:greninja-ash: :greninja-ash: :greninja-ash: :greninja-ash: :greninja-ash: :greninja-ash: :greninja-ash:
:greninja-ash: Hey OM community! :greninja-ash:
:greninja-ash: :greninja-ash: :greninja-ash: :greninja-ash: :greninja-ash: :greninja-ash: :greninja-ash:
Introduction
I'm writing this post to make several remarks about the current state of the OMs section, especially in terms of:
- The organization of the section
- Section management and tournaments
- Tiers and councils
- The community in general
This post is for the sole purpose of improving things and is nothing personal. I will therefore make a constructive criticism of things as they are, but I will also try to propose solutions as far as possible. I do not guarantee that this post will not offend anyone by the tone that may be adopted in it, but, with a view to dialogue, it will remain cordial and free of personal attacks on anyone. Nevertheless, my aim remains to get things moving and to make it clear that some things are not right.
I have already personally contributed a lot to the OM community, notably through the development of an important French OM community which is now quite well represented on Smogon. So I finally want to overcome the language barrier to offer what may be my last contribution to OMs and Smogon. I am doing it for this community in which I have managed to integrate and for the good times they have given me.
Other Metagames section
What is an OM?
An OM makes broad changes off a consistent rule (or small set of rules). For example, introducing a new mechanic (Pokemon have the type(s) of their first two moves - Camomons) or providing access (Pokemon can use any ability - Almost Any Ability). Pokemon that become extremely powerful if allowed to have this new element are not granted special accommodation to remain legal by virtue of being exempted from the OM's rules. (i.e. AAA doesn't keep Shedinja legal while denying it the core gimmick of the meta - it just bans the Pokemon).
Well, let's start at the beginning lol. Here above is the definition of what an OM is according to what is written
here. This definition is quite clear and precise so I won't deny it. My question is as follow:
Why are 1v1, ZU and NFE nowadays considered OMs?
With illustration
I think that's a key point that needs to be discussed and clarified.
If ZU and 1v1 metagames are "historical" OMs (which does not justify their place here anyway) what about NFE? What was the idea behind placing NFE in the OM section this generation? Was this decision made in consultation with the community?
Indeed, NFE is a tier in its own right that doesn't really fit into the definition of an OM. The tier also has a community populating its own room on Pokémon Showdown and whose player base is often quite different from that of other OMs (some OM players now play NFE but there are still a large proportion of players who only play NFE).
I obviously appreciate the NFE players that I had the opportunity to meet during the OMPL and respect their community. However, I don't understand the reason why NFE has joined the OMs roaster.
So, is it the fact that NFE has a fairly large player base and that the assimilation of those players could have brought some healthy new blood in the OM community? I don't think that is a valid argument. With that train of thought, any tiers with a "large" player base would be able to integrate the OMs. This is destroying the identity of the community under the pretext that it helps it by bringing in more players.
Is it a desire to bring communities together on a whim? You can't create a close-knit community this way be it on Pokémon, of course, or in the real world. OMs have their own identity and are based on exploiting the mechanics of the game in a different way (change of talent in AAA, change of typing in Camomons, change of stats in Flipped, TS, etc). NFE is based on a tier list and not a mechanic which, in my opinion, doesn't make it an OM (the tier list is the Pokémon "Not Fully Evolved" tier list, which fits well with a "classic" tier ban list). If you consider NFE to be an OM, then why isn't LC an OM? If it's because of the popularity of the tier, then there's an obvious policy problem here.
What I have discussed here is also true for ZU. ZU is based on a ban list that prohibits all Pokémon PU/ZUBL and therefore doesn't fit in any way the original definition stated earlier, and is thus unable to justify its spot in OMs.
1v1 is a special case and I don't know in which "class" it could fit.
This actually leads me to another question that follows from the first one, why did the UMs disappear?
In USUM, the questions I raised earlier were irrelevant because 1v1, ZU and NFE were part of a full-fledged community of UMs. And in my opinion, this OMs/UMs distinction was perfectly appropriate. So, I would like to understand why this section no longer exists.
I propose to modify the OMs section and redefine what an OM is.
