[15:54:44] <%CaptKirby> any 9 inning shutout
[15:54:49] <%CaptKirby> is essentially the same as any other
I guess this mean's Livan Hernandez's 4 hit, 2 walk, 3 strikeout game in April was just as good as Kerry Wood's 1 hit, 20 strikeout game in 1998...
[15:49:10] <%CaptKirby> he is no 9 strikeouts per 9 innings pitcher
[15:49:17] <%CaptKirby> that is a fluke
[15:49:19] <%CaptKirby> the definition of a fluke
Morrow is leading the league in K/9 (10.67). Both his FIP and xFIP are significantly lower than his ERA (4.49 era vs 3.26 FIP, 3.69 xFIP). For those that don't know, FIP and xFIP are "ERA predictors" and represent how well a pitcher has truly pitched, independent of his fielders, which means Morrow has been a hell of a pitcher for the whole of the year. Not exactly a "fluke" type game.
More on the actual game:
http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/index.php/brandon-morrows-gem/,
http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/index.php/more-on-morrow/
In reality, calling this a “bid” at a no hitter does Morrow no respect and the performance on justice. For all intent and purposes, Morrow threw as well as any pitcher who did record a no hitter or perfect game this season. He completed the game, struck out 17 Rays, and walked only two. Nine of the 12 balls in play were of the fly ball variety, including a few warning track flyouts, but the Rays never seriously threatened until the ninth inning.
I used Baseball-Reference’s Play Index with the following query:
- Individual games spanning the 1920-2010 seasons as a starting pitcher
- Requiring at least 17 strikeouts, fewer than three walks, and at least one inning pitched
The reason for including fewer than three walks is multilayered. It trims the list of candidates down while increasing the difficulty level of the performance, thus giving us the cream of the crop. The above mandates returned 35 individual games. Quite a few being repeats of the true greats. One thing I did not adjust that I’ll disclaim here is how I did not control for age.
Randy Johnson’s 20 strikeout game as a 37 year old is included just as
Kerry Wood’s game as a 20 year old.
He dominated the game in every possible way in a fashion done only 35 times in history since 1920. How's that for backing myself up, CaptKirby? Please, stop before you further embarrass yourself.