Silver,
Ruby and
Sapphire, etc. Each game is mostly identical to its twin, with a few small tweaks. Certain plot details are slightly different, and, most crucially, a handful of Pokemon will only appear in one version. For example,
Electabuzz can only be found in
Red Version, while
Magmar can only be found in
Green Version. Not only does this make it impossible to complete your collection solo, but it also increases the possibility for leverage while trading. Whether it be through version exclusivity or just statistical rarity, scarcity is a powerful economic force.
So the first and second pillars play off each other, as do the second and third, but what about the first and third? Well, a player may find satisfaction in conquering the Pokemon League, but those who thrill for competition will soon find themselves wanting more. The in-game opponents have nothing but their code and their programming. Programming is no match for reason. The ideal opponent must have courage, cunning, and, above all, they must be able to reason. You may protest that no opponent can reason, but my dear fellow, there is one that can.
Overuse of altered quotes from Richard Connell’s
The Most Dangerous Game in an attempt for dramatic effect aside, it’s true that many players find human opponents much more enjoyable than computer-controlled ones. While
Pokemon is ostensibly designed for young children, its battle system hides a staggering amount of strategic depth that goes nearly untouched in the single-player experience. As of the most recent pair of games, there are 890 different species of Pokemon, though only 486 of them are at their full potential (the games count different stages of life, like a
caterpillar,
chrysalis, and
butterfly, or a
cub and
bear, as distinct species, with one Pokemon “evolving” into the next, even though the process is more akin to metamorphosis or puberty). These numbers can even be increased a bit if you want to factor in Pokemon variations (the
Ninetales native to the Alola region are very different than the
Ninetales found everywhere else, for example). That said, variety without meaningful distinction isn’t variety, so each Pokemon has a unique combination of traits across four categories.
Each Pokemon has a set of six base stats, ranging from 1 to 255, that determine its proficiency in certain areas:
HP:
An abbreviation for “hit points,” this determines how much damage a Pokemon can take before it faints. Specifically faint. The Pokemon do not die in battle. Everything is fiiiine.
Attack:
This partly determines how much damage a Pokemon will deal with its physical attacks.
Defense:
This partly determines how much damage a Pokemon will take from incoming physical attacks.
Special Attack:
This partly determines how much damage a Pokemon will deal with its special attacks. There isn’t really anything special about “special attacks.” They’re just not physical.
Special Defense:
Take a wild guess.
Speed:
This determines the order of events in a given turn. More on this later.
Each Pokemon also has access to a portion of the 796 battle techniques creatively titled “moves,” of which there are three categories. Physical and special moves are attacks, with a base damage value that partly determines how much damage it will deal, as well as occasionally some additional effects (Hyper Beam is strong, but forces the user to skip the next turn, while Sludge Bomb may inflict a poison effect on its target that deals damage over time). Moves of the third category are called status moves, which don’t deal any damage. Instead, they trigger a wide variety of effects, like recovering HP, multiplying stats, or directly inflicting nasty effects like poison or sleep. Regardless of category, each move has an accuracy value that determines its likelihood of success, and a PP or “power point” value that dictates how many times it can be used in battle.
Next are the “abilities,” which are relatively straightforward. Each Pokemon has access to between one and three passive traits known as “abilities,” of which there are a possible 258. Like status moves, abilities can do all sorts of things, but unlike moves, abilities go about their way automatically, without direct player input. Examples of abilities include Sturdy, which ensures the user will not be knocked out in a single hit, and Hustle, which boosts the power of the user’s physical attacks, but decreases their accuracy.
Last but certainly not least, there’s type. Each Pokemon has one or two types, out of a possible 18. Each move is also associated with a type, and if a move’s type matches one of its user’s types (a Fire-type Pokemon using Heat Wave, for example) it will deal extra damage. To top it off, a Pokemon’s type may affect how much damage it receives from incoming attacks. For example, Electric-type moves are twice as strong against Water-type Pokemon, Bug-type moves are half as strong against Steel-type Pokemon, and Ground-type moves are completely ineffective against Flying-type Pokemon. The interactions between different types are often compared to Rock-Paper-Scissors, though instead of a simple triangle,
Pokemon has a tangled web.
There’s a reason these interactions are never displayed like this.