In my opinion, the OMs section should include what is not considered an official tier. That is to say tier that do not follow the "classical" rules of official tiers. This includes:
- Anything Goes (tier based on the refusal of "classic" rules)
- Monotype (tier based on a condition and not a tierlist)
- 1v1 (tier based on a particular mechanic)
- Tiers actually considered as OMs (except NFE, 1v1, 2v2 double and ZU) like BH, AAA, etc. (tiers based on new rules/mechanics)
- LC
- NFE
ZU should be considered in the line of "official tiers". It's indeed the continuity of the Smogon tiering system that goes down to PU. I don't understand why this is not the case yet. Is this another popularity problem? I doubt so as for comparison, PUPL has about 200 signed in players, while ZUPL has about 170 signed in players at the moment (early August). I doubt that the popularity argument is in play given the small difference.
LC and NFE are in orange because they can be seen in 2 ways. They can indeed be considered as part of the Smogon tiering system and are in fact included in the official tiers. But one can also see these tiers as a different system in their own right, as there is a restriction other than sheer viability in the selection of what can and can’t be played, justifying the time of inclusion in the OMs.
An OM would then very simply be a metagame that isn’t an official metagame.
Within the OMs a distinction must be made:
- Metagames that are playable on the console or metagames that do not involve a change in the rules of the game. AG, Monotype, 1v1, LC and NFE are included in this definition. These could be called "Unofficial Metagames" (UMs).
- Metagames that cannot be played on a console or metagames that involve changes to the standard game rules. This includes BH, AAA, MnM, etc. These tiers could be called "Different Metagames" (DMs).
Here is a diagram to illustrate:
This seems to me to be the most suitable denomination system. Indeed, at the moment, the distinction between what is an official tier and what is not seems to me to be rather blurry. Here, the official tiers are those based on a system of standardized rules defined by their tierlist (Uber, OU, UU, etc.). The OMs are the metagames based on particular rules that can go as far as changing the basic mechanics of the game (talent, movepools, stats, etc).
Why does this ranking seems better to me?
This ranking is independent of the popularity criterion and therefore allows to gather relatively related tiers under the same banner in a coherent way.
This ranking offers a real identity to the "DMs" community.
Inclusion of important tiers such as AG, Monotype and maybe LC and NFE within the UMs allows to create a community with a meaning and a reason to exist. This can pave the way for a UMPL for instance.
The creation of an OMs community can lead to a new OMPL tournament involving DMs and UMs communities.
In my opinion, the distinction made between what is considered an “official metagames” and what is “not official” is too harsh. It should only be a simple classification under which something either fits or doesn't. That's why I'm against the term “official”/ “not official”. There is nothing glorifying about being in the "official metagames" group, just as there is nothing pejorative about being in the "unofficial metagames" series. It's just a way of arrange things with coherence.
This is, of course, only a suggestion that goes beyond the field of OMs in fact. But nevertheless, I'm convinced that a certain consistency must be maintained in the ranking of the tiers.
Other Metagames (DMs) and tournaments
In this part I will consider as "OMs" what I previously defined as "DMs".
:cresselia: Camomons
Those who know me know that I have made a name for myself in the OMs by my 2 consecutive victories at Camomons tournament in SM. This metagame has been dear to my heart since then and it will be the subject of the following lines.
Why Camomons isn't an official OM?
It's incredible that a tier with a combination of committed contributors, resources and popularity is still not considered an official OM. At the moment, if I am not mistaken, it is the only OM that has an
up-to-date VR (we will come back to this later. edit: in fact no because i'm too late lol).
Euphonos has hosted many events that have helped to keep the tier alive and even produces explanatory videos! Finally, it's a metagame balanced among the most popular unofficial OMs (
May 2020: Camomons - 37516 battles).
Moreover, Camomons was once part of the official OMs in 7G. The tier has also imposed itself in OMPL and WCOOMs in USUM as well as in OMPL this year, taking precedence over the SM BH because of its legitimacy.
With all this, I will be curious to hear what, if any, argument there is against making Camomons an official OM.
