KalosianPorygon said:I made a post about Legendary Pokémon. As for who should lose their status, it's a case-by-case thing. For example, I won't be surprised of the legendary birds lose their Legendary status.
But then... How would we call the no-longer-legendary birds?
I don't think any Legendary Pokemon will lose its status as Legendary, but I do think they can be organized into subcategories:
- Ascended: Legendary Birds, Legendary Beasts, Legendary Titans, Lake Guardians, Phione, Swords of Justice, Forces of Nature, Type: Null family, Island Guardians, Kubfu family, Wild Horses
- Exalted: Eon Duo, Cresselia, Heatran, Regigigas, Calyrex
- Revered: Mewtwo, Tower Duo, Weather Trio, Creation Trio, Tao Trio, Aura Trio, Cosmog family, Necrozma, Heroes of Many Battles, Eternatus
- Aloof: Mew, Celebi, Jirachi, Deoxys, Manaphy, Shaymin, Darkrai, Arceus, Victini, Meloetta, Keldeo, Genesect, Diancie, Hoopa, Volcanion, Magearna, Marshadow, Zeraora, Meltan family, Zarude
Though, if it were up to me, I would move the following Mythicals:
- Keldeo into "Ascended" (combined with the Swords of Justice)
- Deoxys, Darkrai, Genesect, Volcanion, & Zeraora into "Exalted" (I'd combine Cresselia and Darkrai into the "Lunar Duo")
- Arceus into "Revered" (combined with the Creation Trio)
Nokocchi said:I mean, the only official title they were ever given as a group in-game was from a Birdkeeper in Gen I who called them the "Winged Mirages", so in a hypothetical situation like the one you implied we could just call them that.
Think a few of the groups which are just known as "Legendary (Thing)" could use some fancier nicknames:
Legendary Birds: Winged Mirages
Legendary Beasts: Rainbow Envoys
Legendary Titans: Gigas Titans
Hugin said:Huh, which 12? Is he talking Gen II alone had all 12 or both gens combined?
(...)
Pig: Piloswine
Rat: Cyndaquil?(there's a bunch of generic small animals, but most of them aren't rats. It's this or Pichu) / Raticate
Ox: Miltank / Tauros
Tiger: Raikou / Persian?
Hare: Azumarill /
Dragon: Tyranitar / Charizard
Snake: Steelix? / Arbok
Horse: Girafarig? / Rapidash
Ram: Mareep /
Monkey: Aipom / Mankey
Rooster: Ho-Oh?
Dog: Snubbull / Growlithe
(...) So if he's talking about both gens, there's something for every slot. (...). But even with both gens, there's a few in there people have debated over what species they actually are for a while. Rooster specifically concerns me.
Bold are my guesses, pretty much went with the earliest "clear" example.
I imagine Ho-Oh is the rooster as it's based on the
Fenghuang, the "Chinese Phoenix" which is a legendary creature in the Chinese-Japanese parts of Asia (it's often used as the counterpart to the Chinese Dragon). It's a composite creature of several animals, mostly of birds which usually includes parts of a rooster's head (due to the chicken's iconic wattle beaks).
NEW Unpopular Opinion: Not sure if this goes here cause I feel a lot will agree with me, well except for GF, but I'm kind of getting tired of the "giant Pokemon" gimmick.
- In Alola we had the Totem Pokemon. First time they made Pokemon big, fine.
- In Galar we had Dynamax & Gigantamax. Main gimmick of the gen, fine.
- In Hisui we have Alpha Pokemon. They're just bigger because it's easy to make a Pokemon special by enlarging its model. Overall felt pointless.
- And now in Paldea we have Titan Pokemon, cause the Path of Legends storyline needed bosses and, like with Alpha Pokemon, its easy just to make a Pokemon bigger than giving it a unique model.
GF, surely you can think of some other ways to denote a Pokemon is special other than by making it bigger than normal, right?