Now that all of that background information is out of the way, how do you actually play Pokemon? First, you build your team. There are several restrictions to keep in mind. Out of the 890 possible Pokemon, you must select only six. For each of those six, out of however many moves that Pokemon can learn, you must select only four. And if any of your Pokemon have more than one possible ability, you must select only one. Additionally, you may give each Pokemon one of many items to hold, which will function similar to a second ability, as well as fine tune each of your Pokemon's stats through a series of convoluted systems that we don’t need to get into right now. What’s important is that you have to choose a tiny sample from a vast array of options. Opportunity costs are through the roof, so you’re forced to make tough choices to craft a team that has likely never been crafted before in that exact permutation. In other words, building a team of Pokemon is a complex puzzle that allows for a great degree of creative freedom and personal expression. We’re off to a fun start.
Now that you’ve assembled your team, it’s time to put it into action on the battlefield. Both you and your opponent get a preview of each other’s team (just which six Pokemon were chosen, nothing else is revealed) and select a single Pokemon to start the match with. On a given turn, you have five options: use one of the four moves of your active Pokemon, or swap your active Pokemon out for one of your other Pokemon. Once both you and your opponent have decided which option to take, the turn plays out. Both active Pokemon will attempt to use their chosen move, with the order of actions being determined by comparing their Speed stats: the faster Pokemon will act first, then the slower Pokemon. However, if either player decided to swap, that will happen before moves are used. If a Pokemon runs out of HP and faints, it can no longer be used in the battle. If all of a player’s Pokemon faint, they are declared the loser and the game ends.
From these rules of battle springs a play experience wholly unique to
Pokemon. The best way I can think to compare it to other games is to call it a combination of chess and poker. Like in chess, each game piece has unique attributes, and can potentially be eliminated from play. However, like in poker, information is hidden, and the result of a given turn isn’t revealed until everyone has decided what to do. And like in both chess and poker, predicting your opponent’s strategy while concealing your own is paramount. It all comes together to form a beautiful system of challenging decision-making. You’re pretty sure that you can safely swap in your Water-type to deal with your opponent’s Fire-type, but how confident are you that the Fire-type isn’t packing Thunder Punch? Maybe you should swap to a Pokemon with low HP and let it get knocked out, so that you can then bring in your Water-type scot-free. Should you use Earthquake on your opponent’s Electric-type, or should you use Stone Edge to catch them swapping to their Flying-type? If your gameplan is to soften up your opponent’s team so that your main attacker can come in and plow through for the win, when is the right time to swap in that attacker and go for the sweep? With a risky prediction, or a left-field item or move choice that wasn’t accounted for, advantages can swing in an instant. It’s just… gah! It’s so amazing! Alright, enough gushing. I’m seven pages in and I haven’t even begun to talk about the main focus of this paper.
Because
Pokemon is so ripe for competition, fan communities dedicated to competitive
Pokemon naturally arose. Of those communities, none are as prevalent as Smogon University. Smogon’s goal is to design rulesets such that almost any Pokemon could be used to good effect in at least one ruleset, and such that in a battle between two players, the more skilled player would be victorious. To achieve the latter goal, many of Smogon’s rulesets disallow options that make battles overly dependent on luck. To achieve the former goal, Smogon devised a tiering system to rank every Pokemon.
Smogon’s tiering works as such: every Pokemon starts out in the highest tier, called OU (stands for “overused”). At the end of the month, if players haven’t been using a Pokemon enough, that Pokemon drops down to the second-highest tier, called UU (“underused”). Players now have a choice of two rulesets to play under: the OU ruleset, where any Pokemon is allowed; and the UU ruleset, where Pokemon ranked in the OU tier are banned. From here, the process continues. Pokemon who don’t see enough usage in UU drop to RU (“rarely used”), and downwards to NU (“never used”), PU (allegedly not an acronym), and finally ZU (also not an acronym), until players have six different rulesets to choose from. Think professional baseball leagues, or weight classes in boxing, except placement is based on popularity, which is a decent, if flawed, measure of viability. In addition to dropping unpopular Pokemon, some Pokemon may be banned from a tier if it is deemed too powerful. If one of these banned Pokemon does not see enough usage in a higher tier, it will languish in the purgatory of one of many BL (“borderline”) tiers. However, Pokemon banned from OU are spared this fate, and instead find themselves in the Ubers tier, also known as the only banlist tier that people care enough about to play.