If it's popularity then I'd like to say one thing to the people who decided that:
It's not by destroying a community that you develop it! It's obvious, isn't it? However the first argument against Camomons in OMPL was its playerbase. Maybe it was true (though...) but aren't there reasons behind that? Isn't it because Camomons has lost its place in the official OMs/rotational ladder? Isn't it because Camomons hasn't been included in the Other Metas Tour Circuit? What did you do to make Camomons attractive and create a playerbase? Nothing. Quite the opposite, in fact.
So you shouldn't be surprised by a weak playerbase when you obviously don't do anything to create one.
The council also has its share of responsibility in this. The Camomons was until recently a tier without any resources, which lasted throughout the OMPL in particular. Resources are an essential need to help new players learn the tier.
And yet at the moment the Camomons community is well existing and active despite the blows it has been dealt. Perhaps it's time to stop denying its existence and give it a boost rather than rejecting it?
:toxapex: OMPL & OM Snake Draft, a problem of discussion between the community and leaders
The beginnings of the OMPL and OM Snake Draft were a bit chaotic due to decisions that did not take into account the expectations of the community.
I think it's important for the TLs to discuss this kind of event with the community in order to avoid this kind of problem in the future. The role of the TLs should not be to decide everything in their corner. No, the role of the TLs should be to organize the events discussed with the community, propose new projects to keep the community alive and developing, integrate into the community to better understand its expectations, etc.
How can the community be more involved in decisions that affect it?
Apart from the TLs, there are many people who are perfectly capable of taking part in important decisions. Many of them are already moderators of the section or staff on OMs. But that's not all, there are also a lot of very relevant and integrated players in the community who don't hold staff positions but would be quite capable of giving a constructive opinion on certain things. I'm thinking of Jrdn, In The Hills, Andyboy and many others.
In order to make decisions in accordance with the wishes of the community, the leaders can therefore discuss with a small but integrated and representative committee of the community or address it directly through polls, which has already been the case.
I won't stay on this subject any longer because I think that the leaders have become aware of the problem and have recently demonstrated that they want to listen more to the community. So I think that things are on the right track, but we now need to create a real system of community consultation rather than just asking when we are not sure of a decision.
Moreover,
Chloe already mentioned very well in
her post what was wrong with the OM administration so I won't dwell on it any further. I think the message has gotten through :)
:magearna: Innovation, tournaments and ladder
This generation, I feel that there is less innovation to bring new events/tournaments to the community. This is just a personal opinion but I have the impression that this section gets locked into a routine (open, ssnl, ompl, snake) and that it doesn't try to offer something new anymore.
I wasn't particularly present on Smogon in ORAS or early SM but it seemed to me that the section was much more alive and richer than it is today. If the new generation is undeniably one of the causes of this recession, I think it's also due to the OMs section itself.
A section that no longer seeks to innovate and reinvent itself risks running to its doom. So the question is, how do we revive the section?
I don't pretend to be able to answer this question, but perhaps I can suggest some avenues to explore?
Other Metagames Elite Challenge: This is a tournament that has already been offered in the OM FR community (under the name League Other Metagames) and is based on the concept of the Pokémon League.
Concept: Champions are designated in each OM by a team that can do so (here the councils would be able to make this choice because of their knowledge of the tier and its playerbase). The champions must of course be among the best players in the tier for this to be a real challenge. They must also be available enough to respond to the challenges of the participants without having to be available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
The objective for the challengers is to succeed in beating all the members of the elite (without defeat or with at most one defeat).
Each challenger has a single try and if he reaches a defeat or two, he is then eliminated from the tournament.
The first challenger to succeed is the winner of the tournament and the tournament ends (alternative scenarios can be considered).
Variations can be imagined with a master that can only be faced in BO3 if one has managed to pass the elite. The tournament can end once the master is defeated by one of the challengers. The challenger can also become the new master and win the tournament if he is not defeated before the end.
Durée: From one day to 1-2 months. The tournament doesn't necessarily admit a winner.
Exemple: Ligue Other Metagame FR
Ladder tournament: I don't think I'm the only one to have noticed that many OMs ladders are dying this generation. It's complicated to find a match without waiting at least 1-5 minutes. In fact, people lose interest in the ladder and it becomes even more complicated to find a match there. This vicious circle is, I think, partly responsible for the current state of the OMs ladders. Of course we must also take into account the lack of interest of many players for the 8G but also the low renewal of the playerbase.
Comparison
Tiers | Games 7G (2019/06) | Games 8G (2020/06) | Percentage decrease |
|---|
BH | 97060 | 16143 | 83,4% |
MnM | 29451 | 4808 | 83,7% |
AAA | 6548 | 3844 | 41,3% |
STABmons | 3546 | 1210 | 68,6% |
NFE | 19251 | 398 | 97,9% |
We must succeed in reviving the OM ladders. For people who discover PS and who aren't even on Smogon yet (as was my case when I was a beginner), the ladder is the first way to discover a third. It is therefore essential that the ladder is an attractive minimum to hope to attract new players.
Honestly the challenge is not simple and I don't have a miracle solution. Nevertheless maybe the use of ladder tournaments could give a new dynamism to the ladders? If the new generation is undeniably a major cause of this important disinterest, it is not a fatality to which we must give in.
The OMs room is also the showcase for the OMs community on PS and clearly has a role to play in attracting new players. I'll come back to this point below.
Resources are also important in order to help people to get started in OMs and this start is often through games on the ladder. Having more resources means encouraging people to play on the ladder indirectly. But I will come back to the problem of resources later.
Other tournaments:
Smogon focuses mainly on competition/strategy and defines its own framework to promote it as much as possible. In fact, the tournaments offered here are mainly aimed at competition and its outcome, glory. However, is the OM community limited to Smogon? No, the OM community is a whole that also thrives through PS but also on Discord. While I don't want to question Smogon's policy of seeking high level competition above all, I think Discord and PS can offer something different. Especially more "fun" tournaments in which one is looking for more the latter than the glory. Here are a few leads:
Draft League: The players are divided into pools. Each player in a pool must choose a number of Pokémon from a pre-established tierlist to form a team, and this is the pick phase. Players take it in turns to choose a Pokémon from the tierlist, so one Pokémon from the tierlist cannot be chosen by another. Once the quota has been reached for all players, the pick phase ends. Players in the same pool can then compete against each other by matching their team to their opponent's team. The tournament can end with Playoffs where the qualifiers proceed to a new pick phase.
Exemple:
Draft League AAA FR
Survivor: Tournament whose goal is to be the last one still in the running. Classic, you say? Except that the players can actually challenge any of the participants at any time. Of course, it is possible to refuse but there is an obligation to play at least 1 match per week/other duration. A participant can challenge as many participants as he wants as long as the opponents are available and as long as he doesn't lose.
Multi-OMs and no official OM: An unofficial OM can only be played as a ladder every 4 months maximum. However, it is possible to make these tiers live more by means of tournaments on Smogon and thus avoid this very long hollow which does not help the metagames to develop. The OM Mashups are struggling to develop and from the beginning there was only one STAAABmons tournament on Smogon. Maybe we should try to reconsider these unique and very rich third parties?
Exemple: Inheritance, STAAABmons, CAAAmomons, BH Inverse, etc
These events could take place on Smogon but could also take place on the Discord OMs or directly on the PS OMs room. In fact, what I mentioned above concerns partly the improvement of the section but more broadly all that relates to the OMs in general. I note that recently the OM classic and the AAA tournament "Hit It and Quit It Tour" are going in this direction and it's necessary to continue on this way!
Tiers & council
In this section we will focus on the tiers themselves and the role of the council. We have already been able to discuss this a little earlier with Camomons but this was about its inclusion as an official OM and not a discussion about the tiers itself.
As I write this post, Magearna and Cinderace have been banned from the OU very recently. Although re-suspect often takes place in OMs but OU bans are also sometimes applied.
It's not up to the OU players to decide the future of an OM under the pretext that it's OU-based!
I think it's crazy that at the moment when OMs have their own council and their own ban system, they still depend on the OU. Just because an OM is OU-based doesn't mean that what applies in OU should actually apply there. Although based on the OU initially, the tiers OU-based metagame is often quite different from the OU and the arguments for OU-based ban do not necessarily apply in OMs.