With the choice of seven rulesets added onto the countless options mentioned earlier, it’s easy to become overwhelmed. Thus, Smogon makes use of a specific genre referred to in the community simply as an “analysis.” While the word “analysis” can mean many different things depending on the context, in this particular instance, an analysis is a piece of writing that consolidates useful information regarding a particular Pokemon for easy reference. Because the whole point of analyses is to serve as references, they are formatted to facilitate this. The contents of an analysis are neat and discrete, and all analyses share the same layout, so readers always know where to find what they’re looking for.
At the top of an analysis, you’ll find the bare essentials: the Pokemon’s name, what it looks like, its types, its abilities, its stats, and its tier. These are the kinds of things someone would probably want to know at a glance, so they’re appropriately the first things shown on the page.
Scroll down a tiny bit and you’ll find the “overview” section. This section just consists of a paragraph that summarizes the Pokemon’s strength and weaknesses, as well as what options it has. While the density of information makes it ill suited for a passing glance, it’s perfect for a quick rundown of what a Pokemon does. Once again, this informs its placement in the analysis; while it isn’t the first thing you see, it takes minimal effort to get to.
The next set of sections pertain to the various combinations of options available to the Pokemon. As many Pokemon have more than one viable combination to work with, this set of sections, henceforth referred to as a chapter, will repeat itself until the viable combinations are exhausted. Each chapter begins with a title in big, bold font. Titles are usually short and descriptive, like “All-Out Attacker” or “Defensive,” though every now and then a combo will be notable enough to warrant a unique title. For example,
Snorlax is so well known for using the move Curse that any Snorlax combo that uses Curse will likely be titled some variation of “CurseLax,” while one infamous
Suicune combo is titled “CroCune” in reference to the player “Cromat,” who popularized the combo. After the title comes the combination itself. The details of the combo are listed within a large blue rectangle. The moves are listed on the left, while the item, ability, and stat fine tuning are listed on the right. There’s also a handy “export” button to allow users to easily copy and paste the combo into a battle simulator. As the title and combo are the first parts of every chapter, they are very visually distinct, so it’s easy to tell where one chapter ends and the next begins.
Following the combo are two short sections: one to explain the rationale behind the chosen moves, and another to explain the rationale behind the chosen item, ability, and tuning. They may be short and their purpose self-evident, but they are nonetheless important, as they ensure the reader that the combo was not thoughtlessly thrown together. Following the explanations is the “usage tips” section, which gives the reader tips on how to use the combo. This is critical information, as otherwise the reader might fail to play to a combo’s strengths, and then they’ll be stumped as to why they keep losing. The final section of the chapter is titled “team options.” This section will give recommendations for other Pokemon that have some sort of synergy with this combo. This synergy might be defensive, like with
Mudsdale:
Bulky Water-types such as Lanturn, Jellicent, and Poliwrath can help against Ice- and Water-types like Aurorus and Floatzel, with Lanturn also supporting Mudsdale with Heal Bell and providing momentum with Volt Switch. In return, Mudsdale can absorb Electric attacks for Jellicent and Poliwrath.
or it might be offensive, like with
Talonflame:
Kyurem-B is a good partner for Talonflame because it not only can hit Rotom-W with Earth Power but also can handle other Water-types thanks to Fusion Bolt and Ground-types thanks to Ice Beam. In return, Talonflame can revenge kill faster attackers such as Mega Lopunny and Mega Gallade, which threaten Kyurem-B.
Often times, it’s a mixture of both, as well as other more nuanced synergies. The team recommendations for a given Pokemon will often be very similar regardless of what combo you use, so it might be tempting to argue for placing a single “team options” section near the end of the analysis, but despite the repetition, I think placing one at the end of each chapter was the better choice. Certain combos have just enough variance in team recommendations that a single section would be muddied with specifications, and putting it at the end of the analysis would put unnecessary distance between related information. It’s much better to have all the important information contained in neat chapters.
Interestingly, the format of chapters hasn’t always been this way. Up until relatively recently, chapters didn’t always have distinct sections for explanations and tips. All the information would usually still be there, but there wouldn’t be bolded headings to organize the information within a chapter.