For example, Cinderace is not too strong in AAA or Camomons where the metagames are much better suited to its presence. Similarly, Magearna is less effective in STABmons and the strength of its Choice Spec set is weakened in Camomons. If these Pokémon are to be banned in OMs, it must be decided by his council and players on arguments related to tier and not to another.
We need to rethink the link between OU-based metagames and OU.
This link must be based on the beginning of generation because a metagame must be well defined. But this link should not go further. OU and OU-based OMs must evolve independently. Of course, a suspect in OU can have echoes in OMs and councils could discuss what they think of this ban and whether it should be the subject of a suspect in OMs or whether it has no reason to be here.
So far OMs have often acted independently of the OU but this OU-OMs OU-based decorrelation should continue.
OU should no longer apply its banlist to tiers who are often very different. All decisions concerning ban/deban and thus the evolution of the tier be given back to the council and the OM players.
For that, it is necessary to have competent councils ready to do this essential work to make a tier live and lead it to the best. This brings us naturally to the next point.
Are the councils dead? (this post is a bit late because some councils woke up recently but they're late too)
I think it is legitimate to ask the question when AAA has not moved since the banning of Dragapult. The VRs are not up to date and I don't even know if they were readjusted after the banning of Dragapult. The samples are from the pre-home metagame! In MnM the VRs are not up to date for a while too (edit: it's finally the case). The samples are all outdated and each contains at least one currently banned Pokémon (although some council members have posted teams that you could simply put on the post). Balanced Hackmons are exactly the same, VR not up to date and samples not up to date although teams are lost in the thread (edit: very recent update for the latter). These are clearly the 3 big "bad students".
STABmons is doing a little bit well because despite an outdated VR and pre-dlc samples, the council has made decisions and continues to make them. Moreover, the council has shown a willingness to inform players of its actions (
post) which is the right thing to do and should be widely spread!
Finally, NFE and Camomons are "good students". NFE has updated and extremely detailed VRs (compendium role) and specifies that its samples are outdated but that new ones are coming soon. Finally Camomons has very recently (at last) made a VR even if the samples are not yet present.
There is therefore clearly a tier management problem that needs to be reviewed. I'm aware that the idea of having to redo everything or a large part of it after each DLC is a nuisance but it's nevertheless necessary to make the tier live!
Here's what, as a player, I expect from councils:
- An updated VR as soon as possible whenever there is a significant change in the metagame (DLC). And by VR we must understand each other well. No one expects a perfectly detailed VR where all the Pokémon are classified and where there are only small adjustments to be made. No, no one would ask for that on a new metagame that's going to evolve. What I'm expecting from the councils is a provisional VR at first. And I invite you to consult this post which presents a pre-set compendium for the OU. I did not find the post but there was also a pre-VR just after the release of the DLC1 organized in the same way. We're not trying to make a perfect ranking, but any council member knows if a Pokémon will be very good, good or just viable. This first ranking allows us to open a dialogue with the community to prepare a more accurate version of the VRs once the tier is more stable.
- Updated samples too. It's often the easiest way to begin a tier, although I personally find that you learn best by trying it out for yourself and understanding the tier bit by bit. Knowing how to build is essential and proves the mastery of a tier in its totality which also feels in-game. We're not asking for perfect samples from the best teams ever created, just playable teams.
- A regular talk to inform the players of what the council is planning to do. This is essential to maintain the link between the tier leaders and the community and to keep a tier alive. The council can through this small monthly (for example) briefing, consult or just talk with the players to lead the tier to the best. I would like to emphasize the importance of communication between councils and players. If the council is made up of experts from the tier, it does not mean that the opinions of other players do not count. If TLs or council members are no longer able to assume their responsibility, they must resign so as not to hinder the development of their tier. It is better to have a council made up of members who are just good but motivated to keep the tier alive than a council made up of absent top players!
- Being able to judge whether this or that Pokémon/capability/talent is too strong in the metagame (and not too strong is meant offensively or defensively). If metagames are restricted this generation by the number of Pokémon, banning defensive Pokémon that are too strong is not yet restricting the metagame, no, it's opening it up and giving more things to play. You shouldn't be afraid to ban things, or even a lot, in order to create a balanced metagame, not one that's centralized offensively or defensively and fun to play. Communication with the players is also very important in this regard (ie: if no one likes a tier, maybe there is a reason and things need to be questioned in depth).
- Finally councils are an important part of a tier's life. They are often able to launch events to make their tier live and must be force of proposal. Euphonos has done this perfectly with Iron Chief, review & stats Camotour, youtube videos, etc... We don't necessarily ask for as much, but if you like your tier, make it live!
That concludes my comments on tiers and councils. Let's move on to the last step!
OM community
Since I've been able to fit in, I've come to appreciate the OM community very much. It is indeed in my opinion one of the coolest community you can find on Smogon far away from the conflicts and absolute tryhard of some official tiers. So I would like to thank the community for the good times they gave me and I hope it will continue to be a pleasant place where fun and tryhard can be mixed at the right dose.
Nevertheless, it's not easy to become part of the OM community to tell the truth. I personally had this chance thanks to the recognition that my victories at the Camomons tournaments in 7G have brought me. I find it quite complicated to talk to the community in general. I don't know if it's a specific Smogon mentality or American culture but I often see people asking simple questions and nobody answering them. Whether it's on Discord or the OM room for that matter.
How do you hope to make OMs attractive when you simply ignore people you don't know?
There is clearly a communication problem when someone asks a question that everyone, especially the staff, is able to answer but people just ignore it. You can't complain about a lack of players if on the one hand the community doesn't offer the necessary resources for beginners but also doesn't try to integrate new players into its ranks. I'm not making a generalization either. There are also times when help is provided of course.
We need to change this mentality and encourage the integration of new players.
:surskit: Other Metas room
The OMs essentially have 2 showcases. The one on which I'm writing these lines, Smogon, but also the one on PS, the OMs room. It's often one of the top 10 most visited rooms and therefore plays a major role in attracting new players. It is essential for the OMs room to be a pleasant place to learn. Here are some ideas that could improve the OMs room:
- The daily system is not very attractive. Apart from
Dragonillis, I've seen few people really invest themselves in it to get the roomstar rank. I don't necessarily think we should remove this system because I think it's a good idea. Nevertheless, it should be reviewed to make it more attractive and accessible.
- Change the time of the daily or make 2 per day (proposal already mentioned above). At present the daily comes rather late for Europeans, which often prevents them from participating (00AM fr, 00AM ger, 00AM esp, 11PM en, etc). Bringing forward the daily by about 2 hours (or even just one) seems beneficial to me so that as many people as possible can take part. And that would remain quite reasonable for Americans.
- Change the reward. If the roomstar rank is an interesting reward, it remains insufficient to push people to participate in the daily (especially the top OM players). If I don't know what can be given here, on PS or on Discord, I still think we should try to make it more attractive. A Playoffs system can also be a track.
- Maybe classified and reorganize the hall of fame according to the number of daily won. I find it's currently quite unreadable.
- The establishment of a leaderboard. This could be an alternative to the daily system which has the advantage of not posing any time zone problems as the tournaments are launched continuously. Coupled with this leaderboard, it would be possible to organize Playoffs every month between the first 4/8 of the ranking. The winner would get the rank ⋆ and each participant in the Playoffs would get points (according to his final ranking) for the Smogon Tournament Circuit for example (or an independent circuit linked to the OM room itself). Fun tournaments might not count in order to keep some prestige (e.g. Sectiona Servant crazy tournaments might not count lol).
- More access to Smogon resources. When launching a tournament, it would be wise and preferable to post a link to the Smogon thread linked to the tier. This won't necessarily be useful for those who participate in tournaments (although they can actually find samples there and therefore come and try!) but gives visibility to third parties and Smogon via the OMs room. This can be done by hand with a !om or !tiers or by using the bot that could be configured to execute the command itself when launching a tournament. Highlighting resources is a good way to encourage players to get serious about an OM. You might say that "OM Index" already exists on the roomintro but it's not necessarily something you always think of clicking on.
- Communication between staff, contributors and players. This is of course something that is already being done and the staff often intervenes with the players to help them in obtaining information or other. It is therefore necessary to maintain the link between the staff and the community but it's also necessary that the contributors (councils members or OMs contributors) take more part in harmless discussions about their tier. It's important to show that the OMs community is an open community that welcomes and helps newcomers to integrate!