After all the chapters are finished, there are a few more sections left to close out the analysis. First is an “other options” section, which lists miscellaneous move and item options that might have some merit, but weren’t deemed important enough to incorporate into the chapters. Useful, though perhaps a bit extraneous. What’s not extraneous is the following section, “checks and counters.” While the rest of the analysis discussed ways the reader could utilize the given Pokemon, this section discusses how to prevent future opponents from utilizing the Pokemon against you. This section is invaluable for when you realize your team struggles against a certain Pokemon, and you want to make changes to your team to remedy that problem. Fittingly, despite being so far into the analysis, this section is also very easy to locate, due to being the last section made of regular blocks of text. Finally, the last part of an analysis is just a big list of every move the Pokemon can possibly learn. It’s information that is both very space-consuming and also not super important, hence why it’s tacked on at the end.
Because this genre was created to be a reference for information first and foremost, almost every analysis is written in a no-nonsense, matter-of-factly tone. However, there are a few moments where humor creeps its way in. A select few Pokemon are so bad and useless that they might as well be jokes, and their analyses reflect the community’s lack of respect for these weaklings. The overview for
Delibird says nothing in the way of strengths or weaknesses, instead choosing to rant about mall Santas. While the rest of the analysis contains the same information as usual, it’s all written with jeering sarcasm.
Luvdisc gets even less respect. Its analysis abandons any idea of using it for battle, and instead focuses entirely on its possible romantic applications. These nuggets of comedy shine through to the heart of Smogon. To many non-competitive
Pokemon fans, competitive fans can appear cold and robotic, only caring about results. This just simply isn’t the case. The reason Smogon and these analyses exist is because competitive players are having fun. It’s fun to outwit an opponent. It’s fun to devise a clever strategy. And it’s fun to laugh at jokes.
Bibliography
“Ability.”
Bulbapedia.
Albacore. “Talonflame (XY OU).”
Smogon, https://www.smogon.com/dex/xy/pokemon/talonflame/ou/
complete legitimacy and phantom. “Spiritomb (BW RU).”
Smogon, https://www.smogon.com/dex/bw/pokemon/spiritomb/ru/
Connell, Richard.
The Most Dangerous Game. 1924.
Earthworm. “Snorlax (GS OU).”
Smogon, https://www.smogon.com/dex/gs/pokemon/snorlax/ou/
Fatecrashers. “Delibird (BW NU).”
Smogon, https://www.smogon.com/dex/bw/pokemon/delibird/nu/
Kreme. “Suicune (XY UU).”
Smogon, https://www.smogon.com/dex/xy/pokemon/suicune/uu/
Linkpower22 and NJDevil. “What's the origin of the Suicune moveset called CroCune?”
Pokémon Database, 8/2/2011,
https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/42311/whats-the-origin-of-the-suicune-moveset-called-crocune
“List of highest-grossing media franchises.”
Wikipedia.
“List of highest-grossing video game franchises.”
Wikipedia.
“List of moves.”
Bulbapedia.
“List of Pokémon by evolution family.”
Bulbapedia.
“List of Pokémon by National Pokédex number.”
Bulbapedia.
“Pokémon Red and Green Versions.”
Bulbapedia.
“Pokémon: The Story of Satoshi Tajiri.” Narrated by Breton Stripes with illustrations by Kotor.
YouTube, uploaded by Video Game Story Time, 10/11/2016,
“Satoshi Tajiri: How Pokemon Was Made - Did You Know Gaming Ft. Furst.” Narrated by Furst, research/writing by PushDustin, additional writing and video editing by Forrest Lee.
YouTube, uploaded by DidYouKnowGaming?, 11/16/2019,
scorpdestroyer. “Luvdisc (XY PU).”
Smogon, https://www.smogon.com/dex/xy/pokemon/luvdisc/pu/
SergioRules and UberSkitty. “Mudsdale (SM PU).”
Smogon, https://www.smogon.com/dex/sm/pokemon/mudsdale/pu/
Small images of various Pokemon taken from this URL, with the respective Pokemon’s name in place of <pokemon>:
https://www.smogon.com/forums//media/minisprites/<pokemon>.png
Type icons used in the tangled web come from the pages for individual types on Bulbapedia.