- Innovate and reinvent themselves. It isn't a simple thing but it's certainly an essential point to develop the community. Always look for the best. The community is large and there are many people who will undoubtedly have ideas to develop the OMs room.
Finally the OMs community has one last place that also contributes to its activity and development and this is where we will end up.
:mr-mime:Discord
Discord has indeed become a platform where the OM community thrives. It is one of the main places of exchange and where it is easier to converse with veterans and keep an accessible written record of the conversations. Almost all OMs also have their own Discord on which more specific discussions between veterans of the tier can take place.
Discord should continue to be developed and become more than just a place to relay events on Smogon.
I spoke earlier about innovation. This is quite valid for the Discord OM(s) related to Smogon. Here is a list of things that could be put in place to enhance the usefulness of Discord for OMs:
- Use of bots. This is quite standard on many Discords and especially on those with many members. These can be used for moderation functions but it's more for features like auto-rank that we're interested in here.
The creation of a channel intended for bots commands (in order not to flood other chans) on which members could add certain roles through the bot (principle of auto-rank).
Here are some roles that could be interesting for members:
rank
Tournament matchs to be notified for a tournament battle.
OMPL/Snake/OMFL/... to be notified when an information come on Smogon about a specific event/tour.
Metagame evolution to be notified for a suspect test, QB or other changes in a metagame.
Tier to be notified about an element related to the tier, example @camomons to be notified about a tour, suspect or other things. Councils can also start a conversation on Discord with players to ask an opinion with this highlight.
To name a few, here are some bots that allow "auto-rank": Arcane (via reactions on a message), Reaction roles (idem), Dyno (via custom commands such as /camomons to type on the chat, Mee6 (idem), etc.
The self-assignment of these roles only commits the members and they are therefore completely free not to assign themselves a role if they are not interested or do not consider it necessary.
- Added reward role. Always with a view to making certain events attractive, rewarding roles could be assigned by the staff. This already exists for prestigious tournaments such as Gslam or championship but is otherwise not much seen.
Here is another non-exhaustive list of possibilities:
reward rank
Daily champion/Star (with specific color) to reward the current daily champion.
Past daily champion/Past star (no specific color) to reward past winners
Tournament winner (no specific color) to reward winners of an OMs tournaments on Smogon (open, ssnl, fall, camotour, etc).
Veteran (with or without specific color) to reward a long time player recognize by the community. Less prestigious than legend.
OMPL VIII/OMSD III/... winners (no specific color) to reward the members of the victorious team.
Some can be seen as detail, but adding small cumulative details can make something better.
- Others useful role. [tier] leader, [tier] council,
- Organize interactive events on Discord. This is the main advantage of Discord compared to Smogon and the OM room. It is possible to organize events in a separate channel in an interactive way. This can be anything from a quick build contest to a fun tournament. Discord can be a more open place to launch minor events that don't necessarily need to be hosted by Smogon.
This also applies to tier Discord. Councils have the right to organize small events in order to bring their Discord to life other than through announcements and discussions about the tier.
And I think I've already said a lot of things haha
Conclusion
I have raised through this post many topics and suggested improvements. Of course, it's up to the OMs staff to decide what they think should be done or not among what I have proposed, but the OMs community as a whole also has a right to look at it. If I took the time to make this post (which is the 100th !!) it's only to improve the section and help our community by taking advantage of my experience as a former administrator of the OM FR community and former French/arcade staff.
I personally have no expectations knowing that this final post will end my journey on Pokémon for a long time if not forever. It is therefore not useful to answer this post literally because I won't be able to answer. The answer should be to the community and not to me.
Finally, I thank the community and the people I met there for the pleasant moments spent on the game and especially in OMs.
Special thanks to the guys from OM FR who form a top community for which it has been a pleasure to contribute all these years! s/o to
Altthiel,
Frrf,
LaBalladeDesCieux and
Gmansour20 for their help in english and their comments! Ce post existe en français si ça en intéresse certains ;)
Thanks to those who took the time to read this post! I hope that OMs will continue to thrive and will find their good years back,
Farewell Matiss98,
Siamato ~